Pindang: South Sumatran Sour Fish Soup with Tamarind

South Sumatran-style pindang: a bowl of yellow tamarind soup with white fish, tomato, pineapple and lemongrass
Prep
25 min
Cook
35 min
Total
1 hr
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Indonesian

Pindang ikan is a sour fish soup from South Sumatra with white fish, tamarind, galangal and makrut lime leaves. Covers gentle heat, substitutes and sambal.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Season the fish with salt and lime

8 min

Preparing fillets of white fish by coating them with salt and lime juice
Leaving the fish briefly in salt and lime and wiping off the water keeps the pindang broth from turning cloudy

No heat is used. Cut 600g fish into roughly 4 cm cubes and coat with 1/2 tsp salt and 1 tbsp lime juice. Leave it in a cool place at 18 to 22°C (64 to 72°F) for 8 minutes, and press off the water that comes out of the surface with paper towels. Rinsing makes the flesh watery, so only wipe it.

STEP22 / 6

Coarsely crush the aromatic paste

10 min

Making a yellow aromatic paste of turmeric, red onion and galangal in a mortar
Don't make the aromatic paste too smooth; stop at a coarseness that blends with the oil when fried

No heat is used. Make a coarse paste of 3.5 oz (100g) red onion, 18g garlic, 10g fresh turmeric, 8g ginger, 10g galangal and 1 red chili in a mortar or food processor. Don't make it a complete liquid; stop when the onion grains are 0.125 inch (3 mm) or less and the yellow has spread through.

STEP33 / 6

Fry the aromatics

7 min

Frying the yellow aromatic paste, lemongrass and makrut lime leaves in a pot
Frying over medium-low heat until yellow oil seeps leaves less of a floury feeling in the broth

Put 1 1/2 tbsp oil in a pot and warm it over medium heat for 30 seconds. Add the paste from step 2, 2 bruised lemongrass stalks, 4 makrut lime leaves and the remaining 10g galangal, lower to medium-low and fry for 5 to 6 minutes. When yellow oil seeps at the bottom of the pot and the raw smell of onion is gone, that is the signal to add water.

STEP44 / 6

Make the sour stock

12 min

Simmering tomato and pineapple in the yellow pindang stock with tamarind
Set the sour stock before adding the fish, and bring out the aroma at a gentle bubble

Add 800ml water, the 1 tbsp tamarind paste dissolved in 80ml water, 5/6 tsp salt and 2 tsp raw cane sugar, and raise the heat to medium. When it reaches about 85 to 90°C (185 to 195°F), with small bubbles continuing at the edge of the pot, add 2 tomatoes and 150g pineapple and simmer 8 minutes over medium-low heat. Don't let it boil hard; aim for a state where the sourness and the aroma of lemongrass mix in the steam.

STEP55 / 6

Quietly simmer the fish

8 min

Simmering fillets of fish in the yellow sour stock over low heat
Simmer the fish quietly over low heat. Boiling hard splits the flesh and clouds the soup

Lower the heat to low, so the surface of the broth just shivers. Arrange the fish skin side down, and simmer 6 minutes without pressing with a wooden spoon. Don't turn it partway; spoon the broth over it 2 to 3 times with a ladle. It is cooked when the center turns white, and if you have a thermometer, when the center reaches 63°C (145°F).

STEP66 / 6

Season to finish and serve

5 min

Spooning the yellow broth over the fish in the finished pindang
For the finish, turning off the heat and resting a little keeps the fish from breaking and rounds the sourness

Over low heat add 20g scallion or basil and warm for only 1 minute. Turn off the heat and rest 3 minutes, and if the salt is lacking add 1/6 tsp, and if the sourness is weak add 1 tsp lime juice. Move the fish to the bowls first, and pour the broth over them. The lemongrass and large pieces of galangal are for aroma, so eat around them at the table.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Preparation & substitutes
White fish or lightly fatty oily fish 1.25 lb (600g) Cod, sea bream, Spanish mackerel, yellowtail. Cut into about 1.5 inches (4 cm) cubes
Salt 1 1/3 tsp 1/2 tsp for preparing the fish, 5/6 tsp for the broth
Lime juice 1 tbsp For preparing the fish. Lemon juice also works
Red onion or onion 3.5 oz (100g) Coarsely minced. 3.25 oz (90g) if using shallot
Garlic 18g About 3 cloves
Fresh turmeric 10g If none, 1 tsp ground turmeric
Ginger 8g A supplement on days when galangal is short
Galangal 20g 10g for the paste, 10g thinly sliced to release aroma
Red chili 1 Remove the seeds for less heat. Omit for children
Lemongrass 2 stalks Bruise the bottom 4 inches (10 cm) and cut into 2 inches (5 cm) lengths
Makrut lime leaves 4 Remove the rib and tear lightly
Tomatoes 2 (about 9 oz (250g)) Wedges
Pineapple 5.5 oz (150g) Bite-size. Drain if canned
Tamarind paste 1 tbsp Dissolve in ¼ cup (80ml) water and remove seeds and fibers
Water 3¼ cups (800ml) Reduce to 2¾ cups (650ml) if using fish trimmings
Raw cane sugar 2 tsp Rounds the edge of the sourness
Rice bran or canola oil 1 1/2 tbsp For frying the aromatic paste
Scallion or basil 20g To finish. In place of the local kemangi
Warm rice 4 servings Prepared just before eating
Sambal 4 tsp Added in the bowl for heat
0 / 0

Strike a stalk of lemongrass with the back of a knife and a green citrus fragrance rises from the cutting board. Then comes the sour broth with tamarind dissolved in it, the yellow of turmeric and the slightly hard scent of galangal. Pindang is an Indonesian fish soup, often linked to South Sumatra and especially Palembang. It doesn't turn the fish into a heavy stew. Instead, sourness and herbs keep it light. Done well, it's a fish soup you'll want to spoon over white rice.

What Pindang Is

Pindang on the table with white rice, cucumber and sambal
Pindang comes together best with white rice and heat on the side, eaten by spooning the sour fish soup over a little at a time

In Indonesia, pindang is the name for dishes that cook fish or meat with salt, sourness and aromatics. It's as much a way of cooking as a single fixed recipe. Local photos and recipes show clear broths, versions with strong chili, and sweet-sour ones made with pineapple. The kind of fish, the souring ingredient and the heat all vary by region and household.

The core of pindang is cutting the richness of the fish with sourness. Tamarind gives a round sourness, tomato adds its juice and pineapple brings sweet-sour notes, while lemongrass, galangal and makrut lime leaves add a green fragrance. There's no coconut milk, so it's much lighter than rendang or soto betawi. It's a good soup for a hot day.

Pindang patin, well known in Palembang, sometimes uses patin, a freshwater fish close to catfish, but home versions are also made with sea fish. Outside Indonesia, you'll get closer to the real taste by keeping the sourness, herbs and heat than by matching the fish exactly. Fillets of cod, sea bream, Spanish mackerel or yellowtail do perfectly well.

North Sumatra's arsik is a similar fish dish, but a rich one: the fish simmers in a yellow aromatic paste. Pindang keeps the broth clearer and puts the sourness forward. Both are Indonesian fish dishes, yet one is much heavier than the other.

Ingredients (serves 4)

The ingredients for pindang: white fish, pineapple, tomato and aromatic vegetables laid out
For pindang, gather the tamarind, galangal, lemongrass and makrut lime leaves before the fish, and the outline of the flavor is easier to build

Fillets 2.5 to 3 cm (1 inch) thick are easy to handle. Thin fillets overcook, and ones that are too thick break up on the surface before the center is warmed. For a first try, skin-on cod, sea bream or Spanish mackerel make the broth less likely to turn cloudy.

Deciding on substitutes

Leave out the tamarind, galangal and makrut lime leaves altogether and you get a sour fish soup of a plain kind. You don't have to buy all three, but to keep the outline of the dish, tamarind is the top priority, next lemongrass and galangal, and makrut lime leaves if you can manage.

Pineapple is a matter of taste. With it, the soup moves toward the sweet-sour of South Sumatra, and without it, it comes closer to a clear fish soup. On days you use the canned, leave out the syrup and cut the sugar to 1 tsp.

Allergies and heat

This is a dish that uses fish. If you make it with oily fish, fat comes out easily, so don't skip the lime in the preparation. For heat, don't put the chili in the pot; serving sambal in the bowl makes it easy to share across the family.

Nutrition guide

The following is a guide per serving, calculated with 1.25 lb (600g) of white fish and 1 1/2 tbsp oil, without the rice. It changes with the kind of fish, the sugar content of the pineapple and how salty you make it.

Item Guide
Energy about 285 kcal
Protein about 1 oz (29g)
Fat about 9g
Carbohydrate about 21g
Fiber about 4g
Salt equivalent about 2.1g

Shopping for Pindang Ingredients

Tamarind, galangal, makrut lime leaves and lemongrass laid out for shopping
For pindang, what you add when shopping is not the fish but the sourness and herbs

The fish isn't worth a special trip. Buy the fish, tomato and pineapple nearby and save your effort for the sour ingredient and herbs that are hard to find. If you have tamarind, galangal or makrut lime leaves left over, use them in arsik, gado-gado or tom kha gai.

Tamarind is the core of the sourness. You can make the soup with lemon alone, but tamarind gives a rounder sourness that goes better with the richness of the fish. Galangal adds a hard, refreshing edge that ginger alone has trouble giving. Frozen galangal can be sliced straight into the pot. Even a single makrut lime leaf changes the aroma of the broth, so a small stash in the freezer comes in handy whenever you make a Southeast Asian soup.

Local element Role A realistic approach elsewhere
Freshwater fish such as patin The fat and bones of the stock Cod, sea bream, Spanish mackerel or yellowtail. Mixing in a little bone-in fish trimmings deepens the stock
Asam / tamarind The core of the sourness Dissolve tamarind paste in water. If none, lemon juice with a little rice vinegar
Lengkuas / galangal A hard, refreshing quality harder than ginger Frozen galangal. If none, use ginger in a small amount only
Daun jeruk Citrus leaf aroma Frozen makrut lime leaves. If none, thinly shave lime zest
Nanas / pineapple Sweet-sour and a tropical feel Fresh or canned, drained. If the canned is too sweet, reduce the sugar

Method: Don't Break the Fish by Boiling

Pindang is not a dish that squeezes out savoriness by simmering fish for a long time. Get the aromatic paste and sour stock ready first, and put the fish in briefly at the end. Keeping the heat at a level where the surface of the pot quietly shivers keeps the broth clear and leaves the flesh of the fish in large pieces.

Avoid hard boiling

What is more likely to go wrong with pindang is not thin flavor but the fish breaking and the soup turning cloudy. After adding the fish, don't let large bubbles come up from the bottom of the pot. Lowering the heat and spooning the broth over the top leaves the flesh in larger pieces.

The sourness can be brought back a little at the end

During simmering the sourness of the tamarind rounds a little. If it is unsatisfying at the finish, adding 1 tsp lime juice directly in the bowl lets you adjust without making the whole pot too sour.

Common Pindang Failures and Fixes

A comparison of a clear pindang and a pindang boiled hard and cloudy
Pindang stays clear when the fish is simmered without moving it over low heat, and clouds and breaks easily when boiled hard

With pindang, the heat matters more than the ingredients. You can have every herb on hand, but if the soup boils hard after the fish goes in, the flesh splits, the broth turns grayish and the sourness drowns out everything else. If the heat is too low, though, the center of the fish doesn't warm through and the aroma goes dull. Make the aromatic stock first at a heat where it just shivers and bubbles, then slip the fish in gently at the end.

Problem Main cause How to fix it on the spot
The soup turned cloudy Boiled hard over high heat after adding the fish Move only the large pieces to the bowls and lightly strain the broth through a sieve lined with paper towels
The fish broke apart Turned partway, or pressed with a wooden spoon Use the broken flesh to spoon over rice, and serve the large pieces on top
Too sour Too much tamarind, or the pineapple is sour Add 1/2 tsp raw cane sugar and ½ cup (100ml) hot water, and warm for 3 minutes over low heat
The aroma is weak The herbs were put in with water without frying Add 1/2 stalk lemongrass and 1 makrut lime leaf and warm 4 minutes over low heat
Fishy Not prepared enough, or the fish isn't very fresh Add 1 tsp lime juice in the bowl and serve a little sambal alongside

Serving and Storing Pindang

How to eat it

Spoon it over white rice a little at a time, adding sambal in the bowl. For vegetables, cucumber, blanched greens or a light stir-fry go better than a rich side. For a fuller Indonesian table, serve it with sate ayam, the sweet grilled skewers, gado-gado, the warm vegetable dish, or soto ayam, the yellow chicken soup. They use the same herbs and sambal.

Storage and reheating

Pindang smells best freshly made, but it keeps in the refrigerator until the next day. Because it's a fish dish, don't leave it at room temperature. Move it to a shallow container as soon as the heat is off.

Storage method Guide Notes
Refrigerator Until the next day Store the fish and broth together. Removing the herbs makes bitterness less likely
Freezer Not suitable The flesh of the fish splits, and the texture of the tomato and pineapple also drops
Make-ahead The broth alone the day before Make it up to the aromatic stock, and add the fish on the day you eat

Reheat it in a small pot over low heat. The microwave tends to toughen the edges of the fish. Warm the broth first, then return the fish for just 2 to 3 minutes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. Can I make it on a day without tamarind?

Yes. Mix 1 tbsp lemon juice, 1 tsp rice vinegar, 1/2 tsp raw cane sugar and 1 tbsp water and use that instead. The sourness won't be quite as round, so taste at the end and add it a little at a time.

Q2. Is pineapple essential?

No. It adds a sweet-sour quality that cuts the richness of the fish. If you leave it out, add 1 more tomato and just 1/2 tsp raw cane sugar to keep the balance.

Q3. Can I make a pindang that isn't hot for children?

Yes. Leave out the red chili and add sambal only to the adults' bowls. The turmeric, lemongrass, galangal and makrut lime leaves still carry the aroma, so it holds up as a sour fish soup without the heat.

Q4. How do I judge whether the fish is cooked?

It's done when the center of the flesh is white and opaque and breaks into large flakes when pressed lightly. If you have a thermometer, aim for 145°F (63°C) at the center. If you can't tell by looking, break open the thickest piece to check.

Sources