Kjötsúpa: Icelandic Lamb Soup with Root Vegetables and Oats

Icelandic-style kjötsúpa with bone-in lamb, potatoes, root vegetables and cabbage
Cuisine
Icelandic

How to make kjötsúpa, the Icelandic lamb soup, at home: bone-in lamb simmered with onion and herbs, then rutabaga, potatoes, carrots, oats and cabbage added in stages. Covers ingredient substitutes such as turnip and Herbes de Provence, how to judge each stage, and the dish's place in Icelandic food culture.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 5

Bring the lamb and water to a boil and skim

Bone-in lamb heating in a pot of water while foam is skimmed from the surface
Skim the pale foam as the lamb and water come to a boil

Put the bone-in lamb in a large pot and pour in the 8 cups of water. Bring to a boil over medium-high heat. As foam rises to the surface, skim it off with a skimmer or spoon.

STEP22 / 5

Add salt, herbs and onion and simmer for 40 minutes

Salt, Herbes de Provence and chopped onion being added to the simmering lamb
Salt, herbs and onion go in with the lamb before any root vegetables

Add 1–2 tsp salt, keeping some back for the end, then the 2 tbsp Herbes de Provence and the finely chopped onion. Simmer for 40 minutes, keeping the pot at a steady simmer rather than a hard boil.

STEP33 / 5

Add the root vegetables and oats and cook for 20 minutes

Rutabaga, potatoes, carrots and oats being added to the lamb broth
Root vegetables and oats go in together; the cabbage waits

Add the rutabaga, potatoes, carrots and rolled oats. Cook over low-medium heat for 20 minutes. Keep the cabbage aside for now.

STEP44 / 5

Add the cabbage once the vegetables are tender

Chopped cabbage being added once the vegetables are tender
The cabbage goes in last, after the lamb and root vegetables are tender

If the vegetables or lamb are still firm after step 3, keep cooking until they are tender and the lamb is fully cooked. Then add the chopped cabbage and cook for about 5 minutes, or until it is as soft as you like.

STEP55 / 5

Season to taste

Cooked lamb being taken off the bone and returned to the pot
Optional: pull the tender lamb from the bone before serving

Taste the broth and adjust with salt and black pepper.

If you want the soup easier to eat from the bowl, lift the lamb out, pull the meat from the bones on a plate with two forks, and return the meat to the pot.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Bone-in lamb, shank or shoulder 1.5 lb The base of the soup; the bones and meat flavor the broth
Water 8 US cups The cooking liquid that becomes the broth
Salt 1–2 tsp Seasoning; adjust by tasting at the end
Herbes de Provence 2 tbsp The herb seasoning for this version, in place of Icelandic soup herbs
Onion 1 medium, finely chopped Sweetness and aroma in the first simmer
Rolled oats (oatmeal) 1/2 US cup Gives the broth some body
Rutabaga (swede) 1 lb, peeled and cut into large chunks Root-vegetable sweetness
Potatoes 1 lb, peeled and cut into large chunks Substance; how much they break down changes the thickness of the broth
Carrots 1/2 lb, peeled and sliced Sweetness and color
White cabbage 1/2 small head, roughly chopped Added last so it stays distinct
Ground black pepper To taste Finishing seasoning
0 / 0

Bone-in lamb simmers in plain water until it gives up its flavor. Then chunks of rutabaga, potato and carrot go into the same pot with a handful of rolled oats, and the cabbage goes in last. You get the sweetness of the root vegetables, a broth with a little body from the oats, and the whole meal from one pot. This is kjötsúpa, Icelandic lamb meat soup, a soup for a cold day. Icelandic families each make their own version, and this is one home version.

Kjötsúpa in Icelandic Food Culture

Lamb soup, lamb chops and roast leg are the traditional Icelandic lamb dishes, and kjötsúpa is still eaten in Iceland as a traditional dish. For more dishes from the same country, see Iceland.

The soup has changed over time. Older versions were made with lamb, lactic acid and grains, and there was a time when the soup had no vegetables at all. Later versions included rice or oats, and sour skyr made a richer variation. Back then kjötsúpa was a Sunday or Christmas meal. Today it is practical food, kept warm and reheated, and this version follows the modern style with root vegetables and cabbage.

The recipe does not state a number of servings, a total cooking time, or a safe internal temperature for the lamb, so none is given here.

Ingredients for One Pot of Kjötsúpa

Lamb, water, salt, herbs, onion, oatmeal, rutabaga, potatoes, carrots and cabbage
Bone-in lamb, root vegetables, oats and cabbage for one pot of kjötsúpa

This version uses 1.5 lb of lamb. You can go up to 2 lb.

Choosing Ingredients for Kjötsúpa

Lamb. Look for bone-in lamb shoulder or shank. 1.5 lb is about 680 g, 1 lb about 454 g, and 1/2 lb about 227 g. Icelandic or New Zealand lamb is the traditional choice, but any good bone-in lamb works. Boneless lamb cooks fine too, but the broth will have a different depth, so treat it as a substitute rather than the same result.

Rutabaga. If you can't find rutabaga (also sold as swede), use turnip. Turnip is less sweet and gives off more water, so the soup will taste a little different.

Herbs. Icelandic dried soup herbs (íslensk súpujurtir) are the choice if you have them. This version uses Herbes de Provence because it is easy to find, though it won't smell the same as the Icelandic mix. Another option is 1 tsp each of thyme, oregano, parsley and marjoram with 1 bay leaf, used in place of the Herbes de Provence rather than alongside it.

Salt. Salt is given as a range. Grain size changes how salty a teaspoon tastes, so hold some back and finish by tasting.

Equipment

  • A large pot
  • A skimmer or large spoon for the foam
  • A knife and cutting board
  • A ladle
  • A plate and two forks (only if you take the lamb off the bone in step 5)

How to Make Kjötsúpa

About the times

The 40 minutes, 20 minutes and about 5 minutes below are the times for each stage, not the total cooking time, and they don't include bringing the pot to a boil. The cut and size of the lamb change how long it needs, so judge by tenderness as well as the clock.

The lamb goes straight into the pot without browning. There is no oil in this soup.

Kjötsúpa Troubleshooting

Problem What to check What to do
Root vegetables still firm after 20 minutes Chunk size and the variety of potato or rutabaga Keep cooking until tender, then add the cabbage
Lamb still tough when the vegetables are done Cut and size of the lamb Keep simmering until the meat is tender and fully cooked before adding the cabbage
Foam on the surface Whether foam was skimmed as the pot came to a boil Skim when it first boils in step 1
Broth thicker or cloudier than expected Potatoes breaking down, plus the oats That's the oats and potatoes doing their job; a floury potato breaks down more and thickens the broth
Cabbage limp and dull When the cabbage went in Add it only in step 4, after everything else is tender, and cook just until it is as soft as you like
Soup tastes flat Salt at the end Add salt and black pepper a little at a time, tasting as you go

Serving, Storing and Variations

Kjötsúpa with the lamb returned, ladled into a bowl while hot
Ladle the soup into bowls while it is hot

Serve kjötsúpa hot, ladled into bowls so that each one gets lamb, root vegetables, cabbage and broth. Refrigerate leftovers promptly in a covered container, and reheat until steaming hot all the way through.

If you like, you can brown the lamb first. This version puts it straight into the pot.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is kjötsúpa?

It is an Icelandic soup of lamb and vegetables, also called lamb meat soup or Icelandic meat soup.

Can I use rice instead of oatmeal?

Yes, rice works, or you can use rice and oats together. This version uses oats alone, so if you choose rice, use it in place of the oats rather than on top of them.

Sources

  • The Icelandic Association of Washington D.C., "Kjötsúpa – Icelandic Lamb Soup." The recipe followed in this article: ingredients, amounts, cooking order and stage times, the herb and grain options, turnip as a substitute for rutabaga, optional browning, and the note that Icelandic families make differing versions. https://icelanddc.com/kjotsupa-icelandic-lamb-soup/
  • Visit Iceland, "Enjoy Icelandic food." Lamb meat soup with vegetables among Icelandic foods to try, lamb soup as suited to a cold day, and lamb dishes in Icelandic food tradition. https://www.visiticeland.com/article/enjoy-icelandic-food/
  • The Reykjavík Grapevine, "Food of Iceland: Kjötsúpa." The magazine's account of kjötsúpa as a traditional dish still eaten, older versions with lactic acid, grains and sour skyr, and its past and present place at the table. https://grapevine.is/food/2020/03/07/food-of-iceland-kjotsupa-2/
  • Icelandic MAT, "Kjötsúpa: Icelandic Lamb Soup Recipe." Cross-check that modern recipes combine bone-in lamb, root vegetables and rice or oats with cabbage added late; its amounts and times are not used here. https://icelandmat.no/post/kjotsupa-icelandic-lamb-soup