Papeda: Sago Porridge from Maluku and Papua with Yellow Fish Soup

A table in Maluku and Papua with translucent sago porridge papeda and yellow fish soup
Prep
25 min
Cook
35 min
Total
1 hr
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Indonesian

How to make papeda, the sago porridge loved in Maluku and Papua: sago starch versus tapioca, how to stir it clear, the yellow fish soup, substitutes for lemongrass and makrut lime leaves, how it is eaten locally, what goes wrong, shopping, and reheating the next day.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Loosen the sago in water

5 min

Making a white slurry from sago starch and cold water
Loosen the sago in cold water first. Putting it straight into boiling water leaves white lumps

No heat is used.

Add 1 cups (250 ml) water, 1/2 tsp salt and 1/2 tsp sugar to 4 oz (120 g) sago starch and mix with a whisk until no white grains show. The starch settles at the bottom easily, so scrape the bottom once with a spatula. It is ready when it is a smooth, milk-like liquid and no lumps remain that you can feel when you press them with a finger.

STEP22 / 7

Make the yellow spice paste

8 min

Pounding turmeric, shallots and candlenuts into a yellow paste in a mortar
The paste can be coarse, but crush until turmeric and shallot are evenly mixed

No heat is used.

Make a coarse paste of 2.75 oz (80 g) shallots, 20 g garlic, 20 g candlenuts, 8 g turmeric, 12 g ginger and 1 red chili in a mortar or food processor. Don't make it fully liquid; stop while some fine grains remain. It is enough when the yellow is even and no large pieces of onion remain.

STEP33 / 7

Fry the spice paste

7 min

Frying the yellow spice paste with lemongrass and makrut lime leaves
Frying over medium-low heat until the oil turns yellow keeps the soup from tasting floury

Put 2 tbsp oil in a pot over medium-low heat, and add the spice paste, 2 bruised lemongrass stalks, 4 makrut lime leaves and 1 bay leaf. Fry, stroking the bottom of the pot with a wooden spoon, for 5–7 minutes over medium-low heat. When the first raw smell has gone, the edge of the oil bleeds yellow and the lemongrass aroma rises, it is time to add water. Move on before any burnt brown shows.

STEP44 / 7

Simmer the fish in the yellow soup

12 min

Quietly simmering fish and tomato in the yellow fish soup
Don't boil the fish hard; keep it over medium-low heat where the surface just shimmers so it holds its shape

Bring 3 cups (700 ml) water, 1 tsp sugar and 1 tsp salt to a boil over medium heat. Coat 1 lb (450 g) fish with 1 tbsp lime juice and 1/2 tsp salt and leave 10 minutes, pat lightly dry, and add to the pot. Lower to medium-low and keep it at a gentle shimmer on the surface for 8 minutes. Just before the center of the fish turns white and the flesh begins to flake, add the tomatoes and scallions and warm 2 more minutes. Bring it to a boil over medium heat, then keep it at a simmer over medium-low once the fish is in.

STEP55 / 7

Pour the sago liquid into boiling water

4 min

Pouring white sago liquid a little at a time into boiling water
Pour the sago liquid in thin and stir at once so no white layer forms on the bottom

Boil 3½ cups (850 ml) water in a separate pot, then lower from medium-high to medium. Pour in the sago liquid from step 1 in a thin stream. As you pour, stir in one direction with a wooden spoon so the white liquid doesn't collect on the bottom. After about 30 seconds, when the edges turn translucent, the trail of the spoon doesn't fill with white liquid right away, and the whole thing starts to connect smoothly like a loose kudzu pudding, lower the heat to medium-low. Keep it at small steady bubbles on the bottom of the pot, between medium-high and medium.

STEP66 / 7

Stir until clear and stretchy

8 min

Stirring clear papeda with a wooden spoon, the stickiness stretching into a ribbon
Stir until the white is gone and it looks clear, and stop when it stretches thick from the spoon

Keep stirring in big strokes from the bottom for 5 minutes over medium-low heat. As long as cloudy white parts remain, the starch isn't cooked yet. When everything has gone a grayish translucent and lifting the spoon pulls the porridge into a thick ribbon, lower the heat and stir another 2–3 minutes over low heat. If white lumps show at the bottom, don't turn off the heat; press the lumps flat and stir them in.

STEP77 / 7

Wind it up and join it with the soup

3 min

Winding papeda with chopsticks and plating it with yellow fish soup
Wind the papeda with chopsticks and sink it in hot yellow fish soup to eat

Turn off the heat and keep the soup hot. With two chopsticks or a wooden spoon, wind up the papeda. Put it on a plate and ladle the yellow fish soup beside it. At the end add 1 tbsp lime juice to the soup and scatter lemon basil or shiso. Papeda turns heavy as it cools, so wind it up just before it goes to the table. Set sambal and krupuk on separate dishes so each person adjusts heat and texture.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Papeda

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Sago starch 4 oz (120 g) If you can't get it, 4 oz (120 g) tapioca starch
Water 1.25 quarts (1.1 L) 1 cups (250 ml) for dissolving the starch, 3½ cups (850 ml) for cooking
Salt 1/2 tsp Lightly seasons the porridge
Light brown sugar 1/2 tsp Optional. Rounds off the edge of the starch
2 / 2

Fish kuah kuning

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Cooking-grade white fish, swordfish or yellowfin tuna 1 lb (450 g) 1 inches (3 cm) cubes. If bone-in, cut larger
Lime juice 1 tbsp Lemon juice works. To season the fish
Salt 1/2 tsp To season the fish
Vegetable oil 2 tbsp To fry the spice paste
Shallots 2.75 oz (80 g) 2 oz (60 g) red onion can stand in
Garlic 20 g About 4 cloves
Candlenuts 20 g 20 g cashews can stand in
Turmeric 8 g 1 inches (2 cm) if fresh, 1 tsp if ground
Ginger 12 g Sliced
Red chili 1 Remove the seeds for less heat
Lemongrass 2 stalks Bruise the bottom 4 inches (10 cm). 2 tsp if dried
Makrut lime leaves 4 leaves Frozen is fine. Omit if none
Bay leaf 1 Stands in for local daun salam
Water 3 cups (700 ml) Don't boil hard once the fish is in
Tomatoes 2 Cut in wedges. Acidity and looks
Scallions 2 1.5 inches (4 cm) lengths
Lemon basil, or shiso 8 leaves Stands in for kemangi. The aroma differs, but it works as a way out
Light brown sugar 1 tsp Rounds off the edges of the soup
Salt 1 tsp Adjust at the end
Lime juice 1 tbsp To finish. Don't boil off the acidity
0 / 0

Wound up on a pair of chopsticks, papeda looks almost clear, sticky and glossy. It is white but not rice, smooth but not noodles, and it may puzzle you a little the first time you see it. Then it sinks into a bowl of yellow fish soup, and it suddenly makes sense. This sago porridge is the staple of the Maluku Islands and Papua in eastern Indonesia. On its own it is mild and hardly asserts itself, which is exactly why it works: paired with ikan kuah kuning, a yellow fish soup scented with turmeric, lemongrass and makrut lime leaves, it takes in the soup's sourness and the umami of the fish.

A table in eastern Indonesia with papeda, yellow fish soup, sambal and krupuk
Papeda becomes a meal not on its own, but beside yellow fish soup, heat and a light cracker

Papeda and the sago tables of eastern Indonesia

Name and region

Papeda is the Indonesian spelling. It is eaten around Maluku, Ambon, Papua and West Papua, where sago is the staple.

Sago starch, fish, turmeric, lemongrass and makrut lime leaves laid out as ingredients for papeda
Measuring the sago, the fish and the aromatics for the yellow soup first makes the papeda meal easy to assemble

In Java and Bali, rice sits at the center of the table. In Maluku and Papua, sago has long been the staple that supports daily life. Starch from the sago palm is stirred with boiling water until it turns translucent and strongly sticky, and that porridge is papeda. Make it at home and you get the staple of the eastern islands, which is easy to miss if you only know rice-eating Indonesia.

Around Fakfak in West Papua, papeda and yellow fish soup are eaten together. The porridge is eaten less by chewing than by letting it coat itself in the soup and swallowing. Locally it is wound up with a wooden tool called a gata-gata, or a tool like long chopsticks, and moved to the plate. At home, open two disposable chopsticks slightly and turn them in the porridge to wind it.

Papeda is a different kind of plate from rendang with its rich meat, soto ayam with its yellow chicken soup, or rawon, the black beef soup. The porridge at the center adds little flavor of its own, and the dish comes together only when you eat it with the soup. On the plate it takes on the yellow fish soup and passes sourness, heat and fish umami to you bit by bit. So rather than a big bowl like rice, wind a small portion and loosen it in hot soup; that is easier on people who aren't used to it.

A plate of clear porridge alone makes the flavor hard to imagine. With yellow fish soup, a small dish of heat and light krupuk beside it, stickiness, umami, sourness and crisp texture arrive in turn, and papeda eats like a staple in its own right. Each element has a job:

Local element Role Practical substitute
Sago starch Sticky staple Sago starch is ideal. Tapioca starch if hard to find
Yellow fish soup Passes flavor to the porridge Cod, swordfish, yellowtail, yellowfin tuna
Lemongrass Lightens the fish smell Frozen or dried is fine
Makrut lime leaves Citrus aroma A few frozen leaves. If none, omit and make up with lime
Sambal Adds heat plate by plate Store-bought sambal or homemade

Ingredients: sago porridge and yellow fish soup

This serves 4. Papeda is the staple, so skip cooking rice separately and make this the center of the meal. If someone isn't used to it, serving less papeda and more yellow fish soup makes it easier to start.

This dish contains fish, nuts, seasonings that may contain shellfish, and depending on the product possibly wheat or soy. If you use sambal, krupuk or store-bought spice pastes, check the ingredient labels.

Choosing ingredients and substitutes for papeda

Sago starch, lemongrass, makrut lime leaves, sambal and krupuk laid out as shopping items
Worth buying extra: sago or tapioca starch, lemongrass, makrut lime leaves, sambal and krupuk

The real challenge outside Indonesia is judging the porridge, not finding ingredients. Look at what each ingredient does rather than matching every name. Even without lemongrass or makrut lime leaves, three things keep you close to the real dish: cook the fish gently, don't boil off the final sourness, and stir the porridge until it is clear.

Starch

Sago starch and tapioca starch are not the same

Properly it is the starch of the sago palm. Tapioca starch comes from cassava and is different, but it is widely available and close in clarity and spring, so it works as a home substitute. Made with rice flour or potato starch alone, the stickiness and melt in the mouth go in a different direction.

Tapioca makes the porridge a little stickier, and it gets heavy as it cools. Start with the same amount of water, and if it comes out stiff, add 2 tbsp hot water at a time. Potato starch mixed in adds stickiness but feels floury in the mouth once cool, so never use it alone.

Unused starch absorbs moisture and clumps, which means lumps next time, so skip the big bag. The first time, buy a small bag of about 9 oz (250 g) tapioca starch to get a feel for the stickiness. Once you know papeda suits your table, look for sago; the same water ratio is easy to try.

Fish

The yellow soup is made with kakap (snapper family), tuna, skipjack or white fish locally. Elsewhere, cooking-grade cod, swordfish, yellowtail or yellowfin tuna, not sashimi-grade, are easy to use. Look at the thickness of the cut more than the name: thin cuts fall apart in the soup, leaving only crumbs on the plate, while a piece thick enough to cut into 1 inches (3 cm) cubes keeps its shape even at medium-low heat.

Swordfish and yellowfin tuna have firm flesh and suit a first try. Cod has a gentle flavor but breaks easily, so add it last and don't stir once it is in the pot; ladle the soup over from above instead. Yellowtail releases fat that makes the soup heavy, so raising the final lime juice to 1 1/2 tbsp makes it easier to eat.

Aromatics and sides

The yellow color doesn't come from turmeric alone. Shallot, garlic, candlenut, ginger, lemongrass and makrut lime leaves are opened in oil before the fish goes in gently. Buy lemongrass frozen or dried when you find it. A few makrut lime leaves change the soup's character, and frozen ones keep well, so they're worth buying even before the lemongrass. If you shop online, buy in this order: the starch, makrut lime leaves, sambal, then krupuk. Leaves, sambal and krupuk also go into ayam betutu and tom yum goong, so nothing goes to waste.

What to buy Priority Reason
Sago or tapioca starch High Decides the stickiness of the porridge
Lemongrass High Lightens the fish smell
Makrut lime leaves Medium Gives the soup its citrus outline
Sambal Medium Adds heat plate by plate
Krupuk Medium Light texture between sticky bites
Doubt Direction to protect Practical at home Direction to avoid
Starch Sago-derived stickiness Sago starch, tapioca starch if difficult Making porridge from rice flour alone
Water Cook until clear Adjust from 1.25 quarts (1.1 L) water to 4 oz (120 g) starch Putting starch straight into boiling water
Fish Cuts that keep their shape Swordfish, cod, tuna, yellowtail Simmering thin sashimi cuts for long
Aroma Lemongrass and citrus leaves Frozen lemongrass, makrut lime leaves Making it Western with bay leaf alone
Acid Add brightly at the end Lime, lemon Adding early and losing the aroma

Method: stir until clear, and cook the fish gently

Papeda looks like a dish where you just pour boiling water on starch, but the biggest difference comes at the start of stirring. Loosen the starch in cold water first, then add it to boiling water a little at a time. The fish soup is the opposite: don't stir it too much. Use force on the porridge, and barely touch the fish. Remembering that contrast makes it easier.

Don't boil the fish hard

Kuah kuning is a yellow soup, but it is not a dish to boil hard like a curry. Once the fish is in, lower to medium-low and stop at small rising bubbles. If the fish breaks up, don't stir; ladle the soup over from above to cook it through.

Papeda problems and fixes

Comparing porridge with cloudy white lumps against clear, stretchy papeda
White lumps mean the starch wasn't loosened enough or not cooked enough. Stir until clear and stretchy

White lumps come from putting the starch into boiling water before loosening it in cold water, or from letting your stirring hand rest. For small lumps, keep the heat at medium-low and press them against the side of the pot with a wooden spoon, stirring for 2 minutes. If there are many large ones, skip the strainer: add 4 tbsp hot water, whisk hard, and reheat.

If the porridge goes too stiff, add 2 tbsp hot water at a time before you turn off the heat. Cold water drops the temperature and can turn the clear porridge white again. If it's too loose, cook 2 minutes at a time over medium heat, scraping the bottom, until it hangs in a ribbon from a lifted spoon.

Fish breaks up from boiling too hard and from being touched too much. Keep the heat where the soup just circulates, and ladle soup over the fish instead of turning it. A broken fish is no disaster; move the flakes to a small bowl and enjoy them with the soup. Boil the soup hard, too, and the turmeric aroma turns heavy.

If the soup tastes vague, check the acidity before adding salt. Add 2 tsp lime juice and warm just 30 seconds, and the fish flavor stands up. If it lacks heat, put sambal on a separate dish rather than making the whole pot hot.

Serving and storing papeda

At the table

Plate everything and mix it, and papeda suddenly looks heavy. Instead, put a little yellow fish soup in a shallow dish, drop the wound-up papeda into it, and ladle more soup over. It's in good shape when a thin film of yellow oil clings to the clear porridge and the soup drips slowly as you lift it with chopsticks. Warm the plates first: pour boiling water in, leave 1 minute, and pour it off, since papeda turns heavy as it cools. A small portion wound for each person keeps its clarity and stretch better than one big platter.

Serve sambal, lime and krupuk in small dishes. Eat the first bite as is, add a little sambal on the second, and scoop with a broken piece of krupuk along the way, and even this sticky staple doesn't tire you. For children and anyone who avoids heat, give mostly soup with a dab of sambal about the size of a grain of rice at the edge of the plate. Heat lovers keep more fish aroma by touching sambal to each bite rather than stirring it through. Papeda absorbs flavor easily, so once strong heat goes in, it can't be undone.

Krupuk gives your mouth a rest. After two or three bites, the sago's stickiness lingers; break a cracker, dip it in the soup, and the mix of crisp and slightly damp pieces makes the next bite easier. Puff fried krupuk just before serving so it doesn't go damp. Shrimp crackers, thin rice crackers or fried rice vermicelli can stand in, but sweet crackers don't suit the soup.

Side dishes

Dishes that add aroma and heat a little at a time suit papeda better than rich meat. Put a sambal substitute in a small dish, and choose light vegetables like cucumber, tomato and boiled greens over a rich peanut sauce such as gado-gado.

  • Soto ayam: you can reuse the aromatics of the yellow soup.
  • Rawon: East Java's black soup shows the range of Indonesian soup culture.
  • Nasi uduk: a small portion of this coconut-scented rice pulls things together on a day you want a little rice too.
  • Sate ayam: sambal and krupuk work at the same table.

Storage and reheating

Kitchen with leftover papeda and yellow fish soup stored in separate containers
Refrigerate papeda and fish soup in separate containers, and heat the soup first when reheating

Papeda is best fresh. If any is left, store the papeda and the fish soup in separate containers, let them cool slightly, and refrigerate within 2 hours. Plan on keeping them until the next day.

To reheat, warm the soup in a pot over low heat for 5 minutes; the fish toughens if heated harder. Put the papeda in a heatproof bowl, sprinkle on 2 tbsp water, cover loosely with plastic wrap, and microwave at 600 W for 40 seconds. Stir once, and if it's still stiff, add 1 tbsp water and heat 20 seconds more. It won't be quite like freshly made, so the next day it's best with plenty of soup poured over.

Don't freeze papeda: it weeps water on thawing and the stickiness turns gritty. The soup can be frozen without the fish and warmed later with new fish. The herb aroma weakens, so add lime juice and shiso at the end of reheating.

FAQ

If I have no sago starch, can I make it with tapioca starch alone?

Yes. Replace 4 oz (120 g) sago starch with 4 oz (120 g) tapioca starch and start with the same water. Tapioca comes out stickier, so if it feels stiff at the end, add hot water 2 tbsp at a time.

Which fish is least likely to fail?

Swordfish, yellowfin tuna and yellowtail fillets are the easiest. If you use thin sashimi-grade fish, add it just before turning off the heat and let it cook in the residual heat.

Can I make it without heat?

Yes. Leave out the red chili and serve sambal on the side. The soup's aroma comes from turmeric, lemongrass and makrut lime leaves, so it holds up without chili. If it feels flat, add 1 tsp lime juice rather than heat.

Can I make it ahead?

The fish soup can be made the day before, but papeda is better made just before eating. If you must make it ahead, put only the papeda in an airtight container and sprinkle 1 tbsp water on the surface to keep it from drying. The next day, warm it a little at a time in the microwave and bring back the stickiness with hot water.

Sources

Indonesia Travel, the English-language site of Indonesia's tourism ministry, introduces papeda as a sago dish of Maluku and Papua and explains its pairing with yellow fish soup. On another page it takes up Papeda Ikan Kuah Kuning as a dish of West Papua, especially around Fakfak, and touches on sago porridge, fish, turmeric, lemongrass and how it is eaten. The Primarasa recipe was consulted to check the fish, the spice paste, and the water amount and cooking steps for sago starch. The ANTARA News Ambon article was consulted to confirm the aromatics of the yellow fish soup in Maluku and the explanation of stirring sago with boiling water.