Belizean Stew Chicken: Chicken Simmered with Red Recado

Belizean stew chicken simmered in red recado, served with rice
Prep
2 hr 20 min
Cook
1 hr 15 min
Total
3 hr 35 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Belizean

A recipe for stew chicken, a Sunday staple in Belize, Central America. Bone-in chicken is seasoned with red annatto spice paste (recado), soy sauce, and Worcestershire sauce, browned, then simmered with bell peppers and onion. Covers the Creole table with rice and beans and substitutes for recado.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Loosen the recado and rub it into the chicken

Rubbing red recado into bone-in chicken to dye it all red
Rub it in until the whole surface is dyed an even red

Loosen 1 1/2 tbsp red recado with a little vegetable oil (for the quick version, mix the annatto powder, vinegar, and oil into a paste). Spread it evenly over the chicken and rub it in for 1–2 minutes until the whole surface is dyed an even red. If lumps of recado remain, that spot will be darker.

STEP22 / 6

Season and rest

Rubbing seasoning into the chicken in a storage bag and resting it in the refrigerator
Press out the air, close the bag, and rest in the refrigerator at least 2 hours

Put the chicken in a storage bag and add the soy sauce, Worcestershire sauce, ginger, garlic, cumin, oregano, and thyme. Rub from outside the bag to coat everything, press out the air, and close it. Leave in the refrigerator for at least 2 hours, ideally overnight. Take it out of the bag before browning, and keep the marinade rather than discarding it, since it goes back into the pot later.

STEP33 / 6

Brown the chicken

Browning red-seasoned chicken skin side down in a skillet
Flip when the skin is deep reddish brown and releases easily

Heat 1 tbsp coconut oil in a deep skillet or pot over medium heat and lay the chicken in skin side down. Without moving it, cook 4–5 minutes, and when the skin turns deep reddish brown and releases easily, flip it and cook the other side 3–4 minutes. Because it has recado and soy sauce, it scorches easily; if it starts to turn black, lower the heat. When browned, take it out for now.

STEP44 / 6

Sauté the bell peppers and onion

Sautéing bell peppers and onion in the pan juices from the chicken
The onion is translucent and the vegetables soften

In the skillet after the chicken is out, add the bell peppers and onion and cook over medium heat for 3–4 minutes. Mix so the red oil and pan juices in the skillet coat the vegetables, and move on when the oil has coated everything and the onion is translucent and softened. Scraping the pan juices stuck to the bottom with a wooden spoon and mixing them into the vegetables deepens the flavor of the stew.

STEP55 / 6

Return the chicken and simmer

Returning the chicken, adding marinade and water, and simmering over low heat
The cooking liquid becomes a thick gravy

Return the chicken to the skillet and add the reserved marinade and just enough water (about 1¾ cups (400 ml)) to cover the chicken. Bring to a boil over high heat, then lower to low, set the lid on slightly ajar, and simmer for about 1 hour. If the liquid reduces too much along the way, add hot water a little at a time. It is done when the liquid becomes a thick gravy and a chopstick goes easily into the chicken.

STEP66 / 6

Taste and serve

Serving stew chicken over rice with gravy poured on top
Chicken on rice with plenty of gravy

Taste the liquid and adjust with a little salt if it needs it. Because soy sauce and Worcestershire sauce carry saltiness, you often will not need to add salt. Put rice on a plate, set the chicken on it, and ladle plenty of gravy with the peppers and onion over it. Check that the chicken is cooked through to the bone and no red juices run.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Seasoning the chicken

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Bone-in chicken 2.25 lb (1 kg) Bone-in thighs or drumsticks. Halve if large
Red recado 1 1/2 tbsp Achiote paste. If you have none, the quick version below
Soy sauce 1 tbsp
Worcestershire sauce 1 tbsp
Ginger 1 tbsp Grated
Garlic 1 clove Grated
Cumin (ground) 1 tsp
Dried oregano 1 tsp
Dried thyme 1 tsp
2 / 3

Quick red recado (if you have no recado)

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Annatto powder 2 tsp The star of the color
Vinegar 1 tbsp Plain distilled vinegar
Vegetable oil 1 tsp
3 / 3

For the stew

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Coconut oil 1 tbsp Vegetable oil also works
Green bell peppers 2 Cut into thin strips. Mixing in red and yellow peppers adds color
Onion 1 Thinly sliced
Water 2 cups (about 400 ml) Enough to cover the chicken. Adjust to the size of the pot
0 / 0

In the skillet, the red-stained chicken sizzles as it browns to a deep reddish brown. Then it goes back in with softened bell peppers and onion, covered, and after an hour of simmering the liquid has turned into a thick gravy. This is stew chicken, the chicken stew of Belize, a small country in Central America, where it is the familiar dish eaten with rice and beans at Sunday lunch. Its red color comes from "recado," a spice paste made from annatto seeds.

Stew Chicken in Belize

Stew chicken, rice and beans, and potato salad on a Belizean family's Sunday table

Sunday Rice and Beans

Belize lies between Mexico and Guatemala, facing the Caribbean Sea. Its neighbors in Central America speak Spanish, but Belize's official language is English, and it has a deeply rooted Creole culture descended from people of African and European ancestry. The Creole table is built on coconut milk and coconut oil, rice, beans, chicken, and fish.

At the center of that table is rice and beans, a staple of Belizean Sunday dinner. The rice and beans are cooked in coconut and served with stewed meat or fried fish, plus potato salad or coleslaw. The stewed meat is chicken or gibnut, a large rodent that lives in the forest. Of the two, stew chicken is the one that's easy to make elsewhere.

Rice and beans with stew chicken is the meal you see most often in Belize. You'll find it everywhere in the country, even out on the offshore islands, the cayes.

Good to know

Traditional Belizean Creole cooking is done over an improvised outdoor stove called a "fire hearth."

Red Recado

Bone-in chicken rubbed with red recado, and red recado paste in a bowl

Red recado is what gives stew chicken its color and aroma. It is a spice paste made in Belize and Central America, colored red with annatto from the seeds of the achiote tree. Even a small amount stains the meat a vivid reddish brown and adds a mild, earthy aroma, with almost no heat.

Here the recado is combined with soy sauce and Worcestershire sauce to season the chicken. Soy sauce came from East Asia and Worcestershire sauce from England, so annatto, long used in Central America, ends up in one pot with seasonings from far away. That suits Belize, a table shaped by the many different people who have passed through.

Good to know

Besides the red, there is also a "black recado," made by charring chiles black. Black recado is used in dishes such as relleno negro from the Yucatán Peninsula of Mexico, Belize's neighbor. Stew chicken uses the red one.


Ingredients (serves 4)

Stew chicken ingredients: bone-in chicken, annatto, bell pepper, onion, soy sauce, Worcestershire sauce, ginger, garlic, cumin, oregano, and thyme

This formula uses ingredients that are easy to get. Red recado is sometimes sold as achiote paste at Latin American grocers or online. If you cannot get it, substitute the quick version made with annatto powder, vinegar, and garlic.

Tip

Annatto powder is a spice made by grinding the seeds of the achiote tree, used for coloring in Latin American and Filipino cooking. The quick version has a simpler aroma than Belizean store-bought recado, so do not skip the cumin and oregano to make up the aroma.

Warning

Annatto's red color is hard to remove once it gets on hands, cutting boards, or cloths. Wear disposable gloves when rubbing it into the chicken, and avoid a white cutting board. Soy sauce and Worcestershire sauce contain wheat and soy, so check the ingredients if anyone has allergies.

Choosing Recado and Chicken

Achiote paste and annatto powder side by side for comparison

Recado and achiote paste are both red spice pastes made with annatto (achiote) seeds. The other spices vary by maker, but either one works for stew chicken, and achiote paste is often easier to find, sold as an ingredient for Mexican cooking.

Tip

Bone-in meat stays moist as it simmers, and the bones add broth. If you make it with breast meat, shorten the simmering time to about 30 minutes so it does not get too firm.


How to Make Stew Chicken

Including the 2 hours of resting in the refrigerator after seasoning, allow about 2 hours 20 minutes of prep and about 1 hour 15 minutes to brown and simmer. If you have time, seasoning the night before lets the flavor soak in well.

Warning

In bone-in chicken, the area around the bone is the last place to cook through. If you shorten the simmering time, push a skewer into the thickest part and make sure clear juices run before eating.

Getting a Thick Stew Chicken Gravy

Checking the thickness of the stew chicken gravy with a spoon

The gravy gets no flour. It thickens on its own from the gelatin the chicken releases and from the recado and onion as they cook down. Simmering with the lid slightly ajar lets moisture escape slowly so the liquid concentrates.

Tip

If the gravy is still thin after an hour of simmering, remove the lid and reduce over medium heat for about 5 minutes. If it reduces too much, thin it by adding hot water 2 tbsp at a time.

Take the time to brown the chicken well first. Browning renders fat from the skin, adds a toasty flavor, and deepens the color of the gravy. Chicken that goes straight into the pot gives you a pale stew with a vague taste.

Serving Stew Chicken

Rice and beans cooked in coconut milk with stew chicken

For a proper Belizean meal, make rice and beans instead of plain white rice. Soften red kidney beans with garlic and onion, add coconut milk, then add the rice and cook it. Canned red kidney beans make it easy.

On the side, potato salad or coleslaw is essential on a Belizean Sunday plate. Add sweetly fried plantain and you have a plate like you'd get at a Belizean eatery, with sweetness, saltiness, and spice all together.

A finished plate of stew chicken, rice and beans, potato salad, and fried plantain
With rice and beans, potato salad, and fried plantain alongside

Spoon rice and beans or plain rice onto a plate, set the stew chicken on top, and ladle on plenty of gravy. The best bite is gravy-soaked rice and chicken together. If you want heat, put hot pepper sauce on the table.

To try another Belizean dish, cook chimole, a chicken soup simmered in black recado, alongside this one and taste the difference between red and black recado. For more Caribbean chicken, Jamaica's jerk chicken uses its spices in a completely different way.

FAQ

Can I shorten the seasoning time?

Give it at least 2 hours. With less time, the recado's color and aroma only reach the surface of the meat. Seasoning the night before is the surest.

Can I make it ahead?

Yes. Once it has cooled, refrigerate it in an airtight container, and when you reheat it, make sure it's hot all the way to the center. Eat it up soon.

Sources