Each bowl of marak goes to the table with a scatter of fried onion and a wedge of lime. Underneath is a clear broth, fragrant with cumin, coriander, cardamom, cloves and cinnamon, and goat that has simmered low and slow until it is tender. It is a Middle Eastern–style goat soup from Indonesian kitchens. You make it in an ordinary soup pot, and the order of additions does most of the work.
Marak in Betawi Cooking
In Jakarta, the cooking of the Betawi people shows Arab influences, and marak is one of their goat dishes. It sits alongside soup made with goat's trotters and nasi kebuli. Within Indonesian cooking, clear goat and beef soups are a familiar family. Soto betawi and sate kambing are other dishes from the Betawi area and the goat repertoire, but they are cooked in quite different ways. For more dishes from the country, see Indonesia.
The method is simple. Chopped onion is sautéed in vegetable oil. Then come a paste of garlic, ginger, galangal and salt, the ground spices, and the whole cardamom, cloves and cinnamon. The goat is stirred through the fragrant mixture until its surface changes color. Water goes in, and the pot settles into a gentle simmer. Carrots, tomatoes and spring onion are added only once the meat is tender.
Other marak recipes look quite different. Marak Lahma parboils the meat, cooks potatoes, carrots and celery, adds tomato paste, and finishes with lemon and optional pineapple. Another cooks 7 oz (200 g) of meat for two with granulated stock and a packaged seasoning. Some versions add potatoes, celery or pineapple, or rely on a packaged seasoning. Those are different soups from this one.
Ingredients: One Paste, Two Sets of Spices, and Vegetables Saved for the End

Equipment
- Mortar and pestle, for grinding the paste
- An ordinary soup pot with room for 1.5 quarts (1.5 L) of water plus the meat and vegetables
- A wooden spoon or spatula for stirring
- A ladle and serving bowls
- A knife and cutting board for raw meat, and a separate clean set for the vegetables and lime
Choosing Goat, Galangal and Spices for Marak
Goat meat. Look for goat sold as food and cut for stewing. Our photos show boneless pieces. Bone-in goat works too, but the 1 lb (500 g) then includes bone, and there is no weight conversion between the two. Either way, judge doneness by the meat, not the clock.
Galangal. Use galangal (lengkuas). It is a different root from the ginger that is already in the paste, so extra ginger won't stand in for it.
Cardamom and pepper. The whole cardamom pods can be any kind you can find. Black or white ground pepper both work for the 1 sdt.
Fried onion and lime. Ready-made fried onion (bawang goreng) is fine. Indonesian jeruk nipis is a lime, not a lemon. Lemon shows up in other marak recipes, and it changes the finish.
For the packaged spices and the fried onion, check the flavor description, ingredient list and allergen labeling before you buy.
Do not taste the raw meat, or the pot while the meat is still raw. Use a separate board and knife for the raw goat, and don't use the utensils that touched raw meat for serving the finished soup.
Fixing Common Marak Problems
Cook the onion, the ground paste and the spices in oil first, so their fragrance is already in the pot when the water goes in. Then let the goat go soft at low heat, and add the vegetables only after the meat is tender.
| Situation | Likely cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| The goat is still firm when you expected it to be done | It needs more time at low heat; how much depends on the cut, the size of the pieces and your heat | Keep simmering gently and check a piece again. Hold the vegetables back until the meat is tender |
| The soup tastes flat and you want more salt | All the salt is in the paste | Wait until the meat and vegetables are fully cooked, then taste before adding anything. Skip a second full measure of salt |
Variations on Goat Marak
Neither swap comes with its own amounts or times, so cook by feel.
- Lamb or mutton instead of goat. These meats soften at their own pace. Judge by the meat rather than by the time goat took.
- Different spices. You can change the type of cardamom or the color of the pepper. Change the spice set itself, though, and the soup moves away from this version.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take?
About 90 minutes in total. The meat is ready when it is tender, and that depends on the cut, the size of the pieces and your heat.
Does it really serve six?
The recipe makes 6 portions. That won't necessarily feed six adults if the soup is the whole main meal.
Why are the spoons written as sdm and sdt?
They are Indonesian measures: sendok makan (tablespoon) and sendok teh (teaspoon). There is no exact spoon volume behind them, so no milliliter or gram equivalents are listed.
Can I use a pressure cooker or stock?
This marak is made in an ordinary pot with plain water. Parboiling the meat and using stock belong to other marak recipes.
How long are the vegetables cooked at the end?
There is no set time. Heat them gently until they are cooked through and as soft as you like.

















