How to Make Chimole: Belize's Black Chicken Soup

Belizean chimole: chicken, boiled eggs, and potatoes floating in a black broth
Prep
30 min
Cook
55 min
Total
1 hr 25 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Belizean

How to make chimole (Chimole / Black Dinna), Belize's black chicken soup. A stand-in for days without black recado, how to simmer the chicken and boiled eggs, heat that avoids scorching, adjusting the spice, shopping for local ingredients, eating it with rice or tortillas, and storing it for the next day, set out for a home kitchen.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 8

Season the chicken with salt and lime

8 min (plus 15 min resting)

Lime, salt, and black pepper being rubbed into chicken
Season the chicken first with salt and lime. Settle the flavor of the meat before it goes into the black broth

Cut 2 lb (900 g) chicken into pieces about 1.5 inches (4 cm) across and pat off excess moisture with paper. Rub all over with 1 1/4 tsp salt, 1/2 tsp black pepper, and 1 tbsp lime juice. Rest in the refrigerator for 15 minutes. No heat is needed. The surface should be slightly moist and smell of lime.

STEP22 / 8

Boil the eggs and cut the aromatics

15 min

Eggs being boiled while onion, tomato, potatoes, and aromatics are cut
Boil the eggs first. Returning them to the black broth at the end keeps the whites from breaking up

Put 4 eggs in a small pot with water to cover and bring to a boil over medium heat. Once boiling, drop to medium-low heat and boil quietly for 10 minutes. Move to cold water, peel, and cut in half. At the same time, cut the onion into 0.5 inches (1 cm) dice, chop the garlic, cut the tomatoes into 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) dice, and cut the potatoes into bite-size pieces. Yolks should be set in the center, and the whites should be whole.

STEP33 / 8

Dissolve the black recado in warm water

6 min

A black-recado-style paste being dissolved in warm water
Do not put black recado straight into the pot; dissolve it first in warm water to avoid scorching and lumps

If you are using 1.5 oz (45 g) black recado, loosen it little by little with ½ cup (150 ml) of 60 to 70°C warm water. For the substitute paste, mix the annatto, allspice, cumin, oregano, black pepper, cloves, cinnamon, unsweetened cocoa, soy sauce, vinegar, and warm water together. No heat is used. If lumps remain they become black specks in the pot, so press them with the back of a spoon until it is a thick sauce.

STEP44 / 8

Brown the chicken and aromatics

10 min

Chicken, onion, and garlic being browned in a heavy pot
Brown only the surface of the chicken over medium-high heat. Build toastiness before simmering in the black broth

Heat 1 tbsp oil in a heavy pot over medium-high heat for 1 minute. Add the chicken skin side down and brown 3 minutes per side. It does not need to cook through. When the chicken has a light browned surface, add the onion and garlic, drop to medium heat, and cook 3 minutes more. The onion should turn translucent, and the bottom should show a light brown savor, not white scorch.

STEP55 / 8

Pour in the black broth and bring to a simmer

7 min

Black recado broth being poured into the pot of chicken
Bring the black broth slowly to a simmer over medium heat. Trace the bottom and do not scorch the black recado

Add the tomatoes, bay leaf, the dissolved black recado, and 3¾ cups (900 ml) water or unsalted chicken stock. Warm over medium heat while tracing the bottom with a wooden spoon, and wait 5 to 7 minutes until it bubbles gently. If gray foam appears on the surface, skim it lightly. Bringing it quickly to a boil over high heat makes the black paste stick to the bottom, so stop when small bubbles come up around the edge of the pot.

STEP66 / 8

Add potatoes and chile and simmer over low heat

25 min

Chicken, potatoes, and chile simmering over low heat in the black broth
Simmer chimole over low heat. Boiling the black broth hard tends to bring bitterness and toughen the meat

Add the potatoes and the habanero whole, and set the lid slightly ajar. Keep it at 85°C to 203°F (95°C) over low to medium-low heat and simmer 25 minutes. The surface should move quietly, with a small bubble rising about every 2 seconds. Twice along the way, gently trace the bottom with a wooden spoon. Move on when a skewer pushed into the chicken lets clear juices run and chopsticks slide easily into the potatoes.

STEP77 / 8

Return the boiled eggs and adjust the seasoning

8 min

Boiled eggs and potatoes being added to the pot of black chimole
Eggs go in last. Warm them only until the whites are dyed black, and finish without breaking them

Add the halved boiled eggs and warm over low heat for 5 minutes. After the eggs go in, do not stir hard; just spoon the broth over them. If it lacks salt, add 1/6 tsp at a time, and if the sourness is heavy, add 1 tsp lime juice. Take out the habanero when the heat is where you want it. The whites should just begin to turn black, and the yolks should stay intact.

STEP88 / 8

Rest briefly and serve

5 min

Chimole served in a deep dish with rice and tortillas alongside
Serve chimole in a deep dish and eat it with rice or tortillas. Adding the heat at the table makes it easy to adjust

Turn off the heat and rest for 5 minutes. If a lot of oil floats on the surface, skim off only 1 tbsp. In a deep dish about 7 inches (18 cm) across, place 2 pieces of chicken, 3 to 4 potatoes, and 2 egg halves, yolk side up, along the edge. Pour the black broth up to 80 percent of the height of the ingredients, scatter cilantro in the center, and put corn tortillas or white rice alongside. Set out pepper sauce and lime at the table so everyone can season to their own heat.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Chicken and broth

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Bone-in chicken thighs, drumettes, or chicken pieces 2 lb (900 g) total With boneless thighs, 1.75 lb (750 g). Cut to about 1.5 inches (4 cm)
Salt 1 1/4 tsp For seasoning. On days you use bouillon, reduce to 1 tsp
Black pepper 1/2 tsp Coarsely ground suits it
Lime juice 1 tbsp 2 tsp lemon juice also works
Onion 1 (about 6.5 oz (180 g)) 0.5 inches (1 cm) dice
Garlic 3 cloves Finely chopped
Tomatoes 2 (about 10.5 oz (300 g)) 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) dice. 7 oz (200 g) canned diced tomatoes also works
Potatoes 2 (about 10.5 oz (300 g)) Bite-size. Waxy potatoes that resist breaking down suit it
Boiled eggs 4 Cut in half. Whole if you like
Water or unsalted chicken stock 3¾ cups (900 ml) Enough to cover the chicken by 70 percent
Oil 1 tbsp For browning the chicken
Cilantro 10 g If you dislike it, a little scallion
Bay leaf 1 Optional
Habanero 1/2 to 1 Put in whole to pass on only the aroma. Omit for less heat
Lime 1/2 For finishing
2 / 3

If you have black recado

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Black recado (recado negro) 1.5 oz (45 g) If it is hot, start with 1 oz (30 g)
Warm water ½ cup (150 ml) 60 to 70°C. Makes it easier to dissolve
Ground cumin 1/2 tsp Only if the aroma of the black recado is weak
Dried oregano 1/2 tsp Too much tastes medicinal
3 / 3

Substitute paste for days without black recado

Ingredient Amount Role
Annatto powder 2 tsp Aroma and color of the red recado family in Belizean cooking
Ground allspice 1 tsp Warm, sweet aroma
Ground cumin 1 tsp Earthy aroma
Dried oregano 1 tsp Herb quality
Black pepper 1/2 tsp Heat and aroma
Ground cloves A pinch Be careful not to overdo it
Ground cinnamon A pinch A sweet afterglow
Unsweetened cocoa powder 1 tsp Black color and a bittersweet note. Sweetened adjusted cocoa will not do
Soy sauce 1 tbsp Color and saltiness. Not a local ingredient but a stand-in
Rice vinegar or apple cider vinegar 2 tsp The sour outline of recado
Warm water ½ cup (120 ml) 60 to 70°C
0 / 0

The first time you make Belizean chimole (Chimole / Chirmole), the color of the pot stops your hand. It is a chicken soup with tomato, yet the broth is black as ink, and when the whites of the boiled eggs float up, a familiar chicken-and-egg soup turns into something from a Central American kitchen. The blackness comes from black recado (recado negro / black recado), a paste with the aroma of annatto, allspice, cumin, oregano, and chile. Under that startling color is a homey soup. It sits somewhere between Guyana's black pepperpot stew and the chile and warm spice of Jamaica's jerk chicken.

What chimole is

Chimole is Belize's black chicken soup, known as Chimole or Chirmole, and in English sometimes as Black Dinna. In Belizean homes it is chicken soup with black recado dissolved into it, filled out with tomato, onion, garlic, potatoes, and boiled eggs, and it turns up at Sunday tables and on special days.

It is closely related to the Yucatán's chilmole and relleno negro. All of them get their black color from charred tortillas and chiles. The main difference is the stuffing: relleno negro and some versions of Black Dinna are filled with meat, while chimole is simply a black chicken soup. For the Yucatán stuffed version, see how to make relleno negro.

Every household has its own way. Some cooks add ground pork or wrap the egg in meat, some use a whole chicken, and some keep the soup thin.

Do not char black recado in your home

Black recado is traditionally made by burning chiles and tortillas until they are quite black. Charring chiles this heavily sends irritating smoke through the kitchen, and a range hood alone cannot handle it safely. Use store-bought black recado, or use the home-friendly substitute paste.

Ingredients (serves 4)

Chicken, eggs, potatoes, tomatoes, and spices for chimole arranged in the kitchen
Ingredients for chimole. Chicken, boiled eggs, potatoes, tomato, and black-recado-style spices are the pillars

This serves 4 with white rice or corn tortillas. Bone-in chicken adds savor to the broth. Boneless thighs also work: shorten the simmering time a little, and stop before the chicken toughens in step 6.

The substitute paste is not black recado. It does not give the aroma of charred chiles. Still, annatto, allspice, cumin, oregano, bitterness, and sourness make a far richer soup than plain chicken and tomato. The first time you make it, put "do not scorch it, and let the chicken absorb the aroma" ahead of getting it black.

Black recado and other chimole ingredients

Black-recado-style ingredients, annatto, allspice, and hot sauce arranged in the kitchen
On days without black recado, build the direction of the aroma with annatto, allspice, cumin, and oregano

Outside Belize, black recado is not on the shelf at the nearby grocery store, and not every online shop carries it reliably. When you have it, use it. On days you can't find it, make a black-recado-style substitute with annatto, allspice, cumin, oregano, and a little cocoa and soy sauce. It keeps what makes chimole taste like chimole and skips the dangerous step of burning chiles at home.

Chicken, eggs, potatoes, tomatoes, and onion are easy to find nearby, so look online only for what your store can't supply.

Shopping priority What to look for online Role in the dish What to get nearby
Top Black recado, or annatto Color of the broth and Central American aroma Chicken, eggs, potatoes
High Allspice Makes the warm aroma of black-recado-style Cumin and oregano from a grocery store are fine
Medium Scotch bonnet-style pepper sauce Adds fragrant heat without fresh chiles Habanero only on days you can get it
Low Corn tortillas Moves closer to the local way of eating White rice is enough

Annatto builds the base of the aroma when there is no black recado. Paprika can bring the color closer, but it can't give you annatto's earthy aroma. Allspice is worth keeping in the pantry too, since it shows up again and again in Caribbean cooking, from jerk chicken to pepperpot.

Adjust the heat at the table, not in the pot. A whole habanero simmered in the soup gives aroma, but if it splits, the heat comes on all at once. The first time you make chimole, put pepper sauce on the table instead.

Method: let the chicken absorb the black broth without scorching

Make chimole in this order: season the chicken, boil the eggs, dissolve the black recado, brown the chicken, simmer in the black broth, return the eggs, and serve. Scorched black paste on the bottom makes the bitterness harsh. Loosen it with warm water before adding it to the pot.

Common chimole mistakes and fixes

Checking the thickness of the black chimole broth with a wooden spoon
The broth of chimole can be thin. Reduce it briefly over low heat only when you want it thicker

Chimole goes wrong when you rush to make it black. Black recado is strongly aromatic, so if it sticks to the bottom over high heat, the bitterness of scorching comes through. If the broth isn't black enough, don't raise the heat; add a little more dissolved paste instead.

State Cause Fix
Strong bitterness The black recado scorched on the bottom, or too much cocoa in the substitute paste Do not scrape the scorch; move it to another pot and thin with ½ cup (100 ml) water and 1 tsp lime juice
Tough chicken It kept boiling hard, or boneless meat was cooked too long Drop to a low 85 to 95°C. For boneless meat, check step 6 at about 18 minutes
Pale color Too little black recado, or a weak color in the substitute paste Add 2 tsp dissolved black recado or 1/2 tsp annatto
Too hot The habanero split, or too much pepper sauce went in the pot Take out the chile, add ½ cup (100 ml) water and half a potato's worth, and simmer 10 minutes
Eggs break up They went in early and cooked too long, or were stirred hard Add the eggs in step 7 and only spoon the broth over them

In Belize, some cooks thicken the broth slightly with bread or corn-based ingredients. Thicken too much the first time, though, and the bottom scorches easily. For a thin broth to pour over white rice, skip it; if you want the broth to cling to tortillas, reduce it over low heat for about 5 minutes at the end.

Serving and storing chimole

How chimole is eaten

For all its black look, chimole is eaten in a homey way. Pick up the chicken with a corn tortilla and scoop up the black broth, or pour it over white rice. Break a boiled egg and let a little yolk melt into the broth, and the comfort of chicken soup comes through ahead of the surprise of the color.

To compare it with other Caribbean tables, try pelau (/recipes/south-america/trinidad/pelau, in Japanese), a sweetly caramelized rice dish; pepperpot, the black meat stew; and the strongly spiced jerk chicken. Among Central American recado dishes, it sits beside Guatemala's kak'ik and Mexico's mole poblano, which show the range of chile, spices, and black sauces.

Menu Suited to How to pair
Chimole, white rice, lime A weekday dinner Finish the broth thin and ladle it over rice
Chimole, corn tortillas, avocado salad A weekend Central American menu Add heat at the table and pick up chicken with the tortillas
Chimole, pelau, pickled cucumber A day for comparing the Caribbean side Serve small portions of the black soup and the sweet rice
Chimole, grilled corn, bean salad A day children eat too Leave out the habanero and put pepper sauce only on the adults' plates

Storage and reheating

Leftover chimole being divided into shallow storage containers
Chimole contains chicken and egg, so cool it quickly in a shallow container and refrigerate

Chimole contains chicken and egg, so cool it promptly once the heat is off. Divide it into shallow containers and refrigerate it once the steam settles, after about 30 minutes. It keeps in the refrigerator for 2 days, or in the freezer for 3 weeks. Take the eggs out before freezing, since freezing ruins the texture of the whites.

To reheat, put one serving and 2 tbsp water in a pot and warm over low heat for 6 to 8 minutes, until the edge of the broth bubbles and the center of the chicken is hot. In a microwave, heat at 600 W for 2 minutes, stir once, and add 1 more minute. Halve the eggs and check them often so they don't burst.

By the next day, the color of the broth has settled a little and the aroma has soaked into the chicken. If it tastes too salty, add 3.5 tbsp (50 ml) water, warm over low heat for 5 minutes, and finish with a few drops of lime. For more heat, add pepper sauce on the plate, not in the pot.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make it without black recado?

Yes, but the result is chimole-style rather than true chimole, because the aroma of charred chiles and tortillas can't be reproduced. The substitute paste gets close with annatto, allspice, cumin, oregano, and a touch of bitterness and sourness. Next time, look for black recado.

Is it lacking without habanero?

Not really. The star is the aroma of black recado more than the heat. If your household dislikes spicy food, skip the habanero and add a few drops of scotch bonnet-style pepper sauce at the table.

Should the eggs go in whole or halved?

Either works. Whole eggs keep their whites intact, while halved eggs let the yolk blend into the black broth. The first time, halve them and warm them in step 7 for easy eating.

How is it different from versions with ground pork?

Belizean Black Dinna and relleno negro have versions with a stuffing of ground pork or beef and egg. This recipe is the chicken-and-egg chimole, easy to make on a weekday. If you add a meat stuffing, cook it through in a separate step to a safe core temperature, and refrigerate it promptly after cooking.

Can I make it for children?

Yes. Leave out the habanero and use a smaller amount of a mild black recado. If you make the substitute paste, reduce the black pepper to 1/4 tsp and put pepper sauce only on the adults' plates.