A cook sets an iron pot over high heat, tosses in bone-in chicken, and turns it briskly with a wooden spatula. Once the tomatoes go in, they collapse into a red sauce before your eyes, oil bubbles up on the surface, and with a scatter of julienned ginger and green chilies the pot goes straight to the table. Every Pakistani eatery serves chicken karahi, a quick, bold chicken stew named after the pot it's cooked in. It's bright with tomato, sharp with ginger and green chili, and it comes together surprisingly fast.
Chicken karahi and its pot

A karahi is a thick, round, deep pan, a lot like a wok, and any curry made in it takes the pan's name. Cook chicken in it and you have chicken karahi; with lamb or goat it becomes gosht karahi. The word is old: karahi in Hindi and Urdu goes back to ancient Indian languages. In India it is also written "kadai," which is why North Indian restaurants sometimes list the dish as kadai chicken.
Chicken karahi comes from the Punjab, the region that spans Pakistan and India, and it is best known as a specialty of Lahore, Pakistan's second-largest city. Gosht karahi has its roots in the North-West Frontier Province of the British colonial era, today's Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. These days you'll find karahi on the menu at eateries all over Pakistan's cities, from Lahore and Karachi to Peshawar and Islamabad.
While many curries begin by frying onions, chicken karahi is traditionally made without onions. The thickness and sweetness of the sauce come from plenty of tomatoes breaking down. Some versions add onions, but try it first in the onion-free form.
The flavor rests on ginger, garlic, tomatoes, green chilies, and cilantro. The tomatoes break down all at once over high heat and coat the chicken in a rich sauce, so for a stew it's fast, and it reaches the table in about an hour.
Ingredients (serves 4)

Measure the spices from the salt through the garam masala together on a small plate. The black pepper is used only at the end, so keep it on a separate plate and you will not add it at the wrong time.
This dish contains dairy (yogurt). If you have a milk allergy, leave out the yogurt and add a little extra water instead. The richness and mellowness of the sauce will be reduced.
Choosing the pan and ingredients for chicken karahi

No karahi? A wok or a deep frying pan works well, as long as it has a lid that fits snugly. The karahi's round, wide base is there to reduce the sauce quickly, so if you're using a frying pan, pick a wide one, about 12 inches (30 cm) across, so the tomato moisture cooks off fast.
Go for bone-in chicken. Bone-in thighs cut into pieces plus some drumettes are the easiest combination. The savoriness from the bones melts into the sauce and gets you closer to the taste of a Pakistani eatery.
Tube ginger and garlic work, but freshly grated gives a much stronger aroma. For the julienned ginger at the end, cut it as thin as you can, and its sharp bite blends nicely into the sauce.
If you can't find green chilies, use shishito peppers with a pinch of chili flakes. Cilantro gives the finish its aroma, so it's worth tracking down.
How to make chicken karahi
Count on about 20 minutes of prep and about 40 minutes of cooking, about 1 hour in all. Once the chicken starts frying there are almost no pauses, so have everything cut and measured first.
Cook the chicken thoroughly to the center. The US FoodSafety.gov gives an internal temperature of 74°C (165°F) for chicken as the guide for safe cooking. Bone-in meat is slow to cook around the bone, so if you have a cooking thermometer, measure in the thick part of the meat without touching the bone to be sure.
If the bottom of the pot threatens to scorch in step 3, add 2 tbsp water at a time and scrape it up. When the tomatoes are low in moisture, the pot scorches more easily.
Serving, pairing, and variations

Some Pakistani eateries bring the dish to the table in the same karahi it was cooked in. The usual way to eat it is to tear off naan or roti, scoop up the sauce, and work the chicken off the bone as you go. It's also good with plain white rice, and mixing the sauce into the rice brings out the tomatoes and spices.
For more Pakistani meat dishes, try nihari. Both are Pakistani, but the approach is opposite: karahi is finished fast over high heat, while nihari simmers slowly for a long time. Chapli kebab, flat-fried spiced minced meat from the northwest, also goes well alongside.

Swap the chicken for bone-in lamb or mutton and you have gosht karahi. Lamb takes longer than chicken, so give the low-heat simmer in step 5 more time and keep checking until the meat is tender. There's also an onion version: before step 2, fry 2 chopped onions until golden, then add the chicken.
The chili powder and green chilies set the heat. If someone at the table doesn't like spice, cut the chili powder to 1/4 tsp and let everyone add green chilies at the table. That way you can split the heat in one pot.
Frequently asked questions
Can I make it with boneless chicken?
Yes. Cut boneless thighs into large bite-size pieces, shorten the times in steps 3 and 5 slightly, and keep an eye on the chicken so it doesn't turn tough. Always check at the end that it is cooked through to the center.
Can I use canned tomatoes?
Canned diced tomatoes can stand in for fresh. They hold more liquid, so in step 3 cook with the lid off and reduce until the sauce is thick.
The yogurt separated.
Stir the yogurt smooth before adding it and don't let it boil hard afterward; it's much less likely to separate that way. If it does separate, the taste barely suffers, so just keep cooking and finish the dish.

Can I make it ahead?
This is a cooked chicken dish, so serve it soon after cooking. For leftovers, let it cool a little, refrigerate promptly, and reheat in a pot until it is hot all the way through.













