Kare-Kare: Filipino Oxtail Stew in Peanut Sauce

Filipino kare-kare, oxtail and leafy greens simmered in peanut sauce
Prep
35 min
Cook
3 hr 10 min
Total
3 hr 45 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Filipino

Kare-kare is a Filipino oxtail stew in peanut sauce. This recipe covers oxtail or beef shank, unsweetened peanut butter, annatto, bagoong and serving.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Prepare the oxtail and beef shank

Searing oxtail in a pot
Sear the oxtail and shank first so their toasty flavor carries into the broth

Rinse the oxtail under running water. If a lot of blood is seeping out, blanch it in boiling water for just 5 minutes and discard the water. Pat dry, heat 1 tbsp oil in a heavy pot, and sear the surfaces of the oxtail and beef shank. A light browning on all sides is enough.

STEP22 / 6

Simmer the meat until tender

Oxtail simmering with aromatics in a pot
No peanuts in the first simmer; draw out a clear beef broth

Add 1.8 L water, 1/2 onion, 3 cloves garlic and the bay leaf to the pot and bring to a boil. Skim off the scum, then simmer over low heat for 2 hours 30 minutes to 3 hours, until the meat is just short of falling apart when pressed with chopsticks. In a pressure cooker, cook at high pressure for 45 to 60 minutes and let the pressure release naturally. Don't discard the broth; set aside about 3 cups (about 600 ml, using 200 ml cups).

STEP33 / 6

Toast the rice flour and dissolve the sauce powders

Dry-toasting rice flour and preparing peanuts and annatto
Toast the rice flour until just before it colors, and the sauce is less likely to taste floury

Put 3 tbsp rice flour in a skillet and dry-toast over medium-low heat for about 3 minutes. When it turns from pure white to pale beige and smells toasty, turn off the heat. In a bowl, combine the toasted rice flour, annatto powder and 1 cup (200 ml) of the broth, and mix well until there are no lumps.

STEP44 / 6

Make the peanut sauce

Thinning a golden peanut sauce in a pot
Loosen the unsweetened peanut butter with broth a little at a time, watching the thickness

In a separate pot, heat 1 tbsp oil and sauté the remaining onion and garlic over medium-low heat. When fragrant, add 2 cups (400 ml) of the broth, the rice flour and annatto mixture, the unsweetened peanut butter and the crushed peanuts, and stir. Simmer over low heat for about 7 minutes, and once it turns thick and silky, season lightly with fish sauce, salt and pepper.

STEP55 / 6

Blanch the vegetables

Blanched eggplant, green beans and bok choy
Cooking the vegetables separately keeps them from going limp in the peanut sauce

Cut the green beans into 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 inches (3 to 4 cm) lengths, the eggplant into 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) thick diagonal slices, and the bok choy lengthwise into quarters. Bring 1.5 quarts (1.5 L) water to a boil, add 1 tsp salt, and keep it at a gentle boil over medium heat. Blanch the green beans for about 1 minute, the eggplant for 1 minute 30 seconds, and the bok choy for 40 seconds, then drain in a colander. Stop when the beans are bright green with a little bite and the eggplant is just starting to turn translucent at the center. If using banana blossom, rub it lightly in salted water until the fibers soften slightly and clump together, then boil it separately for 1 minute to remove the astringency.

STEP66 / 6

Return the meat and finish

Returning the oxtail to the peanut sauce to finish
Return the meat to the sauce, and add the vegetables last just to warm them

Return the tender oxtail and beef shank to the sauce and warm over low heat for 10 minutes. Keep the sauce at the point where a small bubble rises only now and then, and aim for a thickness where a wooden spatula dragged across the bottom shows the pot for just 1 second. If it's too thick, add broth 2 tbsp at a time. Finally add the vegetables and warm for just 2 minutes without breaking them up. Turn off the heat when the eggplant still holds its edges and the bok choy leaves are warm and still deep green. Serve with white rice and bagoong.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Meat and broth

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Oxtail 500 g Butcher, frozen meat section or online. If unavailable, increase the shank
Beef shank or beef chuck, in one piece 400 g Adding 200 g beef tendon gives more gelatinous body
Onion 1 (about 200 g) Half goes into the simmer, half into the sauce
Garlic 6 cloves Jarred minced garlic: 3 tsp, though fresh smells better
Water 1.8 L About 7 1/2 US cups. Top up if it reduces too much
Bay leaf 1 Optional. Don't let its aroma get too strong
Vegetable oil 2 tbsp Rice bran oil also works
2 / 3

Sauce

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Unsweetened peanut butter 3.5 oz (100 g) Avoid sweetened kinds, which make the sauce sweet
Unsalted roasted peanuts 1.5 oz (40 g) Crush coarsely. Peanut butter alone is fine too
Rice flour 3 tbsp (about 27 g) Joshinko (Japanese rice flour) also works. Glutinous rice flour turns gummy and isn't suitable
Annatto powder 2 tsp Also called achiote. Without it, use 1 tsp paprika for color only
Fish sauce 2 tsp Traditional recipes use fish sauce. Don't overdo it
Black pepper A pinch For finishing
Salt 1/2 tsp to start Start light, since bagoong is served on the side
3 / 3

Vegetables and accompaniments

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Eggplant 3 (about 10.5 oz / 300 g) Long Asian eggplants are closest to the Filipino kind
Green beans 4 oz (120 g) Stand in for long beans. Trim the strings
Bok choy 2 heads Stands in for pechay. Komatsuna also works
Banana blossom 2.75 oz (80 g) If you can find it. Otherwise leave it out
Bagoong alamang 4 tbsp Fermented shrimp paste. See the substitutes below too
Cooked white rice 4 bowls Slightly firm rice holds up best under the sauce
Allergy information

This dish contains beef, peanuts and seafood (fish sauce, bagoong). Most bagoong is made from shrimp, so anyone with a shellfish allergy should not use it. Treat substitutes such as a little fish sauce or miso as a way to suggest the aroma only, not as the same thing; that is the safe approach.

0 / 0

On a kare-kare day, the air in the kitchen changes partway through. For hours the oxtail simmers and the pot barely smells of anything. Then you stir unsweetened peanut butter and toasted rice flour into the annatto-tinted broth, a toasty aroma rushes up all at once, and you know it's time to cook the rice. Kare-kare is a Filipino stew of oxtail, beef shank and sometimes tripe in a peanut sauce. Its depth doesn't come from dairy, as a cream stew's would. It comes from nuts, beef broth and the savoriness of a fermented condiment. The sauce has a deep color but a gentle taste. It isn't spicy and isn't very salty, because the salt arrives later, at the table.


About kare-kare

How kare-kare is eaten

When Filipino families sit down to kare-kare, there is white rice beside it and a small dish of bagoong, a fermented shrimp paste. Each person works a little bagoong into their rice as they eat. That habit of not finishing the dish completely in the pot is what makes kare-kare what it is. You'll see the name spelled two ways in English, kare-kare and kari kari, and both are common.

Among Filipino dishes, kare-kare sits at the opposite end from sour sinigang or adobo, which is braised in soy sauce and vinegar. It doesn't lean sour, spicy or sweet. It's a soft sauce, and you add the salty bagoong yourself.

Kare-kare turns up for special occasions and for ordinary family meals alike. The oxtail needs a long time to get tender, so a weeknight after work is the wrong time to start it from scratch. Simmer it on the weekend and reheat the sauce the next day, or cut the prep time with a pressure cooker.

Where kare-kare comes from

A large platter of Filipino kare-kare with white rice and bagoong
Kare-kare isn't finished in the pot; it comes together at the table with white rice and bagoong

There are three stories about where kare-kare came from. One credits cooks in Pampanga. Another says it began as a curry brought by Indian sepoys during the British occupation of Manila from 1762 to 1764 and was later adapted to local tastes. The third ties it to the kari traditions of the southern Philippines and the wider Malay world. The karihan, small eateries that served kari, are part of the picture as well.

Whatever its beginnings, the dish today is built on oxtail and tripe and an orange-brown sauce of annatto oil, rice flour and peanuts. The vegetables change with region and season.


Ingredients (serves 4): built on oxtail, made practical with beef shank

Oxtail, peanuts, annatto and leafy greens laid out in a kitchen as kare-kare ingredients
Oxtail, peanuts, toasted rice, annatto and greens: kare-kare is built from ingredients where trade and home cooking meet

This makes one large platter for 4. Using only oxtail gives a stronger aroma and more gelatinous body, but it raises the bar on price and availability. 1 lb (500 g) oxtail plus 14 oz (400 g) beef shank is an easier mix, and the sauce still gets plenty of savoriness.

Ingredients and equipment for this dish

Oxtail often isn't on the shelf at an ordinary supermarket, so once you pick a cooking day, secure the meat first. Combining it with beef shank keeps the cost down and makes the simmering time more predictable.

Annatto isn't a spice that adds heat; it's the ingredient that gives kare-kare its orange color. Paprika can approximate the color, but if you want the aroma closer to the original, use annatto.

Avoid peanut butter that contains sugar or honey. A sweet product pushes kare-kare toward a dessert-like aroma and throws off the balance with the bagoong.

Bagoong divides opinion, but in kare-kare it's less a part of the sauce than a partner that adds salt right before you eat. A small jar is plenty; look for it at a Filipino or Asian grocery or online.

If you make braises often, a heavy pot or a pressure cooker makes life easier. Even with a pressure cooker, finish the sauce at the end in a separate pot, checking the thickness as you go.


Choosing kare-kare ingredients and substitutes

Beef shank, greens and peanut ingredients from a shopping trip for kare-kare
On days you can't find oxtail, build the dish around beef shank and unsweetened peanut butter

On paper, kare-kare's ingredient list looks hard to shop for. In practice only a few things need protecting: beef broth, peanuts, the orange color and the fermented saltiness added at the table. Get those right and it still works as kare-kare even with regular supermarket ingredients.

Pillar of kare-kare Why it matters Practical solution at home
Beef broth The base of the sauce. Water alone tastes flat Combine oxtail, beef shank and beef tendon
Peanuts The toasty flavor at the heart of the dish Unsweetened peanut butter and unsalted peanuts
Toasted rice Body and toastiness Dry-toast rice flour. Otherwise a little joshinko (Japanese rice flour)
Annatto Orange color and a faintly earthy aroma Annatto powder. Paprika gives the color, but not the aroma
Ingredient in question Closer to the original Home kitchen choice Effect of the substitute
Oxtail Mostly oxtail Oxtail + beef shank Shank alone gives less gelatinous body
Tripe Beef tripe, boiled separately Fine to omit Lighter texture, but easier for a first try
Pechay pechay Bok choy, komatsuna Komatsuna is more assertive, so cook it briefly
Long beans sitaw Green beans Shorter pieces, but a similar texture
Banana blossom puso ng saging Omit, or use a little bamboo shoot The bitterness and fibrous texture change
Bagoong ginisang bagoong Shrimp paste, fish sauce, a little miso The fermented shrimp aroma can't be fully replaced

The one swap to avoid is sweetened peanut butter. Spreads meant for toast are high in sugar and fat, and in a savory dish that sweetness pushes to the front. Pick a jar whose label reads little more than "peanuts, salt," and pass on anything sweetened, chocolate, whipped or sold as "peanut cream."


Method: handle the beef broth, rice flour and vegetables separately

If you simply simmer everything in one pot, kare-kare turns heavy. Make the meat tender on its own. Dry-toast the rice flour before dissolving it. Keep the color and bite of the vegetables. Separating these three keeps the peanut sauce rich without becoming tiring to eat.

Using a pressure cooker

If you take the peanut sauce all the way in a pressure cooker, it scorches easily and the thickness is hard to adjust. Use the pressure cooker only to make the meat tender, and finish the sauce in a regular pot for fewer failures.


Common kare-kare problems and fixes

Small dishes comparing the thickness of kare-kare peanut sauce
If it sets too firm like the one on the left, loosen it with broth; aim for the one on the right, where a spoon trail holds

Kare-kare usually goes wrong in thickness more than in seasoning. A loose sauce won't cling to the meat and vegetables. A sauce that's too thick turns pasty from the rice flour and feels heavier with every bite.

Problem Cause Fix
Gritty sauce Rice flour added straight in, lumps left Dissolve the toasted rice flour in broth before adding
Too sweet Sweetened peanut butter Switch to unsweetened. If already sweet, adjust at the table with fish sauce and bagoong
Pale color Not enough annatto Dissolve a little annatto powder in broth and add
Too heavy Too much peanut butter, overreduced Add broth 2 tbsp at a time
Mushy vegetables Simmered too long in the sauce Blanch the vegetables separately and add them at the end
Tough meat Not simmered long enough Simmer another 30 minutes, or 10 more minutes in a pressure cooker
Bland Trying to finish everything in the pot Add bagoong at the table

Toasting the rice flour brings out its nutty flavor and makes an overly thick sauce less likely. Dry-toasting it and then dissolving it in broth gives a much smoother texture than adding the flour straight to the pot, and it's worth the extra step.

No rice flour on hand? Dry-toast 3 tbsp white rice and grind it in a spice grinder or mortar. You'll get a stronger toasty note than from rice flour. If the grind comes out coarse, sift it through a strainer so the sauce stays smooth.

Don't settle the salt too early

Even if it tastes bland partway through simmering, don't add a lot of salt at once. The saltiness intensifies as it reduces, and bagoong goes on the side at the end. Light salt in the pot, adjust at the table: that's the safe way to make kare-kare.


Serving and storing kare-kare

Kare-kare at the table

Many Filipino dishes, like pancit canton, are shared from a big platter. Kare-kare goes further: each person sets the seasoning on their own plate. Pour the sauce over rice and start with a dab of bagoong about the size of 2 or 3 grains of rice, so the saltiness doesn't hit you all at once.

If someone at the table doesn't care for bagoong, keep it out of the pot and serve it in a small dish. That makes it easy to share one pot with family members who aren't used to Filipino food. For heat, mix a little chopped chili or lemon into the bagoong. And if you have bagoong left over, pinakbet, with squash, eggplant and okra cooked down in a little liquid, is an easy next dish.

Storage and reheating

Leftover kare-kare divided into sauce and vegetables in storage containers
Storing the meat and sauce separately from the vegetables keeps their texture into the next day

The sauce settles and tastes even better the next day. Vegetables left in it don't hold up, though: the eggplant soaks up too much sauce and the bok choy loses its color. If you're planning on leftovers, store the meat and sauce separately from the vegetables.

Leftovers keep in the refrigerator for 2 to 3 days. Once the stew has cooled slightly, move it into shallow containers and get it into the fridge promptly. It's a rich sauce of beef and peanuts, so don't let it sit at room temperature for long. To freeze, freeze only the meat and sauce, which keep for about 1 month, and blanch fresh vegetables when you serve it again.

Reheat the meat and sauce in a pot over low heat, loosening it with broth or water 2 tbsp at a time. The microwave tends to leave some parts stiff, so use a pot if you can. Add the vegetables at the end, just long enough to warm them.

The easiest next-day meal is kare-kare over firm-cooked white rice with a little bagoong and a squeeze of lemon or another tart citrus. The acidity cuts through the richness of the peanuts. Leftover beef shank is also good shredded and served as a small side next to lumpiang shanghai.


Kare-kare variations and menus

A lighter chicken variation of kare-kare
Kare-kare made with chicken is lighter and easier to fit into a weeknight dinner

Oxtail kare-kare feels like a feast, but as Filipino home cooking it's flexible about the meat. Chicken, pork trotters, pork shank, seafood and tofu can all carry the peanut sauce.

Chicken thigh kare-kare

Use 1.75 lb (800 g) bone-in chicken thighs instead of oxtail and the simmering time drops to about 30 minutes. You lose the depth of beef broth, so reduce the peanut butter to 2.75 oz (80 g) and use chicken stock for a lighter result. This is the version to make when you want kare-kare on a weeknight.

Budget version with beef shank only

Skip the oxtail and use 2 lb (900 g) beef shank, adding 7 oz (200 g) beef tendon if you want more gelatinous body. You give up the aroma from the oxtail bones, but the meat is easy to cut and easy to eat. This version is perfectly good for a first try.

Tofu and vegetable kare-kare

Press 2 blocks of firm tofu, cut them into thick slices and sear the surfaces before adding them to the sauce. Leave out the fish sauce and bagoong and use 2 tsp miso and kombu dashi for savoriness. It won't taste exactly the same, but it makes a good peanut and vegetable stew. If someone has a peanut allergy, don't make kare-kare; switch to a different dish.

Building a Filipino menu

Kare-kare is mild yet rich, so something sour and something fried balance the table. For soup, a small serving of sinigang. For something fried, a few lumpiang shanghai. For noodles, a platter of pancit canton. On days you crave heat, Bicol express takes the same Filipino table in a different direction.

For dessert, the glutinous rice sweet sapin-sapin is a perfect match. Its coconut and sticky rice gently round off the richness of the peanut sauce.


FAQ

Kare-kare on the table with white rice and bagoong
Set white rice and bagoong beside the kare-kare, and let each person add saltiness as they eat

Can I make kare-kare with curry powder?

No. The name sounds like curry, but the flavor is built on peanuts, beef broth, toasted rice and annatto. Curry powder pushes it toward an Indian- or Japanese-style curry and buries kare-kare's gentle nuttiness.

What can I use if I can't find oxtail?

A combination of beef shank, beef chuck and beef tendon works well. Using 1.5 lb (700 g) shank plus 7 oz (200 g) tendon gets you closer to the gelatinous body of oxtail. Pork trotters or pork shank also work, but the aroma changes quite a bit.

Can I eat it without bagoong?

You can, but it won't taste as much like kare-kare. If you don't have a shellfish allergy, start by setting out just 1 tsp and try a tiny bit on your rice. If you can't use it, make up the salt and savoriness with a few drops of fish sauce, a little miso and a little lemon.

Can children or people who don't like spicy food eat it?

Yes. Basic kare-kare isn't spicy. Add heat at the table by mixing chili into the bagoong. For children, keep the salt in the pot light, serve the bagoong in a separate dish and pair the stew with white rice so it's easy to eat.

Sources

About the references

Kare-kare has several origin theories, and this article does not settle on any single one. We cross-checked food history, what home recipes have in common, and the handling of rice flour and peanut sauce against several English-language sources.

Kare-kare isn't a dish that surprises you with fiery heat. Beef broth, peanuts, rice flour, annatto, vegetables, bagoong: each plays a slightly different role, and it finally comes together on top of white rice. For your first time, don't hunt too hard for oxtail; try it with some beef shank mixed in. When the sauce starts to turn glossy in the pot, the Filipino platter is suddenly within reach.