Shuizhu Niurou: Sichuan Water-Boiled Beef in Red Chili Oil

Sichuan shuizhu niurou: thin-sliced beef, napa cabbage and bean sprouts in a red chili-oil broth topped with dried chilies and Sichuan peppercorns
Prep
25 min
Cook
20 min
Total
45 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Chinese (Sichuan)

Shuizhu niurou (水煮牛肉) is Sichuan boiled beef: sliced beef poached in Pixian doubanjiang red oil, finished with sizzling oil. Includes substitutes and fixes.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Marinate the beef

10 min

Massaging potato starch, soy sauce and Shaoxing wine into thin-sliced beef for shuizhu niurou

No heat for this step. If the 12.5 oz (350 g) of thin-sliced beef is in large pieces, cut it into 1.5 inches (4 cm) widths, then massage in 1 tbsp Shaoxing wine, 2 tsp soy sauce, 1/4 tsp salt and 1 tbsp water. Add 1 1/2 tbsp potato starch and mix until the surface of the meat turns a thin, pale white, then coat it with 2 tsp oil at the end. The oil should be evenly distributed, the meat should look glossy, and the slices should come apart one by one when you lift them with chopsticks.

STEP22 / 6

Cook the vegetables first

6 min

Briefly blanching napa cabbage and bean sprouts in a wok and laying them in a bowl

Bring 2½ cups (600 ml) water to a boil over high heat in a wok or deep skillet, and blanch the 9 oz (250 g) napa cabbage for 2 minutes and the 7 oz (200 g) bean sprouts for 40 seconds. Lift them out when the white stems of the cabbage turn slightly translucent and the sprouts are limp but not broken. Drain, spread them in a large serving bowl, and scatter half of the thinly sliced white part of the leek on top.

STEP33 / 6

Fry the doubanjiang into a red oil

5 min

Frying doubanjiang, garlic, ginger, chilies and Sichuan pepper in a wok to release red oil

Wipe out the pan, add 2 tbsp oil, 2 cloves' worth of sliced garlic, 20 g ginger matchsticks, half of the dried chilies and 1 tsp Sichuan peppercorns, and set over medium-low heat. When it smells fragrant, add 2 tbsp Pixian doubanjiang and fry for about 2 minutes. Move on once the paste has dissolved into the oil, red oil is seeping out at the bottom of the pan and the edges of the garlic are lightly colored. If it looks about to scorch black, turn the heat down to low right away.

STEP44 / 6

Bring the broth to a simmer and slide in the beef

5 min

Adding thin-sliced beef one piece at a time to the red broth and cooking it briefly

Add 2 cups (450 ml) chicken stock, 1 tbsp soy sauce and 1 tsp sugar and bring to a gentle bubble over medium heat. A hard boil makes the meat shrink, so adjust to medium-low, with bubbles rising quietly from the bottom of the pan. Add the beef one slice at a time, loosening it gently with chopsticks. When about 80 percent of the pink is gone and the surface looks smooth and whitish, turn off the heat. Not letting it keep boiling hard is what decides whether it stays tender.

STEP55 / 6

Pour everything over the vegetables

3 min

Pouring the cooked beef and red broth over the napa cabbage and bean sprouts

With the heat still off, pour the beef and broth into the bowl of vegetables. Arrange it so the cabbage and sprouts soak up the red broth and the beef sits on top. Now add 2 tsp black vinegar around the rim of the bowl (not around the sides of the pan); it lightens the heaviness of the oil a little. If the meat sinks too far into the broth, pull it back up with chopsticks.

STEP66 / 6

Sizzle the chilies and Sichuan pepper with hot oil

2 min

Pouring hot oil over chilies, Sichuan pepper and garlic piled on shuizhu niurou to finish

Pile the remaining dried chilies, 2 tsp chili flakes, 1 tsp coarsely crushed Sichuan peppercorns, 2 cloves' worth of chopped garlic and the green part of the leek on top of the beef. Heat 2 tbsp oil in a small pan over medium heat to around 180°C (356°F). Without a thermometer, it's ready when a scrap of leek dropped in immediately throws up fine bubbles. Turn off the heat and pour the oil in a thin stream over the mound of chilies and Sichuan pepper. When it sizzles and the red oil smells fragrant, it's done.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Thin-sliced beef 350 g Chuck eye, trimmings or thin-sliced round. Cut large slices into 4 cm (1 1/2 in) widths
Shaoxing wine 1 tbsp 1 tbsp sake also works
Soy sauce 2 tsp For marinating the beef
Salt 1/4 tsp For the marinade. Don't add more; the doubanjiang is very salty
Potato starch 1 1/2 tbsp Forms the coating that keeps the beef silky. Cornstarch works too
Water 1 tbsp Helps the marinade soak in
Rice bran oil or canola oil 2 tsp For the marinade. Keeps the slices from sticking together
Water for blanching 600 ml For blanching the napa cabbage and bean sprouts. Separate from the water for the soup
Napa cabbage 250 g Cut into 4 cm pieces. Green cabbage also works
Bean sprouts 200 g Soybean sprouts give more crunch
Japanese leek (naganegi) 1 Slice the white part thinly on the diagonal; save the green part for finishing. A few scallions or a small leek can stand in
Garlic 4 cloves Thinly slice half and coarsely chop the other half
Ginger 20 g Cut into 3 cm matchsticks
Pixian doubanjiang 2 tbsp If using regular doubanjiang, up to 2 1/2 tbsp
Dried red chilies 8 g Shake out some of the seeds and cut into 2 cm pieces
Sichuan peppercorns (whole) 2 tsp Half goes into the oil, half into the finish
Coarse chili flakes 2 tsp Korean gochugaru gives color with milder heat
Chicken stock 450 ml Or 450 ml water + 2 tsp chicken bouillon granules. About 1 3/4 cups + 2 tbsp
Soy sauce 1 tbsp For the broth
Sugar 1 tsp Rounds off the edge of the heat
Chinese black vinegar 2 tsp Cuts the richness at the end. 2 tsp rice vinegar also works
Rice bran oil or canola oil 4 tbsp Finishing oil. Olive oil's aroma doesn't suit the dish
Scallions or cilantro 20 g For finishing. If you don't like cilantro, use only scallions
0 / 0

Some evenings you pick up a pack of thin-sliced beef and want neither a stir-fry nor a stew; you want the kitchen to smell of Sichuan pepper. Fry chili bean paste at the bottom of the pot and red oil seeps out, with garlic and ginger close behind. Then you slip the beef in slice by slice, and instead of tightening up it loosens softly in the spicy broth. Shuizhu niurou (shuǐ zhǔ niú ròu / 水煮牛肉) means "water-boiled beef," which sounds pale and mild. It's actually a forceful Sichuan dish built on doubanjiang, dried chilies, Sichuan pepper and hot oil. This home version is gentler on the heat than a Sichuan restaurant's, but it keeps the red oil, the tingling aroma and the tender meat over a bed of vegetables.

What shuizhu niurou is

Shuizhu niurou on the table with rice, a small dish of cucumber and soup

The shuizhu method

In Sichuan cooking, shuizhu means cooking the main ingredient in a spicy broth. Then, at the end, you pour hot oil over chilies and Sichuan pepper to wake up their aroma. The cooking is gentle, but the aroma is strong. The meat slides briefly through a broth seasoned with doubanjiang instead of frying until it toughens, and it lands on vegetables waiting in the bottom of the bowl. That makes it a different thing from an ordinary braise.

Did you know?

Shuizhu is the name of a Sichuan cooking method: made the same way with pork, it becomes shuizhu roupian, and with fish, shuizhu yu.

Like mapo tofu, shuizhu niurou revolves around chili bean paste and Sichuan pepper. Here, though, thin-sliced beef and vegetables take the place of tofu, so at the table it feels almost as satisfying as a hot pot. It also sits apart from other red-oil dishes. Biangbiang noodles are a dry dish where the aromatics bloom on top of the noodles, and chow mein is about stir-frying against a hot wok. Gathering around one big bowl of shuizhu niurou is more like having a small Sichuan hot pot.

Shuizhu in Chengdu and at home

At Chengdu eateries, shuizhu goes well beyond beef to fish, pork, eel and vegetables, and the vegetables underneath and the types of chili change from shop to shop. For shuizhu fish, the flesh is cooked even more briefly so it doesn't break apart; for beef, some places coat it with starch or egg white. Home cooks often use whatever vegetables are cheap that day as the base: napa cabbage, bean sprouts, lettuce, celery or garlic shoots. It's a meat dish, but those vegetables soak up the spicy oil and broth and become a second star.

At home, the key isn't cranking up the heat. Fry the doubanjiang in oil to bring out its fermented aroma; coat the beef in starch and cook it briefly; and use hot oil at the end to wake up the Sichuan pepper and chilies. Stick to those three things and the dish keeps a clear shuizhu outline, even if you go easy on the chilies. Cut back too far on the Sichuan pepper and doubanjiang as well, though, and it drifts toward a plain red beef soup.

Ingredients and amounts for a home kitchen

Ingredients for shuizhu niurou: thin-sliced beef, napa cabbage, bean sprouts, doubanjiang, Sichuan pepper, chilies and aromatics

Serves 4. You don't need expensive beef; chuck eye (shoulder loin) or trimmings are plenty. Rather than thick slices for grilling, choose slices about 0.125 inch (2 mm) thick, which turn tender with a short cook.

Allergies and heat

This recipe uses beef and seasonings with soy and wheat in them. Ingredients in doubanjiang, soy sauce and bouillon granules vary by brand, so check the labels if you have allergies. The numbing tingle of Sichuan pepper is separate from chili heat, so the first time, don't go above 2 tsp; it makes the dish easier to finish.

Ingredients and tools worth a closer look

Doubanjiang, Sichuan pepper, dried chilies and a wok laid out for shuizhu niurou

For shuizhu niurou, the things worth seeking out aren't the beef or the cabbage but the doubanjiang and Sichuan pepper that anchor the aroma, plus a pot that handles hot oil comfortably. Buy ordinary meat and vegetables nearby, and save your attention for the few items that make it taste like Sichuan.

Pixian doubanjiang isn't a sweet bean paste; it's a salty seasoning made by fermenting broad beans with chilies. In shuizhu niurou it provides the red color of the broth, the fermented aroma and the base of the heat. You can make the dish with other doubanjiang, but the depth of aroma changes quite a bit. Look for it at Asian grocers or online.

Whole Sichuan peppercorns are easier to work with than ground. Lightly crushing the whole peppercorns releases an aroma a lot like citrus peel. If someone at the table doesn't like the tingle, put the finishing portion in a separate dish so each person can adjust it.

Because you pour hot oil over the dish at the end, a deep pan is the safer choice. With a wide wok, you can blanch the vegetables, loosen the doubanjiang in oil and make the broth all in one pan.

Choosing ingredients and substitutes for shuizhu niurou

The cut of beef and the vegetables can change to suit your kitchen. The doubanjiang, the Sichuan pepper and the finishing oil are what make it taste of Sichuan.

What makes it taste like Sichuan Why it matters Substitute
Pixian doubanjiang The aroma of fermented broad beans and chilies is the foundation of shuizhu With regular doubanjiang, use a little more and cut back on the sugar
Whole Sichuan peppercorns Brings not just tingle but an almost citrusy aroma With ground Sichuan pepper, start with 1/2 tsp in the finish
Thin-sliced beef Cooks tender in a short time Thin-sliced pork loin
Napa cabbage and bean sprouts Catch the spicy broth and keep the dish from becoming tiring Green cabbage, komatsuna, soybean sprouts
Hot finishing oil Wakes up the chilies and Sichuan pepper at the very end Even if you cut the oil, keep 2 tbsp

With 10.5 oz (300 g) thin-sliced pork loin and the same salt in the marinade, the dish becomes close to shuizhu roupian (boiled pork slices). Shuizhu yu, made with fish, needs more delicate cooking, so beef is the easier place to start.

Any ground red chili will bring heat. The depth that tastes of Sichuan comes from the fermented aroma of Pixian doubanjiang and the citrusy tingle of Sichuan pepper. To keep shopping simple, buy the beef, cabbage and sprouts at the supermarket and limit the specialty items to those two. Everything else is flexible: sake can stand in for the Shaoxing wine, leek for the scallions, and the cilantro can be skipped.

Method: keep the beef tender and raise the red oil

Tip

Shuizhu niurou is a lively dish, but it isn't one you boil hard over high heat. Only the doubanjiang-frying stage is about building aroma; the beef cooks briefly in gently bubbling broth. If you drop all the beef in at once it clumps, so add it while separating the slices with chopsticks.

Common problems with shuizhu niurou and how to fix them

Side-by-side comparison of shuizhu niurou finished with red oil and one with pale color and tough-looking beef

When shuizhu niurou goes wrong, the problem is rarely that it's too spicy. It's usually one of four things: tough beef, oil that isn't red, a thin broth, or bitter Sichuan pepper. Following the steps in order prevents most of them.

What happened Cause Fix
Tough beef It kept cooking in a hard-boiling broth Bring the broth down to a gentle bubble and stop when 80 percent of the pink is gone
Beef clumps together No oil after the starch, or all added at once Add 2 tsp oil to the marinade and slide the slices in one at a time with chopsticks
Oil isn't red The doubanjiang wasn't fried before the broth went in Fry it for 2 minutes over medium-low heat and wait until red oil separates
Bitter The Sichuan pepper or chilies scorched Use medium-low heat for the first Sichuan pepper, and pour the finishing oil after turning off the heat
Too salty Too much doubanjiang and soy sauce Add ½ cup (100 ml) broth and 1 tsp black vinegar to cut the heaviness

If you add more doubanjiang to make it spicier, the salt goes up too. For more heat, add 1 tsp chili flakes instead; for more tingle, add 1/2 tsp Sichuan pepper to the finish.

When people at the table want different levels of heat, use half the chilies in the broth and adjust bowl by bowl at the end. Once the whole platter is spicy, you can't take it back, but right up until the finishing oil you still have a choice. Set aside some beef and vegetables in a separate heatproof bowl for anyone who doesn't like heat, and pour oil over just garlic and scallions. Top only the adults' bowls with chopped chilies and Sichuan pepper, and one pot makes the same dinner for everyone.

Serving and storing shuizhu niurou

Plain white rice is the natural partner, since it soaks up the spicy oil nicely. Light side dishes suit it better than strongly seasoned stir-fries: cucumber dressed with black vinegar, chilled tomatoes, or egg drop soup. Instead of adding another spicy dish, you might plan a different night around the vegetarian Buddha's delight or biryani, with its completely different aromatics.

To store, let it cool slightly, then transfer the beef and vegetables with their broth to a clean container and refrigerate. Eat it by the next day. Reheat in a small saucepan rather than the microwave, over low heat until it bubbles gently, and stop before the beef toughens. If the aroma has faded, a pinch of Sichuan pepper just before eating brings it back.

Freezing isn't recommended. The bean sprouts and cabbage lose their moisture and the coating on the beef breaks down. Leftover broth is easy to turn into a small mala soup the next day with tofu or glass noodles: add ½ cup (100 ml) water, taste for salt, and only then add soy sauce.

Frequently asked questions

Which cut of beef works best?

Thin-sliced chuck eye, trimmings and thin-sliced round all work well. Fatty short plate makes the oil heavy, and thick steak cuts won't turn tender in a short cook. Choose slices about 0.125 inch (2 mm) thick.

How can I adjust it if I don't like Sichuan pepper?

Reduce the Sichuan pepper that goes into the broth to 1/2 tsp and serve the finishing portion on the side. Leaving it out entirely weakens the shuizhu character, but with doubanjiang and chilies it still works as a spicy beef soup.

Can I serve it at a table with kids or people who don't like spicy food?

If you're making it in one pot, use 1 tbsp doubanjiang and halve the dried chilies and chili flakes. After dividing it up, add the hot oil, chilies and Sichuan pepper only to the adults' bowls.

Sources