Arroz a la tumbada comes to the table in a deep bowl: rice stained red with tomato, clams, shrimp, squid and white adductor meat resting on top, and a little broth pooled around the grains. The rice is fully cooked yet slightly soupy, and that broth is the point. This is a traditional dish of the Sotavento region of Veracruz, built on tomato, garlic and herbs, with the seafood added in stages so each piece stays tender.
Arroz a la Tumbada, Veracruz's Soupy Seafood Rice
Arroz a la tumbada is a red, soupy rice made with varied seafood, tomato, oregano, garlic and epazote, and it is a specialty of the Sotavento de Veracruz. It is easy to mistake for seafood paella, but the goals are opposite. A paella aims for dry, separate grains, while this rice is brought to the table with its broth.
It is served as a main course, often with black beans and tortillas or bread. Traditionally it arrives in the cazuela it was cooked in, or in deep bowls. The dish is also tied to Alvarado and its Las Cruces de Mayo celebration.
Recipes with this name vary widely. One version uses rice with fish stock or water and adds fish, shrimp, clams, crab, octopus, langostinos, fish roe and epazote, served in deep bowls with corn tostadas. Another local recipe also builds a soupy rice with fish stock, tomato, seafood and epazote, adding the seafood in stages. The version here uses fish stock but no fish fillet, and its herbs are Yucatan oregano, oreganón, chives, parsley and cilantro in place of epazote. For more dishes from the country, see Mexico.
Ingredients (6 Servings)

1 cup is 240 ml, 1 tbsp is 15 ml and 1 tsp is 5 ml. Do not swap in a 180 ml Japanese rice cup or a 200 ml Japanese measuring cup. Measure the rice by volume, not by weight.
The recipe lists 1 tsp of salt for the rice. The shrimp get "a little salt," but no amount is given. Season the shrimp lightly and taste the broth at the end.
Equipment
- A small saucepan for cooking the tomato
- A wide, heavy pot with a lid, large enough for the rice, broth and seafood with room to spare at a boil
- Tongs and a plate for the seared shrimp
- A blender and strainer for the tomato
- Measuring cups and spoons
- A food thermometer, to check the seafood's center
Choosing Ingredients for Arroz a la Tumbada
Fish stock. Water can replace fish stock, and stock can replace part or all of the water if you have enough. All water works, though the broth will taste less of the sea. If you use a prepared stock, read its label for added ingredients and allergens.
Callo de hacha. In Mexico this is the adductor meat of pen shells, Atrina rigida and Pinna rugosa, and the white adductor is the part that is eaten. Scallop adductors come from a different shellfish. They work as a substitute, but expect a different result.
Yucatan oregano and oreganón. These are two separate ingredients, and ordinary dried supermarket oregano is something else again. If you can find only one of the two, the flavor will shift and the dish becomes your own variation.
Parsley. Use either 2 tbsp of chopped ordinary parsley or 4 whole parsley ranchero leaves, which are removed before eating. Pick one option, not both. Any clam species will do for the clams.
Allergens. This dish contains shrimp, squid, bivalves (clams and pen-shell adductor) and fish in the stock.
Method: Tomato First, Seafood in Stages
The rice cooks for about 25 minutes under the lid. The clams go in halfway through that time. The remaining seafood and the herbs go in near the end, so watch the rice and the seafood.
Fixing Arroz a la Tumbada
| What you see | What to check | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| The rice has gone dry, like a paella | The dish should finish slightly soupy | Watch for broth around the grains during the last stretch of cooking |
| The herbs look dull and dark | Whether they went in early | Add them near the end so they stay green |
| The shrimp look done but you are unsure | The first sear does not cook them through | Make sure they went back into the pot and their centers reached 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute |
| The clams have opened | An open shell alone is not proof of safety | Check the heat with a thermometer, and follow any "for cooking" label or local instructions |
| The salt seems off | The shrimp salt has no listed amount | Taste near the end, which is when the recipe says to adjust the salt |
Achiote and Leftovers
For extra color, you can add 1/4 tsp Tabasco achiote paste (pasta de achiote tabasqueño). Dissolve it in 2 tbsp water, separate from the 4 cups of water. Fry it briefly after the rice and aromatics, then add the reserved tomato.
Leftover rice and seafood shouldn't sit at room temperature for long. Divide them into shallow containers, cool them quickly and refrigerate. Reheat to at least 167°F (75°C).
Frequently Asked Questions
How is this different from seafood paella?
Arroz a la tumbada is red with tomato and slightly soupy, while a paella has dry, separate grains. Serve it with its broth in deep bowls or in the cooking pot.
Isn't epazote supposed to be in it?
Several other versions use epazote. This one uses Yucatan oregano, oreganón, chives, parsley and cilantro instead, so adding epazote changes the recipe.
How do I know the seafood is cooked?
Go by temperature rather than the rice's cooking time. The center of the shrimp, squid and adductor meat should reach 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute. An opened clam shell on its own is not proof of safety.














