Arsik: North Sumatran Fish Braised in Yellow Aromatic Paste

North Sumatran arsik: fish braised in yellow aromatic sauce, served with white rice and herbs
Prep
30 min
Cook
45 min
Total
1 hr 15 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Indonesian

Arsik is a Batak fish dish from North Sumatra braised in a yellow paste of turmeric, lemongrass, makrut lime and tamarind. Covers heat and substitutes.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Prep the fish with salt and lime

10 min

Coating fish fillets with salt and lime juice for prep
Let the fish sit with salt and lime for 10 minutes and wipe off the moisture, and the yellow braising liquid stays clearer

No heat. Coat 1.25 lb (600 g) fish with 1/2 tsp salt and 1 tbsp lime juice and leave 10 minutes at a cool place at room temperature rather than in the refrigerator. When moisture and odor come out of the surface, press it lightly with paper towel. Rinsing makes the flesh watery, so just wipe.

STEP22 / 7

Crush the aromatic paste coarsely

12 min

Making a coarse yellow paste from turmeric, shallots and galangal in a mortar
The paste need not be too smooth; stop at a coarseness that blends with the oil when fried

No heat. Make a coarse paste of 3.25 oz (90 g) shallots, 18 g garlic, 12 g fresh turmeric, 15 g galangal, 1 red chili, 3 candlenuts and 1/4 tsp Sichuan peppercorn in a mortar or food processor. Don't make it fully liquid; stop when the large pieces of onion are 0.125 inch (3 mm) or smaller and the yellow has spread throughout.

STEP33 / 7

Open the paste in oil

8 min

Stir-frying yellow aromatic paste with lemongrass and makrut lime leaves
Fry over medium-low heat until the oil at the edge turns yellow and the braising liquid is less likely to taste floury

Put 2 tbsp oil in a skillet or shallow pot and warm 30 seconds over medium heat. Add the paste from step 2, 2 bruised lemongrass stalks, 5 makrut lime leaves and the remaining 15 g galangal, lower to medium-low and stir-fry 6 to 8 minutes. Stroke the bottom with a wooden spatula; when the green smell is gone, yellow oil seeps at the edges and the lemongrass fragrance rises, that is the sign to add water.

STEP44 / 7

Make the sour braising liquid

6 min

Warming a yellow braising liquid dissolved with tamarind, with tomato and beans added
Don't boil the liquid hard; let the acidity blend while small bubbles keep rising at the edge

Add 1½ cups (350 ml) water, 2 tsp tamarind paste dissolved in 2 tbsp water, 1/2 tsp salt, 1 tsp raw cane sugar and 1 tomato. Raise to medium heat and warm about 3 minutes until small bubbles keep rising at the edge of the pot. If it boils hard, lower to medium-low, so that the acidity comes out round in the steam and the liquid is an even yellow.

STEP55 / 7

Lay in the fish and simmer quietly

18 min

Laying fish fillets in the yellow aromatic liquid and simmering while spooning it over
Don't flip the fish; simmer over medium-low and spoon the liquid over to cook it

Arrange the fish skin side down and tuck 2.75 oz (80 g) green beans into the gaps. The heat is medium-low, with the surface of the liquid just trembling with bubbles. Simmer 12 minutes with the lid slightly ajar, then without flipping the fish, spoon the liquid over it 5 to 6 times and simmer another 6 minutes. The fish is cooked when the center turns white and clear juice comes from the hole made by a bamboo skewer.

STEP66 / 7

Thicken the sauce and rest

12 min

Arsik's yellow sauce reduced and coating the surface of the fish
Reduce the sauce over low heat and stop at a consistency where the spatula's track stays for a moment

Remove the lid and reduce 7 minutes over low heat. Without moving the fish, tilt the pot lightly and spoon liquid over the surface. When the track made by a wooden spatula across the bottom stays for about 1 second and the sauce thinly coats the fish, turn off the heat. Pour in 2 tsp finishing lime juice and rest 5 minutes, and the flesh settles and the sharp edge of the acidity softens.

STEP77 / 7

Serve with rice

5 min

Plating arsik beside white rice and spooning yellow sauce over
Plate without breaking the fish, with the yellow sauce running a little onto the rice, and it is easier to eat

No heat. Put warm rice on a plate and move the fish over with a spatula so it doesn't break. Spoon 2 to 3 tbsp sauce over, and place the beans and tomato beside. The lemongrass and large pieces of galangal are for fragrance, so eat around them at the table. For those who want more heat, serve sambal in a separate dish.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Prep & substitutes
White fish or oily fish fillets 1.25 lb (600 g) Sea bream, cod, Spanish mackerel, yellowtail. About 1 inches (2.5 cm) thick
Lime juice 1 tbsp For prepping the fish. Lemon juice also works
Salt 1 tsp 1/2 tsp for prep, 1/2 tsp for seasoning
Shallots or red onion 3.25 oz (90 g) Thinly sliced. If regular onion, use the milder inner layers
Garlic 18 g About 3 cloves
Fresh turmeric 12 g If none, 1 1/2 tsp turmeric powder
Galangal 1 oz (30 g) Thinly sliced. If replacing with ginger, up to 10 g
Lemongrass 2 stalks Bruise the lower 4 inches (10 cm) and cut into 2 inches (5 cm) lengths
Makrut lime leaves 5 Remove the center vein and tear
Red chili 1 Seed it for less heat
Candlenuts 3 Replace with 20 g macadamia nuts
Sichuan peppercorn 1/4 tsp Substitute for andaliman. Crush coarsely
Tamarind paste 2 tsp Dissolve in 2 tbsp water
Tomato 1 Cut in wedges. Helps with acidity and moisture
Green beans 2.75 oz (80 g) 1.5 inches (4 cm) lengths. Substitute for the long beans used locally
Water 1½ cups (350 ml) For the braising liquid
Raw cane sugar 1 tsp Rounds the edge of the acidity
Rice bran or canola oil 2 tbsp For frying the aromatic paste
Lime juice for finishing 2 tsp After turning off the heat
Warm rice For 4 Prepare just before eating
0 / 0

Bruise a stalk of lemongrass with the back of a knife and the green citrus scent hits you first. Fry a yellow paste of turmeric, galangal and chili in oil, and before the fish even goes in, you feel a little closer to a Sumatran table. Arsik (Arsik / ᯀᯒᯘᯂ) is a Batak dish from North Sumatra, Indonesia, and its whole job is to move that aroma slowly into the fish. The finished braise is golden and fragrant, with gentle sourness, some chili heat and a faint citrusy numbness that lingers.

Arsik in North Sumatra

Arsik is fish braised in a yellow bumbu (aromatic paste). Turmeric gives the color, lemongrass and galangal give the aroma, and tamarind or citrus brings acidity, all layered with chili. Don't think of it as a dish weighed down with coconut milk. The fish soaks up the aromatic sauce, and rice catches whatever is left. Locally it is often made with ikan mas, a carp-family fish, and it is known as a dish that comes to the table at weddings and ceremonies.

Andaliman is the spice most often named as the mark of Batak cooking. It has a numbing quality close to sansho pepper and a citrus-like aroma, and it shapes the whole impression of North Sumatran food. The other mark is acidity: local recipes call for regional souring ingredients such as asam cikala and asam gelugur. Done well, the sourness pulls the sweetness of the sauce and the fat of the fish together.

Ingredients (serves 4)

Skin-on fillets are easiest to handle. Mixing in a few bone-in fish collars makes the broth deeper, but for the first time fillets that don't fall apart are enough.

Fish, turmeric, lemongrass, galangal, makrut lime leaves and tamarind laid out as arsik ingredients
For arsik, gather the yellow aromatic paste and the souring ingredients before the fish, and the outline of the flavor is easier to set

Allergens and heat

This is a fish dish. If you are concerned about nuts, omit the candlenuts or macadamia nuts and add 1 tsp oil to the aromatic paste to help it hold together. It works without the chili, but increasing the Sichuan peppercorn to make up for heat shifts the aroma, so it is better to let only those who want heat add sambal in their own bowl.

Ingredients That Cause Hesitation When Shopping

Lemongrass, makrut lime leaves, galangal and tamarind laid out in a kitchen as shopping ingredients
For arsik, prioritize aromatic roots, citrus leaves and tamarind rather than the fish

What is worth seeking out specially is not the fish but the aroma and acidity. Buy the fish at a nearby fish counter and gather galangal, lemongrass, makrut lime leaves and tamarind in small quantities, and they carry over to your next papeda or tom kha gai.

Ingredient Priority Reason
Galangal High Ginger alone struggles to give North Sumatra's hard citrus feel
Lemongrass High Rounds the fish smell and lightens the yellow sauce
Makrut lime leaves Medium Gives the braising liquid a citrus outline. Frozen is convenient
Tamarind Medium Easy to make a round acidity close to the local souring ingredients

You don't need to get everything in large bags from the start. For arsik alone, prioritize galangal, lemongrass and tamarind, and add makrut lime leaves if you spot a small frozen bag. Souring with lime alone gets too light, so look for a small jar of tamarind at an import store or an Asian grocery online and flavor adjustment gets much easier. The useful extras are aromatic ingredients easy to move to other dishes after leftovers, Sichuan peppercorn as the andaliman substitute, and sambal to split the heat at the table.

On days you can't find andaliman, a small amount of Sichuan peppercorn moves the numbness in that direction. Buy it whole and crush coarsely just before using, and it keeps a more citrus-like aroma than powder.

Frozen makrut lime leaves have a strong aroma in a small amount, and the rest is easy to move to curries and soups. For people who want a citrus outline in the braising liquid, they are worth looking for after lemongrass.

On days you want to divide the heat within the family, serving sambal in a separate dish is easier than putting too much chili in the pot. Leftover sambal also goes into nasi goreng, sate and egg dishes.

Choosing Fish and Substitutes for Arsik

Outside Indonesia, you'll have better luck sorting out what the dish needs than hunting down every local ingredient. Hold on to four things: the yellow aroma, the round acidity, a lingering numbness, and heat that cooks the fish without you moving it. Use at least two of lemongrass, galangal and citrus leaf for aroma.

Local axis Role Realistic approximation
ikan mas Freshwater fish umami and bone-in stock Thick fillets of sea bream, cod, Spanish mackerel, yellowtail or swordfish. Closer if bone-in
andaliman Citrus-like numbness Just 1/4 tsp Sichuan peppercorn. Don't overdo it
asam cikala Round acidity Supplement with 2 tsp tamarind paste and lime juice
galangal Harder, cooler than ginger Thin slices of frozen galangal. If none, just a little ginger
daun jeruk Aroma of citrus leaf Frozen makrut lime leaves. If none, a little lime zest
turmeric Yellow color Powder is fine if no fresh

Bone-in fish makes a deeper broth, but the first time you make it, fillets that hold together are the safer bet. Sichuan peppercorn isn't a perfect stand-in for andaliman, though it nudges the numbness and aroma the right way. Start with 1/4 tsp for 4 servings and don't let the numbness take over, or the dish starts drifting toward Chinese mala.

Galangal and tamarind are the two gaps most likely to throw the dish off. Lots of ginger in place of galangal turns it into an ordinary ginger-simmered fish, so if you use ginger, cap it at 10 g and add more lemongrass and makrut lime leaves. Without tamarind, mix 1 tbsp lime juice, 1/2 tsp dark brown sugar and 1 tbsp water. This reduces more lightly, so give the dish a longer rest at the end. If lime is all you have for acidity, add 1/2 tsp sugar.

Method: Don't Move the Fish, Simmer in the Aromatic Sauce

Arsik is not a dish to boil hard and flake the fish. Fry the aromatic paste first, then lay the fish in gently at a heat where the surface of the liquid just trembles with bubbles. Spooning the liquid over rather than flipping keeps the flesh from breaking and concentrates only the sauce.

Don't flip the fish

The easiest failure with arsik is not weak flavor but the fish breaking apart. It is fine if the liquid only half covers it. Spoon the liquid over instead of flipping, and keep the heat between medium-low and low. A hard boil splits the flesh and clouds the sauce.

Common Arsik Problems and Fixes

You can spot an under-reduced sauce the moment you plate it: it runs off the fish and spreads like water to the edge of the plate. When that happens, lift the fish out first. Reduce just the sauce for 2 to 3 minutes over low heat, until a spatula leaves a visible track, then put the fish back.

A comparison of watery yellow sauce and arsik sauce reduced just right
Don't finish arsik sauce while watery; reduce it to a consistency where a spatula's track stays for a moment
Symptom Cause Fix
Fish broke apart Boiled hard, flipped midway Next time use medium-low. This time move the large pieces to the plate and spoon sauce over
Floury taste Paste not fried long enough Return only the sauce to the pot and reduce 3 minutes over low heat
Too sour Too much tamarind and lime Add 1/2 tsp raw cane sugar and 2 tbsp water and warm 2 minutes over low heat
Weak aroma Herbs only boiled from cold water Add 1/2 stalk lemongrass and 1 makrut lime leaf and warm 3 minutes over low heat
Fishy Moisture left from prep Add 1 tsp lime juice at the end and increase the herbs a little

Serving, Storing and Nutrition for Arsik

Building a Menu Around Arsik

Arsik is a rich fish dish made for rice. Keep the sides light on oil and lean on vegetables or acidity for contrast.

Dish to pair Reason
Papeda Lets you compare the same Indonesian line of fish and yellow aromatics
Pindang A South Sumatran sour soup that lets you eat fish lightly with tamarind and herbs
Gado-gado Warm vegetables with peanut sauce round out the table
Ayam betutu Easy to compare as a Balinese dish that also uses aromatic paste
Tom kha gai Uses up leftover galangal, lemongrass and makrut lime leaves

Shopping gets much easier when the herbs carry over from one dish to the next. Frozen lemongrass can go into soups, makrut lime leaves into curries, and tamarind into pad thai.

Storage and Making Ahead

Arsik actually tastes better after resting about 20 minutes, once the aroma has worked into the fish. It is still a fish dish, though, so don't leave it out at room temperature for long.

Method Guide Reheating
Refrigerate 2 days In a pot, add 2 tbsp water and heat 5 minutes over low heat
Freeze Not suitable The flesh breaks easily and the herbs' aroma fades
Make ahead Sauce only the day before Fry the paste and make the braising liquid, add the fish on the day

The sauce firms up in the fridge. The microwave tends to toughen the edges of the fish, so reheat in a small pot over low heat if you can. Spoon the sauce over the top as it warms and leave the fish alone, and the flesh will hold together better.

Nutrition Estimate

These numbers shift with the type of fish and the amount of oil. They are per person, based on 1.25 lb (600 g) white fish and 2 tbsp oil, without rice.

Item Estimate
Energy About 360 kcal
Protein About 1 oz (31 g)
Fat About 18 g
Carbohydrates About 16 g
Fiber About 4 g
Salt equivalent About 1.9 g

FAQ

Q1. Can I make it without tamarind?

Yes. Use the lime juice, dark brown sugar and water mix described above. It won't have the round acidity of tamarind, so go easy on the finishing lime and taste before you add it.

Q2. Can I make a mild arsik for children?

Yes. Leave out the red chili and the Sichuan peppercorn. Turmeric, lemongrass, galangal and makrut lime leaves still carry the aroma, so it holds up as a yellow aromatic fish braise without any heat. Put sambal in the adults' bowls only, and everyone can adjust at the table.

Q3. What do I do if the fishy smell bothers me?

Let the fish sit 10 minutes with salt and lime, and make sure to wipe off the moisture that comes out. A hard boil after the fish goes into the liquid brings the fishy smell out, so keep it at a gentle bubble over medium-low heat. Add the finishing lime juice after you turn off the heat so the aroma stays fresh.

Sources