Seswaa: Botswana's Pounded Beef Cooked with Salt and Water

Botswana seswaa: beef simmered in salted water, pounded into coarse strands and coated with a little of its cooking juices
Serves
6 servings
Cuisine
Botswana

How to make seswaa (also called chotlho), the Botswana dish of beef simmered with salt and water until tender, then pounded into coarse strands and moistened with its own reduced broth. Covers amounts for 6 servings, how to judge tenderness and texture, serving with bogobe, fixing mistakes, safe storage, and the dish's place at weddings, funerals and ceremonies.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Put the beef, salt and water in the pot

Putting the beef, salt and water into a deep pot
Pour the water so it reaches between and around the pieces of beef

Pat the surface of the beef dry and cut it into large, even pieces that fit the pot. Put the 3.25 lb (1.5 kg) beef in a deep pot without stacking the pieces, add the 15 g fine salt, and pour in the 1.5 quarts (1.5 L) water. Check that the water flows between and around the pieces. Add nothing else.

STEP22 / 6

Cover and simmer gently

Beef simmering gently in a covered pot
Keep a gentle simmer rather than a rolling boil

Bring to a boil, then cover and lower the heat to a gentle simmer, with only a few quiet bubbles at the edge. Simmer for 2.5–3 hours. Don't rush it with a hard boil. Lift the lid now and then to check the water level and the meat. If the meat does not yet come apart when pressed, keep simmering past 3 hours and put tenderness first.

Cook the meat through: the center should reach 167°F (75°C) and stay there for at least 1 minute.

STEP33 / 6

Lift out the tender beef

Lifting the tender cooked beef out of the pot
The cooked beef should be tender enough to start separating at the edges

When the beef separates easily when pressed, lift it out with tongs onto a clean board or shallow bowl. Leave all the cooking liquid in the pot. If there is any bone or tough connective tissue, remove it now.

STEP44 / 6

Reduce the cooking liquid

Reducing the broth in the uncovered pot after removing the beef
Reduce the broth until it tastes concentrated, without letting it scorch

Simmer the broth left in the pot uncovered to concentrate it. Taste it with a spoon as it reduces. Stop while there is still liquid in the pot; do not let it dry out or scorch.

STEP55 / 6

Pound the beef into coarse strands while hot

Pounding hot beef into coarse strands with a wooden spoon
Keep the texture coarse and thread-like, not minced

While the beef is still hot, pound and press it firmly with a strong wooden spoon or a meat pounder until it breaks into coarse threads. Stop when the fibers are clearly visible. Do not take it as far as a paste or fine mince.

STEP66 / 6

Return the broth and serve hot

Spooning concentrated broth back over the pounded beef
Add broth until the strands are moist, but not submerged

Spoon the reduced broth back over the pounded beef a little at a time, mixing as you go, until the strands are moist and glossy but not swimming in liquid. You may not need all of it. Taste, and add salt only a little at a time if needed. Serve hot, beside bogobe.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Boneless beef chuck or brisket 3.25 lb (1.5 kg) A cut suited to long simmering; it softens and separates into strands
Water 1.5 quarts (1.5 L) The cooking liquid, later reduced and returned to moisten the meat
Fine salt 15 g Seasons the meat and broth as they cook together

Use fine salt. If your salt has a coarser grain or a different saltiness, add less at first and adjust by tasting at the end.

0 / 0

Seswaa asks for beef, salt and water, and then for time. There's no onion, no spice blend, no oil. The flavor comes from the beef itself, the salt and the broth it cooks in, plus the patience to wait until the meat falls apart. In Botswana it turns up at most special occasions, from weddings and funerals to ceremonies and community gatherings: beef boiled until soft in a three-legged iron pot, pounded with a wooden stick, and served hot beside maize or sorghum porridge.

Seswaa in Botswana

Seswaa, also known as chotlho, is made with beef, sometimes chicken, boiled in water with a good amount of salt until soft. The meat is then beaten with a wooden spoon until it shreds. It belongs to the big occasions where beef is eaten in quantity, and it is cooked and served communally.

The pounding stick is called tswaiso, or loswao in other dialects. One explanation for the pounding is that it made tough meat from older cattle easier to share out, and easier to chew for both the young and the elderly. Skill comes in at every stage, from picking the cut to judging when the strands are right. The aim is thread-like meat that is neither too dry nor too wet, and getting there takes experience.

Some traditional methods boil the beef for about four hours, while a covered, gentle simmer in a modern pot takes 2.5–3 hours. Either way, the meat is ready when it is tender, not when a timer goes off.

Ingredients for 6 Servings: Beef, Salt and Water

Seswaa ingredients laid out: beef chuck, fine salt and water only
Seswaa uses only beef, fine salt and water

Equipment

  • A deep, heavy pot with a lid, large enough to hold the beef and 1.5 quarts (1.5 L) of water
  • Tongs, for lifting the meat out
  • A sturdy board or shallow bowl for pounding
  • A strong wooden spoon or a meat pounder
  • A spoon for returning the broth
  • Clean, shallow containers for any leftovers

A deep pot and a strong wooden spoon are practical tools for pounding the beef at home.

Choosing the Beef and Salt for Seswaa

Beef. Chuck and brisket are both cuts for slow cooking. At the butcher, ask for a boneless piece of chuck or brisket and look at how much fat it carries. Different cuts break down and release fat differently, so a different cut gives a different result.

Salt. Salts vary in grain size and saltiness. If you use something other than fine salt, add it with care and finish seasoning by taste.

Seswaa Doneness, Texture and Fixes

What this pot should keep

Cook the beef until it gives way under a wooden spoon, pound it into coarse threads rather than a paste, and return just enough reduced broth that the strands are moist but not sitting in liquid. Nothing else goes into the pot.

Pot, water and doneness

The recipe uses 1.5 quarts (1.5 L) of water for 3.25 lb (1.5 kg) of beef, and whether that surrounds the meat depends on your pot and on the size and shape of the pieces. Before you start, set the beef in the pot and picture where the water will come to. A deeper, narrower pot helps it reach around and between the pieces. If the water falls well short of the meat, switch pots rather than changing the amounts.

Water added during cooking dilutes the salt, so taste at the end and adjust. Keep track of how much you added. It'll help the next time you make it.

Judge doneness by tenderness

Whether 1.5 quarts (1.5 L) of water surrounds 3.25 lb (1.5 kg) of beef depends on your pot and the shape of the meat. Read "Before You Simmer" first, and judge doneness by tenderness and a fully cooked center, not by the clock alone.

Pot size, the cut and the size of the pieces all change how long the beef takes. The meat is ready when it separates into fibers when pressed with a fork or wooden spoon and the center is fully cooked.

Common problems

Problem Likely cause What to do
The beef won't come apart Not cooked long enough, or the simmer was too low or too uneven Return it to a gentle simmer and check again for tenderness. If the pot is getting dry, check the water level and the heat
The pot is drying out during simmering Heat too high, or a wide pot loses water fast Lower the heat. Added water dilutes the salt, so taste at the end
The strands are dry Not enough broth returned, or the meat cooled before pounding Spoon in more of the reduced broth, a little at a time
The meat is sitting in liquid Too much broth returned at once Lift the meat out with a slotted spoon, or stop adding broth. Next time, add it gradually
It has turned to paste Pounded too long or too finely Next time, stop as soon as coarse fibers show
Too salty The pot or pieces were smaller, so the salt was more concentrated Return less of the reduced broth. The salt amount is meant for 3.25 lb (1.5 kg) of beef and 1.5 quarts (1.5 L) of water
Scaling

These amounts are for 6 servings. For a smaller batch, add salt with care and adjust by tasting rather than dividing the numbers.

Serving, Storing and Varying Seswaa

Serving with bogobe

Hot seswaa served with a separate mound of porridge such as bogobe
Seswaa and porridge are served side by side, not mixed

Sorghum and maize are staple crops in Botswana, and bogobe is the porridge eaten with a relish. Serve seswaa hot with maize or sorghum porridge, which is firm enough to carry the salt and broth of the meat. Leafy greens make a good optional side. For another Botswana porridge, try bogobe jwa lerotse, and for more about the country's food, see our Botswana page.

Leftovers and food safety

Cooling, refrigerating and reheating

Don't leave cooked seswaa at room temperature for long. Divide leftovers into clean, shallow containers so they cool quickly, then refrigerate them at 50°F (10°C) or below. Reheat only the portion you will eat, and heat it until the center reaches 167°F (75°C).

With beef as the main ingredient, this dish is unsuitable for anyone with a beef allergy. For packaged meat and salt, check the labels for allergen and shared-facility warnings.

Variations

The plain version is beef, salt and water, and some cooks change it. Each addition shifts the flavor:

  • Black pepper: brings aroma to the front.
  • Onion: adds sweetness and savory depth.
  • Bay leaf: changes the aroma of the broth.
  • Chili: adds heat, though it is not traditional.
  • Pressure cooker: some cooks use one. It is a separate method, so follow your appliance's instructions for meat and check that the beef is fully cooked and tender.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make seswaa with meat other than beef?

Chicken is sometimes used. The amounts and timing here are for beef, and chicken would cook differently and give a different texture.

Can I add onion or pepper?

You can. Onion, black pepper, bay leaf and chili are all changes some cooks make, and each moves the result away from the plain dish. To taste seswaa as it is usually made, try it plain first.

Do I need a special wooden stick?

No. Traditionally cooks use a tswaiso stick and a three-legged iron pot, but at home a strong wooden spoon or meat pounder works well for breaking the meat into coarse strands.

How long does the whole recipe take?

Beyond the 2.5–3 hour simmer, allow time for trimming the beef, reducing the broth and pounding. Your pot, the cut and the size of the pieces all affect the total, so leave room for the meat taking longer.

Sources

  • Hospitality & Tourism Association of Botswana (HATAB), "Cuisine." Seswaa/chotlho as a popular traditional meat dish served on most special occasions; its traditional preparation with salt and water in a three-legged iron pot; regional variation in Botswana cuisine, sorghum and maize as staples, and bogobe as porridge. A tourism overview, not a recipe. https://hatab.bw/cuisine/
  • "Beef as intangible cultural heritage in Botswana: a documentary review," Journal of Ethnic Foods (Springer Nature). Seswaa as beef, water and salt, boiled until soft and pounded with a wooden stick (tswaiso or loswao); cooked for ceremonies and community events and served hot with maize or sorghum porridge; the skill of reaching a thread-like texture that is neither too dry nor too wet; recorded modifications (onion, black pepper, bay leaf, chili, pressure cooking); the oral account attributed to a Bakwena regent; one cited account of about four hours of boiling. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s42779-023-00199-y
  • Sixto Carreon, "Botswana Seswaa — Slow-Cooked Pounded Beef with Bogobe." The contemporary recipe followed in this article: 6 servings; beef chuck or brisket 1.5 kg, fine salt 15 g, water 1.5 L; covered simmer for 2.5–3 hours, reducing the liquid, pounding the beef and returning enough liquid to keep it moist; bogobe and leafy greens as accompaniments. An individual recipe page, not an official or sole traditional version. https://sixtocarreon.com/recipes/botswana-seswaa/
  • James Denbow and Phenyo C. Thebe, Culture and Customs of Botswana (Greenwood Press, 2006; scan hosted by South African History Online). Seswaa (also chotlho) as beef, sometimes chicken, boiled with considerable salt until soft and beaten with a wooden spoon until shredded; its popularity at weddings, funerals and ceremonies. https://sahistory.org.za/sites/default/files/archive-files/james_denbow_phenyo_c._thebe_culture_and_custombook4you.pdf
  • Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (Japan), "Six points for preventing food poisoning at home" (in Japanese). Cooking meat thoroughly to 75°C at the center for at least one minute; not leaving cooked food at room temperature for long; cooling leftovers quickly in shallow containers, refrigerating, and reheating thoroughly. https://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/seisakunitsuite/bunya/kenkou_iryou/shokuhin/syokuchu/01_00006.html