Gatsby Recipe: Cape Town's Giant Shared Sandwich

Cape Town's Gatsby: a giant sandwich of a long roll filled with masala steak, thick-cut chips, vegetables, and red sauce
Prep
25 min
Cook
35 min
Total
1 hr
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
South African

A recipe for the Gatsby, a Cape Town specialty from South Africa, made at home: masala steak, thick-cut chips, red sauce, how to choose the bread, and storage.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Mix the red sauce

5 min

Mixing ketchup, chili sauce, and hot sauce in a small bowl to make the red sauce for the Gatsby
Mix the red sauce first, keeping it thick enough to drizzle in thin lines over the chips

No heat is used. Put 3 tbsp ketchup, 2 tbsp sweet chili sauce, and 1 tsp hot sauce in a small bowl and stir with a spoon for 30 seconds. Stir until the red is even, with no dark streaks of chili sauce left at the bottom. On days you want to separate the heat, keep the hot sauce in a separate dish and add it at the end for the adults.

STEP22 / 6

Fry the thick chips

18 min

Double-frying thick-cut potatoes in shallow oil to make golden chips
Double-frying thick chips keeps the core from being too firm even when tucked into the bread

Peel 1.25 lb (600 g) potatoes and cut them into 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) sticks. Soak in water for 5 minutes to wash off the surface starch, and pat dry with a cloth. Pour oil 1 inch (2 cm) deep in a skillet and heat to 350°F (170°C) over medium heat, then add the potatoes in two batches without overlapping. After frying 6 minutes, take them out once, raise the oil to 350°F (180°C), and return them for 2 minutes. They are done when the surface is a light golden brown, the corners are crisp, and the center bends fluffy.

STEP33 / 6

Cook the masala steak

10 min

Cooking spice-coated beef in a skillet and cooking off the liquid
Do not leave too much liquid in the masala steak. If meat juices pool on the bottom, the bread sinks

Cut 1 lb (450 g) beef into 0.25 inch (5 mm) strips and work in the curry powder, paprika, cumin, garlic, lemon juice, Worcestershire sauce, salt, and black pepper for 2 minutes. The meat should be evenly coated with seasoning, the powdery look gone, and the surface moist and colored. Put 1 tbsp oil in a skillet and heat over medium-high for 1 minute. Spread in the meat and leave it alone for the first 2 minutes to brown. Turning it over, cook 4–5 minutes more until the red is gone and almost no liquid remains on the bottom. If you have a thermometer, aim for 167°F (75°C).

STEP44 / 6

Prepare the bread and vegetables

5 min

The long roll opened with one side attached, with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles prepared beside it
Opening the bread with one side attached keeps the fillings from slipping out the bottom, even stacked

No heat is used. Cut a slit along the side of the long roll and open it like a book with one side left attached. If you cut through the bottom, the filling falls out easily, so leave about 0.5 inches (1 cm) of connection. Tear the lettuce into 1 inch (3 cm) pieces, cut the tomato 0.25 inch (7 mm) thick and the onion 0.125 inch (2 mm) thick. Pat the vegetables dry with paper towels and drain the pickles.

STEP55 / 6

Layer the chips, meat, and vegetables

4 min

Layering chips, masala steak, vegetables, and red sauce in order in the opened long roll
Heavy fillings below and juicy vegetables above keeps the cross section from collapsing

Drizzle 2 tbsp mayonnaise in a thin line along the inside of the bread. Lay the chips in a single row, leaving 1 inch (2 cm) at each end, and spread the masala steak evenly over them. Drizzle half of the red sauce in thin lines over the meat, then layer tomato, onion, pickles, and lettuce in that order. If you put the vegetables down first, things slip below, so use the heavy chips and meat as the foundation.

STEP66 / 6

Press and cut

3 min

A finished Gatsby cut into four with chips and steak visible in the cross section
Pressing lightly before cutting makes the chips and meat one, so it is easy to eat even divided

No heat is used. Gently close the bread and press down from above with both hands for 10 seconds so the chips and meat come together. If you crush it hard, the sauce escapes sideways, so stop when the bread has lowered about 1 inch (2 cm). Cut into 4 with a sharp knife and drizzle a little of the remaining red sauce on the cut faces. If meat juices run from the cut, rest it on the cutting board for 1 minute before moving it to a plate.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

The sandwich

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Soft baguette or baguette 1 loaf (40–45 cm, about 9 oz (260 g)) A slightly soft long roll suits it better than a very hard baguette
Beef steak or beef for grilling 1 lb (450 g) Cut into 0.25 inch (5 mm) thick strips. Chicken thighs also work
Potatoes 1.25 lb (600 g) For thick chips 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) wide. 1.25 lb (600 g) if using frozen fries
Lettuce 4 oz (120 g) Pat dry and tear into 1 inch (3 cm) pieces
Tomatoes 2 (about 9 oz (260 g)) Sliced 0.25 inch (7 mm) thick
Onion 1/2 (about 3.5 oz (100 g)) Sliced 0.125 inch (2 mm) thick. Soak in water for 5 minutes if too sharp
Pickled cucumbers 2 oz (60 g) If you have achar, replace with 3 tbsp
2 / 3

Masala steak

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Curry powder 2 tsp An easy way to bring in the Cape Malay aroma at home
Paprika 1 tsp Red color and sweet aroma
Ground cumin 1/2 tsp If none, increase the curry powder by 1/2 tsp
Garlic 2 cloves (grated) 2 tsp if tubed
Lemon juice or vinegar 1 tbsp Cuts the heaviness of the meat
Worcestershire sauce 1 tbsp Adds sweetness and acidity
Salt 2/3 tsp For seasoning the meat
Black pepper 1/3 tsp Coarsely ground suits it
Vegetable oil 1 tbsp For cooking
3 / 3

Red sauce and finishing

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Tomato ketchup 3 tbsp The sweet base
Sweet chili sauce 2 tbsp With sambal, start from 2 tsp and adjust
Hot sauce 1 tsp 2 tsp if you have peri-peri sauce
Mayonnaise 2 tbsp Drizzle in a thin line. Do not mix in
Frying oil 1 inch (2 cm) deep in the skillet Not needed if baking frozen fries in the oven
0 / 0

Pull open a long roll, heap it with hot chips, then layer on masala-scented steak, lettuce, tomato and red sauce. Press it down with both hands and cut it into pieces. The Gatsby is Cape Town's giant sandwich, and it goes in the middle of the table for family and friends to share. The long roll and chips give it staying power, and the meat and sauce bring the heat and punch.

The Gatsby in Cape Town

When people think of South African food, bobotie, baked in the oven, and bunny chow, which uses bread as a bowl, usually come up first. The Gatsby is more street-side: the takeaway counter, the trip home from school or work, weekend gatherings. At its core it is chips tucked into a long bread roll, and the fillings, such as masala steak, polony, chicken, calamari or sausage, change from shop to shop and household to household. Locally, several people often share one.

A Gatsby wrapped in paper placed in the center of the table as the family prepares to share it
The Gatsby suits a mood of cutting it up and sharing it more than eating it quietly alone

The name is often linked to the film The Great Gatsby, but the dish itself grew up in Cape Town's takeaway culture. It is cheap, long, shareable and filling thanks to the chips, and once meat and sauce go in, each shop gives it its own character. It is a dish to fill the stomach rather than to impress on the plate, so at home, make it big and share it.


Ingredients (serves 4)

A long roll, beef steak, potatoes, vegetables, spices, and red sauce laid out in a kitchen for the Gatsby
Prepare the long roll, thick chips, fragrant meat, and red sauce separately, and assembly goes without hesitation
Allergen information

This recipe uses wheat, beef, mayonnaise that may contain egg, and seasonings that may contain soy. Check the ingredient labels of the bread, Worcestershire sauce, chili sauce, and mayonnaise. For anyone who dislikes heat, do not mix the hot sauce into the sauce; add it at the table afterward.


Choosing Ingredients and Substitutes for a Gatsby

Outside Cape Town, keep the structure rather than copying a particular shop: a long roll, thick chips, fragrant meat and an acidic sauce. With those four in place, the first bite tastes like a Cape Town snack. What matters most at home is the balance among the bread, the chips and the sauce.

Element What to preserve Substitute
Bread Long, a little soft, with thickness to hold the fillings Soft baguette, thick baguette, two long hot dog rolls
Chips Thick and fluffy, not thin french fries Homemade at 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) wide, or thick frozen fries
Meat Masala aroma and browning, with the moisture cooked off Beef, chicken thighs, sausage, fried white fish
Acidity Red sauce and pickles that cut the heavy fillings Ketchup, chili sauce, hot sauce, pickled cucumbers
How to eat Cut one loaf and share it Divide into 4 and put on plates, with the sauce served separately

A hard baguette never quite becomes one with the fillings; when you bite, the contents just get pushed out. A slightly soft baguette or a thick roll is easier to eat.

Spice and sauce

For masala steak in a home kitchen, start with curry powder. Even if it is not the local blend, a ready-mixed base of turmeric, coriander and cumin rises from just a small amount and leans toward the Cape Malay flavors of South Africa. The same powder goes into roti john and doubles.

A red sauce that is only sweet turns heavy. Peri-peri sauce is ideal, but a small amount of hot sauce with strong heat and acidity also cuts through the chips and mayonnaise. If you can't find peri-peri sauce, mix the hot sauce in a separate dish first, because even 1 tsp is plenty hot. Sambal oelek helps when sweet chili sauce alone tastes flat, and any leftover goes into satay or in place of sambal.

If you have local achar, a little in place of the pickles gives acidity that blends with the oil. Too much from the start lets its aroma take over, so the first time, use up to 3 tbsp and add the rest at the table.

Equipment

Both the chips and the steak keep their flavor when cooked quickly over a wide surface. A cast-iron or heavy skillet that boils off the meat's moisture before it goes into the bread works better than layering batches in a small pan.


How to Make It: Finish the Chips First and Cook Off the Meat's Moisture

If you try to fill the Gatsby with everything piping hot, it falls apart. Fry the chips, cook the meat, open the bread, and drain the vegetables, in that order, and keep only the final assembly quick. Rather than spreading sauce thickly on the bread, scatter it in thin lines over the chips and meat, which helps the cross section hold.


Common Gatsby Problems and Fixes

The real challenge is moisture. Bread that is too soft, chips that are too thin or sauce spread on too early will make the whole thing sink before you eat it, so assemble in an order that keeps everything intact.

A comparison of the cross section of a Gatsby that collapsed from too much moisture and one with chips and meat in good order
The causes of collapse concentrate on weak bread, thin chips, and too much sauce
Problem Cause Fix
Bread tears from the bottom Cut through the bottom, or the fillings were too wet Open it leaving 0.5 inches (1 cm) attached, and cook off the meat's moisture
Everything is soggy Sauce spread widely on the bread Drizzle sauce in thin lines over the meat and add the rest at the table
The chips lose presence Too thin, or fried too pale Cut 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) wide and fry in two stages at 350°F (170°C) and 350°F (180°C)
The meat tastes like plain grilled meat Spice only coated the meat, no browning Over medium-high heat, leave it alone for the first 2 minutes to make a toasty side
Too hot All the hot sauce was mixed in Serve only the hot sauce separately and build the base with ketchup and chili sauce

On days when you can only get thin bread, split the fillings between two long hot dog rolls. You lose a little of the visual impact, but you get to enjoy it to the end instead of having the bottom drop out halfway.


Storing and Reheating a Gatsby

Leftover Gatsby wrapped in paper and the chips and meat being separated into containers for storage
If making ahead, separating the bread, chips, meat, and vegetables keeps it from falling apart the next day

A Gatsby tastes best right after assembly. For leftovers, wrap each cut piece in paper, put them in a storage container, refrigerate and finish them by the next day. Because it contains meat and mayonnaise, throw out any that has sat at room temperature for long.

To reheat, remove the vegetables first if you can. Warm in a microwave at 600 W for 30–40 seconds, then toast the surface of the bread in a toaster oven for 2–3 minutes, which brings back some of the chips' dampness. In a skillet, warm it over low heat for 2 minutes without a lid; high heat scorches the bread while the center stays cold.

If making ahead, store the bread, meat, chips, vegetables and sauce separately. The meat keeps about 2 days in the refrigerator, but eat the chips the same day. To assemble the next day, warm the meat in a skillet over medium heat for 3 minutes and bake the chips in a 400°F (200°C) toaster oven for 5 minutes before filling.

To keep cooking from the list of African cuisines, try bobotie, the sweet-and-savory meatloaf, and bunny chow, curry caught in bread. Alongside the Gatsby, they show three different ways South Africa uses bread and spice.


Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make it with something other than beef?

Yes. Cut chicken thighs into 1 inch (2 cm) cubes, season with the same spices, and cook over medium heat for 8–10 minutes, until the center is cooked through and the juices run clear. Some shops use fried white fish or calamari, but chicken releases less moisture and is easier to handle at home.

Can I use frozen french fries?

Thick frozen fries work. Bake them in the oven or toaster oven 2–3 minutes longer than the label time to crisp the surface. Thin shoestring fries disappear inside the bread.

I do not have peri-peri sauce.

Mix 3 tbsp ketchup, 2 tbsp sweet chili sauce and 1 tsp hot sauce. The sauce needs acidity as well as heat, so if you have no hot sauce, 1 tsp lemon juice cuts the heaviness.

Can I make a small one for one person?

Yes. Use a quarter of the ingredients and assemble it in one roll of about 8 inches (20 cm). Frying such a small batch of chips is inefficient, so either use frozen fries or make extra chips and serve them on the side.


Sources