Soto Betawi: Jakarta's White Beef Soup

Soto betawi, Jakarta's white beef soup, topped with beef, fried potatoes, tomato and fried shallots
Prep
30 min
Cook
1 hr 20 min
Total
1 hr 50 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Indonesian

A recipe for soto betawi, the white beef soup of Jakarta. Covers blanching the beef, heat control so the coconut milk and milk don't split, local accompaniments, substitutions, storage, common failures, and how to build a bowl with white rice and lime, with step photos.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Blanch the beef

12 min

A pot of beef being blanched, with foam on the surface
Blanch by boiling over medium heat, dropping to low, and rinsing once gray foam appears

Cut 1.5 lb (700 g) beef into 1.5 inches (4 cm) cubes, put them in a pot with 1 quarts (1 L) water and 20 g sliced ginger, and bring to a boil over medium heat. In about 7 minutes it boils and gray foam rises to the surface; lower the heat to low and simmer for 2 minutes. When the surface of the beef turns whitish and the water clouds, drain in a colander and rinse off the foam with lukewarm water. Discard this water. The center of the meat can still be red. This step is not to cook it through but to remove the off smell and excess blood.

STEP22 / 6

Fry the bumbu

10 min

A pot frying the aromatic paste for soto betawi in oil
Fry the bumbu over medium-low heat until the moisture is gone and oil seeps out

Process the onion, garlic, ginger, galangal, candlenuts, coriander, cumin, white pepper and nutmeg to a coarse paste in a food processor. Adding 2 tbsp water makes it easier to process. Put 2 tbsp oil in a heavy pot and fry the paste over medium-low heat. At first it is watery, and in about 5 minutes the bubbles turn fine. Fry for 3 more minutes, and stop when a spatula dragged across the bottom leaves a trail for about 2 seconds and the raw onion smell has turned sweet. If it threatens to scorch, add 1 tbsp water.

STEP33 / 6

Simmer the beef in the aromatic broth

45 min

A pot of beef simmering gently with lemongrass and cinnamon
Keep the beef at small bubbles over low heat and simmer until a skewer goes in

To the pot with the fried bumbu, add the blanched beef, 1.75 quarts (1.6 L) water, the crushed lemongrass, bay leaves, cloves, cinnamon stick, 1 tsp salt and the sugar. Bring to a boil over medium heat in about 8 minutes, and when the surface bubbles, lower to low. Set the lid slightly ajar and simmer about 35 minutes. Keep the heat so the bubbles do not rage; the soup should be a clear-looking brown, with the bumbu blended throughout rather than floating in large lumps. When a bamboo skewer slides into the meat with slight resistance, go to the next step. If still tough, add ½ cup (100 ml) water and cook 10 more minutes over low heat.

STEP44 / 6

Add the coconut milk and milk

12 min

Pouring coconut milk and milk into the beef soup to turn it milky white
Add the dairy over low heat and stop at small bubbles at the edge so it is less likely to split

Mix 1¼ cups (300 ml) coconut milk and 1¼ cups (300 ml) milk in a separate bowl, lower the pot to low heat and pour in a little at a time. After pouring, stir slowly from the bottom with a spatula and warm for 10 minutes without boiling. The guide is small bubbles at the edge of the pot; if the whole surface shakes and churns, the heat is too high. Adjust the seasoning by adding salt 1/4 tsp at a time, and turn off the heat when the soup is smooth and milky white. Boiling hard here separates the oil from the dairy and makes it grainy.

STEP55 / 6

Prepare the potatoes and accompaniments

10 min

A kitchen with shallow-fried potatoes, tomatoes, spring onion and emping laid out
Take the potatoes to a light golden color over medium heat and prepare the accompaniments just before so they keep their texture

Cut the potatoes into 1 inches (2 cm) cubes, soak in water for 5 minutes and wipe dry. Put 0.5 inches (1 cm) of oil in a small frying pan, heat to about 350°F (170°C) over medium heat, and shallow-fry the potatoes for 6 minutes. When the surface is a light golden brown and a bamboo skewer goes in easily, drain the oil. Cut the tomatoes into wedges, slice the spring onions and cut the lime into 4. Emping and fried shallots go limp from humidity, so keep them aside until just before filling the bowls.

STEP66 / 6

Assemble the bowls and add the aroma

5 min

Assembling a bowl of soto betawi with beef, potatoes and tomato, then pouring in the white soup
Pour in hot soup, then adjust the sourness, heat and sweetness at the table

Just before eating, rewarm the soup over medium-low heat for 3 minutes and turn off the heat when it bubbles at the edge. Divide the beef and potatoes among the bowls and pour in about 1½ cups (350 ml) soup per person. Top with the tomato wedges, spring onion sliced to 0.125 inch (2 mm) and fried shallots, and serve emping, the lime in 4 pieces, sambal and kecap manis on the side. Don't squeeze all the lime in at the start; add half and taste. For those who want sweetness, start with 1 tsp kecap manis, and for heat, 1 tsp sambal, so they don't drown the aroma of the white soup.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Beef and soup

Ingredient Amount How to choose
Beef shank or chuck, in a block 1.5 lb (700 g) 1.5 inches (4 cm) cubes. Pre-cut stew beef works
Water 1.75 quarts (1.6 L) Used for the main simmer after blanching
Lemongrass 2 stalks Crush the bottom 4 inches (10 cm) with the back of a knife. If dried, 2 tsp
Bay leaves 2 leaves A substitute for daun salam
Ginger, sliced thin 20 g For blanching
Salt 1 1/2 tsp Adjust at the end in 1/4 tsp steps
Raw cane sugar 1 tsp Rounds off the edges of the soup
Coconut milk 1¼ cups (300 ml) Canned, for cooking. Beverage types are thin
Milk 1¼ cups (300 ml) Whole, unadjusted. Low-fat milk splits more easily
2 / 3

Bumbu, the aromatic paste

Ingredient Amount How to choose
Onion or purple onion 4 oz (120 g) Stand-in for the local shallot. 1 inches (2 cm) pieces
Garlic 4 cloves Minced
Ginger 15 g Sliced
Galangal 10 g If you have none, increase the ginger by 5 g
Candlenuts 3 nuts Substitute 20 g cashews
Coriander seeds 1 tsp With ground, 3/4 tsp
Cumin seeds 1/3 tsp Too much pushes it toward curry
White pepper 1/2 tsp With black pepper, 1/4 tsp
Nutmeg 1/4 tsp Use ground
Cloves 3 Strong aroma, so don't increase
Cinnamon stick 1 stick, 2 inches (5 cm) Added at the main simmer
Vegetable oil 2 tbsp For frying the bumbu
3 / 3

Accompaniments and the table

Ingredient Amount How to choose
Potatoes 2, about 9 oz (260 g) 1 inches (2 cm) cubes. A waxy variety holds up better
Frying oil As needed 0.5 inches (1 cm) deep in a frying pan
Tomatoes 2, about 10.5 oz (300 g) Cut into 8 wedges
Spring onions 3 stalks Sliced thin
Fried shallots 4 tbsp A stand-in for bawang goreng
Emping 12 crackers If you have none, prawn crackers or thin rice crackers
Lime 1 If using lemon, 1/2
Sambal 4 tsp 1 tsp per person, in a separate dish
Kecap manis 4 tsp 1 tsp per person, to taste
White rice 4 bowls Served on a separate plate
0 / 0

White steam rises from the pot, carrying beef and lemongrass. Up to the last few minutes it is a clear meat broth, with a split stalk of lemongrass simmering alongside the beef. Then the coconut milk and milk go in, and the whole pot turns white and round at once. Soto betawi is beef stock and aromatic spices wrapped in that milky white: a slightly luxurious beef soup, served with white rice at eateries all over Jakarta.

A table with the white beef soup soto betawi, white rice, emping crackers, lime and sambal
Soto betawi is a white beef soup to which you add sourness, heat and sweetness at the table

Soto betawi and Jakarta's soups

Soto betawi belongs to the food culture of the Betawi people, Jakarta's native community. Soto means a soup with meat or vegetables, and Indonesia has many of them. Soto ayam, for instance, is a yellow soup of chicken and turmeric. Soto betawi uses beef and offal instead and builds a thick white soup from coconut milk, milk and aromatic spices.

At local eateries, the beef sits in the white soup and comes with fried potatoes, tomato, spring onion, fried shallots, emping, lime, sambal and sweet soy sauce. Some places mix tripe, lung, intestine and tendon in with the beef.

A note on spelling

It is written Soto Betawi in Indonesian. Some places lean on milk, others on coconut milk, and some make a clearer soup.

Dish compared Color of the soup Main ingredients What to keep at home
Soto Betawi White and rich Beef, milk, coconut milk The milky soup, fried potatoes, tomato, emping
Soto Ayam Yellow and clear Chicken, turmeric The aroma of lemongrass and turmeric
Rawon Black Beef, keluak The black soup and beef stock
Rendang Braise with little liquid Beef, coconut, spices The reduced, concentrated aroma

Even with the same beef, rendang cooks the liquid off so the aroma clings to the meat. Soto betawi is the opposite: you sip the soup. The beef should be tender enough to fall apart and the soup rich but drinkable, which is why the stock is made over low heat and the dairy goes in last.

Ingredients: enough for a white bowl to be the main dish

This makes 4 servings, enough to be a main dish with white rice. Beef shank gives a richer stock and chuck gives a softer finish. Beef belly alone is heavy with fat, so for a first batch, use shank or chuck.

Ingredients for soto betawi: beef, coconut milk, milk, lemongrass, spices, potatoes and tomatoes
Prepare separately the ingredients that make the white soup and the ones that add texture at the end

This dish contains beef, dairy, coconut and candlenuts (or cashews). If you substitute cashews for candlenuts, do not use them for anyone with a nut allergy. Check the labels on commercial fried shallots, sambal and kecap manis, since some contain wheat or soy.

If you include offal

If you use tripe, lung or intestine, buy it already prepped separately from the beef, and add it after blanching it thoroughly. For your first try, make the white soup with beef alone first to learn the heat.

Choosing ingredients for soto betawi

What to shop for

Shopping ingredients for soto betawi: coconut milk, kecap manis, cumin seeds and lemongrass
The things hard to find nearby are coconut milk, kecap manis, whole spices and sambal

Beef, potatoes, tomatoes and milk are easy to buy anywhere. The things worth seeking out at an Asian grocery or online are the coconut milk that forms the base of the white soup, the kecap manis for sweetness at the table, and cumin seeds for the aromatic paste. Sambal can be homemade, but if you haven't made the sambal substitute recipe yet, store-bought is easier.

Coconut milk decides how white and round the soup turns out. Leftovers can go into nasi uduk or arem-arem. Kecap manis, just 1 tsp dropped into the soup, adds a sweetness like dark brown sugar, and it also works in sate ayam and nasi goreng, so it earns its place if you plan to keep cooking Indonesian food.

Use only a little cumin. Ground works, but lightly crushing the seeds before frying puts an earthy note between the beef and coconut milk and keeps the soup from tasting too sweet.

Beef, dairy and substitutes

Hunting for offal on your first try will only stall you at the shops. Beef shank or chuck keeps the aroma and texture of the white soup just fine.

Ingredient in doubt Closer to the original Practical option at home Direction to avoid
Beef Shank, chuck and offal mixed Start with shank or chuck only Fatty beef belly alone
Milk A white soup with milk Add whole milk at the end Boiling low-fat milk hard
Coconut Rich santan Canned coconut milk Diluting with a coconut beverage
Candlenuts Kemiri A small amount of cashews A lot of sesame paste
Daun salam Indonesian salam leaf A little bay leaf Several bay leaves, which make it taste Western
Emping Melinjo crackers Prawn crackers, thin rice crackers Thick potato chips

Milk and coconut milk are the pairing to handle most carefully. Milk alone makes a light soup, and coconut milk alone makes it sweet and heavy, so start with half and half and adjust toward your taste next time.

Emping is a thin, slightly bitter cracker made from melinjo nuts. It can be hard to find; thin rice crackers or prawn crackers give you the crunch instead, and shallow-fried potatoes help too on days without it.

Method: keep it from splitting and make the beef tender

Failures with soto betawi gather into three: tough beef, a raw-tasting aromatic paste, and a white soup that splits. Blanch the beef to remove its off smell, simmer the main cook over low heat, and add the dairy last without boiling hard.

A guide to keeping the white soup from splitting

The most important thing for a milky soup is not to boil it hard. Small bubbles at the edge of the pot, steam rising, and the whole thing moving smoothly when stirred with a spatula: stop at that state. If it keeps boiling, a large ring of oil floats to the surface and the texture turns grainy.

What goes wrong with soto betawi

A comparison of smooth white soto betawi soup and a split soup
Smoothness matters in the white soup. If it splits, lower the heat and stir, and next time add the dairy last
Problem Main cause Fix
Tough beef Not simmered long enough, or the heat was too high and the liquid cooked off Add ½ cup (100 ml) water and extend over low heat in 10-minute steps
Thin soup The main simmer after blanching was too short Return the beef and add 10 minutes over low heat before adding the dairy
Soup splits Milk and coconut milk were boiled hard Turn off the heat and stir slowly; next time add them last over low heat
Tastes like curry Too much cumin or coriander Next time return to 1/3 tsp cumin, centered on nutmeg and white pepper
Too heavy Too much beef belly and coconut milk Focus on shank and increase the milk slightly
Weak aroma Bumbu under-fried, lemongrass not crushed Fry the aromatic oil 3 more minutes over medium-low heat and return it to the soup

When the flavor seems vague, squeeze in a little lime before reaching for more salt. Fat and dairy make the soup round, and a bit of sourness suddenly gives it an outline. Add sambal in the bowl rather than the pot, so everyone at the table can set their own heat.

Serving, storing and reheating soto betawi

Soto betawi broth and toppings separated into different containers in a kitchen
Storing the soup, potatoes, tomato and aromatic toppings separately keeps the texture the next day

Store the soup and beef together, and keep the potatoes, tomato, fried shallots and emping separate. Mixed together, the potatoes fall apart, the emping goes limp and the tomato waters down the flavor. The soup and beef keep 2 days refrigerated and 3 weeks frozen.

Chilled soup forms a white film as the fat sets, but it melts back in when warmed slowly in a small pot over medium-low heat. In a 600 W microwave, heat one bowl for 2 minutes, stir, and add 30 seconds. Stop at small bubbles at the edge of the pot; a hard boil makes it split.

The next day, it's easy to pour over rice as soto rice. If it tastes too strong, add 2 tbsp water or milk and a squeeze of lime. For an Indonesian spread, gado-gado, which takes extra vegetables, or the fragrant rice nasi uduk keeps things lighter than the sweet-spicy mie goreng.

Per serving (approx.) Value
Energy about 610 kcal
Protein about 1.25 oz (32 g)
Fat about 1.5 oz (39 g)
Carbohydrate about 1.25 oz (33 g)
Fiber about 3 g
Salt equivalent about 3.2 g

A bowl of white rice raises the carbohydrates and calories. If the fat bothers you, skip beef belly and use shank, and trim the fried potato. Cut back too far on milk and coconut milk and you lose the soup's white roundness.

FAQ

Can I make it without milk?

Yes. Add 1¾ cups (400 ml) coconut milk and ½ cup (100 ml) water, and finish it as a slightly heavier soup. The "white yet light" mouthfeel typical of soto betawi comes more easily with milk, though. If you are avoiding dairy, add a little more lime and tomato to cut the heaviness.

Is it not authentic without offal?

Beef alone is perfectly good. Many places include offal, but for a first try, focus on the beef, white soup, fried potatoes, tomato, emping and lime. Next time, add a small amount of prepped tripe or beef tendon.

If the coconut milk splits, do I have to throw it away?

No. Turn off the heat, stir slowly with a spatula, and add 2 tbsp milk a little at a time; the texture comes back somewhat. It won't be completely smooth, but it is still good to eat.

Do the potatoes have to be fried?

Shallow-frying holds them together best; boiled potatoes fall apart in the soup and give a weak texture. To use less oil, microwave 1 inches (2 cm) potato cubes at 600 W for 3 minutes, toss with 2 tsp oil and pan-fry over medium heat for 4 minutes.

What Indonesian dishes go with it?

Gado-gado as a side, nasi uduk as the staple and sate ayam as a grilled dish all fit easily. Save soto ayam for another day; the difference shows better than side by side.

Sources