Sukiyaki: Japanese Beef Hot Pot with Warishita and the Order of Simmering

A sukiyaki pot of beef, negi, grilled tofu and mushrooms simmering in a sweet-savory warishita
Serves
3–4 servings
Cuisine
Japanese

How to make sukiyaki, the Japanese hot pot of thin beef, negi, grilled tofu, shirataki and mushrooms simmered in a sweet-savory warishita of soy sauce, mirin and water at 100ml each, with 4 tbsp sugar. Covers preparing the ingredients, the order of searing and simmering, eating with beaten egg, the difference between Kanto and Kansai styles, and food-safety basics.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Prepare the ingredients

Negi sliced diagonally, with shirataki, mushrooms, shungiku and grilled tofu prepared separately
Cut the negi on the diagonal and prepare the shirataki, mushrooms, greens and tofu separately

Cut the negi diagonally into pieces about 0.5 inches (1 cm) thick. Parboil the shirataki in a separate pot of water and cut it into easy-to-eat lengths. Use this separate water for parboiling, not the ½ cup (100ml) in the warishita. Trim the hard base from the mushrooms, then halve the enoki clusters and the shiitake. Cut the shungiku into lengths of about 2 inches (5 cm). Cut the beef and grilled tofu into easy-to-eat pieces.

STEP22 / 6

Mix the warishita

Warishita of soy sauce, mirin, water and sugar being stirred in a glass bowl
Mix the warishita ahead of time so it is ready to pour

In a bowl, combine the soy sauce, mirin, water and sugar, and stir until the sugar is mixed in. Set it beside the stove. It goes into the pot only after the negi and beef have been seared.

STEP33 / 6

Sear the negi in beef suet

Negi searing in a shallow pot coated with beef suet
Sear the negi in the suet until it smells fragrant

Heat the pot over medium heat and rub the beef suet over the surface so the fat coats it. If you use vegetable oil, spread a thin layer instead. Add the negi and sear until it gives off a toasty aroma.

STEP44 / 6

Sear the beef briefly and add the warishita

Thin beef slices being seared briefly beside browned negi
Sear the beef only briefly, then pour in the warishita

Lay the beef beside the negi and cook it quickly, just until the surface begins to change color. Then pour in the warishita. Use your separate raw-meat chopsticks or tongs to handle the uncooked beef, and keep them apart from your eating utensils.

STEP55 / 6

Add the rest and simmer

Grilled tofu, shirataki, mushrooms and greens simmering in warishita, with tofu being turned
Simmer over medium heat and turn the tofu partway through

Lower the heat to low and add the grilled tofu, shirataki, enoki, shiitake and shungiku. Return the heat to medium and simmer. Turn the tofu over partway through so both sides take up the liquid. Keep simmering until the beef and every other ingredient are cooked through. Don't judge by color alone: heat the food until the center reaches 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute.

STEP66 / 6

Dip in beaten egg and eat

Fully cooked sukiyaki beef, tofu and vegetables served beside a small bowl of beaten egg
Dip the cooked ingredients in beaten egg, or eat them as they are without egg

Once everything is cooked through, beat the 4 eggs and divide them among the individual small bowls for the 3–4 diners, then dip the hot ingredients into them as you eat. Don't let the beaten egg sit out for a long time. Hot food does not cook the egg safely, so if you prefer not to eat raw egg, skip it and eat the fully cooked ingredients as they are. Anyone who should avoid raw egg, including young children, older adults, pregnant people and people with weakened immunity, should skip the egg.

Rice visible in the background is a separate accompaniment, not an ingredient or a required part of this recipe.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Thinly sliced beef chuck roll (gyū kata-rōsu) 10.5 oz (300g) The star of the pot, bringing savory depth. Use thin slices sold for sukiyaki
Grilled tofu (yaki-dōfu) 1 block (9 oz / 250g) Takes up the simmering liquid
Long green onion (negi) 2 stalks (6.5 oz / 190g trimmed) Seared for aroma and sweetness
Shirataki noodles 7 oz (200g) Texture. Parboiled before use
Enoki mushrooms 1 pack Savory flavor and bite
Fresh shiitake mushrooms 4 Aroma
Chrysanthemum greens (shungiku) 3.5 oz (100g) Aroma and a light bitterness
Beef suet (gyūshi), or vegetable oil As needed Coats the pot surface. Vegetable oil works but does not give the aroma of beef fat
Eggs 4 Beaten in individual bowls for dipping
Soy sauce ½ cup (100ml) Warishita
Hon-mirin (true mirin) ½ cup (100ml) Warishita sweetness and gloss
Water ½ cup (100ml) Warishita, loosening the sauce
Sugar 4 tbsp Warishita sweetness
0 / 0

A shallow pot sits in the middle of the table, and thin slices of beef, long green onion (negi), grilled tofu, shirataki noodles, mushrooms and chrysanthemum greens simmer together while everyone reaches in for pieces as they're done. Each bite gets dipped in beaten egg before eating. Sukiyaki is Japan's beef hot pot, and its flavor comes from a sweet-savory sauce of soy sauce, mirin, water and sugar. Cooking takes about 20 minutes, a little more or less depending on how long you parboil the shirataki.

Sukiyaki Styles and Background

Warishita and the Two Styles

The sauce is called warishita, a premixed blend poured into the pot. Mix it first, then sear the negi in beef suet until fragrant, give the beef a brief sear, and pour the warishita in. The tofu, shirataki, mushrooms and greens then take up the sweet-savory liquid as they simmer.

A Kanto-style pot simmering in warishita next to a Kansai-style pot searing beef first
Left: ingredients simmered in a prepared warishita. Right: beef seared first, with sugar and soy sauce added

Sukiyaki is made in two broad styles. In the Kanto style, the warishita is prepared in advance and the ingredients simmer in it. In the Kansai style, the beef is seared first, then sugar and soy sauce go straight into the pot and the liquid is adjusted as you go. This recipe uses a warishita but borrows the Kansai habit of searing first; if you want to cook the Kansai way, use a recipe written for it rather than mixing its amounts into this one.

Both styles vary from household to household. Families in Japan adjust the sweetness, the strength of the liquid and the choice of ingredients to their own taste, and in Aichi Prefecture a regional version for 4 servings uses kombu water in the warishita.

Background of Sukiyaki

Sukiyaki made with beef spread in the early Meiji era, around 1870. The origin of the name, its exact birthplace and its inventor are not clear. What hasn't changed is how it's eaten: ingredients go into one pot in turn, and people serve themselves as each piece is done.

For other ways beef appears in East Asian cooking, see Sichuan shuizhu niurou and Korean japchae. For more about the country's cooking, see the Japan page.

Ingredients for 3–4 Servings

Thinly sliced beef chuck roll, negi, grilled tofu, shirataki, mushrooms and shungiku for sukiyaki
Sukiyaki ingredients: thin beef, negi, grilled tofu, shirataki, mushrooms, shungiku, eggs and the warishita seasonings

These amounts are for 3–4 servings. The 4 eggs are for the whole pot, not 4 per person.

The warishita is soy sauce, mirin and water at ½ cup (100ml) each, plus 4 tbsp sugar. To make it a little sweeter or lighter, adjust after the base is mixed.

A whole-soybean soy sauce works well; an ordinary Japanese dark (koikuchi) soy sauce is also fine.

Allergens and raw meat

This dish contains beef, egg and soy (grilled tofu and soy sauce). Soy sauce can also contain wheat, so check the label of the product you use, along with labels on shirataki, tofu and mirin. Keep the plate, chopsticks and tongs you use for raw beef separate from the ones you eat with.

Equipment

  • A shallow sukiyaki pan or shallow pot
  • Knife and cutting board
  • A small bowl and spoon for mixing the warishita
  • A saucepan for parboiling the shirataki
  • A separate plate and chopsticks or tongs for raw beef
  • Small individual bowls for beaten egg

Choosing Ingredients for Sukiyaki

Beef. Use thin slices of chuck roll sold for sukiyaki. Thin slicing matters because the beef cooks only briefly before it simmers. Leaner thin slices also work, though the sweetness from the fat will be milder.

Tofu. Grilled tofu holds its shape in the simmering liquid. Pressed firm (momen) tofu can stand in, but it breaks apart more easily.

Shirataki. Other konjac noodles will change the flavor and texture.

Shungiku. Its aroma and gentle bitterness are part of the pot's character, and a substitute shifts the flavor. If you dislike it or can't find it, leave it out; the rest of the method stays the same.

Mushrooms. Enoki and shiitake are the base, and shimeji can be added too.

Vegetable oil instead of beef suet. It coats the pot just as well, but you lose the aroma of beef fat.

How to Make Sukiyaki

The order that matters

Mix the warishita ahead of time, but in the pot the order is: suet, negi, beef, then warishita, then everything else.

Fixing Common Sukiyaki Problems

Whatever goes wrong, cook everything through before eating.

Condition Likely cause What to do
The sauce becomes too strong and salty The warishita reduced as it simmered Add the warishita gradually, topping up as it reduces. If it's already too concentrated, add a little water
The beef turns tough It simmered too long after cooking through Sear the beef only briefly before adding the warishita, and take pieces out once cooked through. Never cut heating short for the sake of texture
The shungiku goes limp and dull The thin leaves soften quickly in hot liquid Place it where you can see it and take it out once wilted and cooked
The tofu takes up uneven color It was never turned Turn it over partway through simmering, as in step 5

Serving Sukiyaki and the Zosui Finish

Bring the pot to the table and let everyone take pieces as they're done, dipping them in beaten egg. When the pot is empty, the leftover simmering liquid makes a good zosui (rice porridge). Bring the liquid back to a full boil before adding the rice.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use store-bought warishita?

You can. Sweetness and concentration differ between products, so follow the label for how much to use and whether to dilute it.

Can I eat sukiyaki without raw egg?

Yes. Leave out the egg and eat the ingredients once they are fully cooked. If you want egg but would rather cook it, cook it until the yolk and white are firm. Hot food does not cook raw egg safely, so skip the raw egg if you are unsure.

How should I handle leftovers?

Divide them into shallow containers, cool them quickly and refrigerate. When reheating, heat to 167°F (75°C) or above and bring the liquid to a boil. Eat leftovers soon.

Sources