Pelau Recipe: Trinidad's Burnt-Sugar Chicken and Rice

Trinidadian pelau: chicken colored with caramelized sugar, cooked with pigeon peas and rice
Prep
25 min
Cook
55 min
Total
1 hr 20 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Trinidadian

Pelau, the one-pot chicken and rice of Trinidad and Tobago, browned with caramelized brown sugar. Pigeon peas, coconut milk, adjusting the liquid for short-grain rice, what goes wrong, storage and what to serve alongside.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Marinate the chicken

Marinating chicken for pelau with aromatics and lime
Work the herbs and lime into the chicken, building aroma before it meets the burnt sugar

Cut 1.75 lb (800 g) bone-in chicken thighs at the joint into pieces about 1.5–2.5 inches (4–6 cm), and rub in the lime juice, garlic, scallions, onion, thyme, cilantro stems, black pepper and salt. Mix by hand for about 5 minutes, and when the aromatics coat the surface of the meat evenly, refrigerate for 20 minutes. If you prepare it the day before, reduce the salt to 1 tsp and bring it back to room temperature 30 minutes before cooking.

STEP22 / 7

Burn the sugar to make the color

Burning brown sugar to a deep amber in the pot
Burn the sugar over medium heat and move on the moment it reaches deep amber

Put 2 tbsp oil in a heavy pot and warm over medium heat for 1 minute. Spread 2 1/2 tbsp brown sugar and leave it untouched for 2–3 minutes. When the bubbles get fine and the color goes from dark barley tea to a deep amber, lower the heat. If it turns black and smokes, it is bitter and you have to start over. Stop at the faintly bitter aroma, before the sugar turns completely to carbon.

STEP33 / 7

Sear the chicken

Searing chicken coated in burnt sugar in the pot
Sear the surface of the chicken deep brown, building the color and aroma of pelau

Return the heat to medium-high and add the marinated chicken skin side down. It spatters, so keep your face away from the pot, and don't touch it for the first 2 minutes. When one side has a deep brown gloss, turn it, searing for about 8 minutes in total. Look for a mahogany surface and a thin toasty fond on the bottom of the pot. You don't need to cook it through yet.

STEP44 / 7

Add the rice and coat it in the oil

Adding rice to the pot of burnt sugar and chicken and stir-frying it
Coating the rice in colored oil keeps the flavor from going dull after cooking

Add 2 rice cups of rice, washed and drained in a sieve for 10 minutes, and stir over medium heat for 3 minutes. Scraping the bottom with a wooden spoon, mix until the grains are coated in caramel-colored oil, the edges turn translucent and the aroma rises. Don't press the rice hard here, since it breaks; just turn it from the bottom. If it threatens to stick, add 2 tbsp water.

STEP55 / 7

Add the beans, vegetables and liquid

Adding pigeon peas, vegetables and coconut milk to the pot of pelau
Add the beans and coconut milk, and set the liquid so it just covers the rice

Add the drained pigeon peas, pumpkin, carrot, bell pepper, ¾ cup (200 ml) coconut milk, 1½ cups (360 ml) water or chicken stock and 1 tbsp ketchup. Heat on high for 2–3 minutes, and when the whole pot is simmering, check the seasoning. Aim for a liquid level about 0.25 inch (5 mm) above the surface of the rice. Place the Scotch bonnet whole in the center, taking care not to break it.

STEP66 / 7

Cook over low heat

Cooking pelau over low heat in a pot with the lid slightly ajar
Keep small bubbles over low heat, cooking the rice and chicken slowly

When it boils, cover and cook over low heat for 18 minutes. Open the lid only once along the way, and at the 10-minute mark run a wooden spoon along the bottom of the pot just once. If small bubbles continue at the edge of the pot and you smell a sweet toastiness rather than burning, it is going well. If the liquid disappears early and white cores remain in the rice, add 3 tbsp boiling water.

STEP77 / 7

Rest, then turn from the bottom

Fluffing the cooked pelau gently from the bottom of the pot
A big turn from the bottom after resting evens out the flavor without crushing the grains

After 18 minutes, turn off the heat and rest with the lid on for 12 minutes. Remove the Scotch bonnet, drop in 10 g butter, then turn from the bottom in 3 big folds. It is done when the grains are plump, a thin layer of crust is on the bottom of the pot, and the center of the chicken reaches 167°F (75 °C) or above. If red juices remain near the bone-in meat, cook another 5 minutes over low heat.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Chicken and marinade

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Bone-in chicken thighs 1.75 lb (800 g) Drumsticks or chopped thighs also work
Lime juice 2 tbsp Lemon juice works
Garlic 4 cloves Split into 2 grated and 2 minced
Scallions 4 Sliced thinly. The base of the aroma
Onion 1/2 onion, 4 oz (120 g) Coarsely chopped
Thyme 4 sprigs fresh, or 1 tsp dried Caribbean aroma
Cilantro stems 20 g Stand-in for chadon beni. Increase the scallions if you dislike it
Black pepper 1/2 tsp Coarsely ground
Salt 1 1/2 tsp For the marinade
All-purpose seasoning 1/2 tsp Optional. If you use it, reduce the salt to 1 tsp
2 / 2

For cooking the rice

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Long-grain rice 2 rice cups (about 300 g) Short-grain rice works in the same amount (1 Japanese rice cup is 180 ml). Use a little less liquid
Brown sugar 2 1/2 tbsp Raw cane sugar or light brown sugar also works
Vegetable oil 2 tbsp Rice bran or canola also works
Canned pigeon peas 1 can (about 240 g drained) Substitute black-eyed peas, cooked soybeans or chickpeas
Coconut milk 200 ml Shake well before using
Water or chicken stock 360 ml With short-grain rice, start from 320 ml
Pumpkin 180 g 2 cm cubes. Butternut squash or sweet potato also work
Carrot 1/2 carrot (80 g) 1 cm cubes
Bell pepper 1 1 cm cubes. Stand-in for pimento pepper
Scotch bonnet 1 Add whole and remove at the end
Ketchup 1 tbsp Helps color and tang. Don't overdo it
Butter 10 g For finishing. Optional
0 / 0

Once brown sugar hits the oil in the pot, it melts, the bubbles grow larger, and the color deepens from pale amber to deep brown. Add the chicken at that point, and the kitchen fills with the smell of caramel and meat. That is how pelau starts: Trinidad and Tobago's one-pot chicken and rice, which gets its color and aroma from burnt sugar the way a Japanese takikomi gohan gets its color from soy sauce. Rice, pigeon peas, coconut milk, pumpkin, carrots and aromatics then cook with the chicken. The finished rice is rounded and savory, with the faint bitterness that marks a real pelau.

Trinidadian pelau brought to the table in the pot, with cucumber and lime on the side
Pelau is more fun, in the way of a one-pot dish, when brought to the table in the pot rather than neatly plated

About Trinidad Pelau

Where pelau comes from

The food of Trinidad and Tobago draws on Indian, African, Indigenous, European, Chinese and Middle Eastern cooking, and pelau puts several of those into one pot. The Indian pilaf idea of cooking rice in an aromatic liquid meets the African technique of coloring meat with sugar, and the Caribbean adds beans and coconut. Pelau is known as the unofficial national dish of Trinidad and Tobago.

Among Trinidadian dishes, doubles is the morning street-stall food, made from Indian fried bread and chickpea curry. Pelau belongs to home cooking. You'll find it at weekends, picnics and potlucks, and packed as lunch for the beach.

Spelling and pronunciation

In English it is written pelau. Locally it sounds close to "pelau" or "pilau", and related names such as pileau and cook-up rice appear in different Caribbean countries and households.

The burnt-sugar step

A table with a pot, herbs, beans and rice, evoking Trinidadian home cooking
Pelau is home cooking that brings rice, beans, chicken and herbs together in one pot

Burnt sugar, beans and coconut milk are the heart of pelau, so keep those three as far as you can. The step that matters most is the order: check the color of the sugar before the chicken goes in. If you're used to takikomi gohan, burning sugar on purpose can feel a little frightening. Skip it and color the rice with soy sauce alone, though, and you lose the faintly bitter aroma that makes pelau what it is.

There's a narrow window. Burn the sugar too far and the whole pot turns bitter, so add the chicken when the bubbles are fine and the color looks like dark barley tea. Those few dozen seconds decide the dish.

Element What it means locally What to keep at home
Burnt sugar Color, toasty flavor, the outline of bitterness Stop at deep amber, and add the chicken before black smoke appears
Pigeon peas Bean aroma and substance If unavailable, substitute black-eyed peas, cooked soybeans or chickpeas
Coconut milk The rounded aroma and fat of the rice Too much makes it heavy
Scotch bonnet Aromatic heat Adding it whole and removing it makes the heat easier to control
Chadon beni Green aroma Approximate with cilantro stems, scallions and thyme

Ingredients (serves 4): Decide the Color and the Beans Before the Rice

Ingredients for pelau: chicken, rice, pigeon peas, coconut milk, pumpkin and aromatics laid out
Chicken, rice, beans, coconut milk and burnt sugar form the skeleton of pelau

This serves four as a main dish. It is also good the next day. For a small household, making the full amount and refrigerating the rest gives more of the true pelau pot aroma than halving it. Long-grain rice is the easiest to handle, but short-grain rice also works. In that case, use a little less liquid and rest it longer.

Allergies and heat

Read the labels on all-purpose seasoning, chicken stock and ketchup. Brands differ, and some contain wheat, soy or dairy. Scotch bonnet is a very hot chile. Add it whole without breaking it, and remove it when the rice is done to keep the heat down. If you chop it, wear gloves and keep your hands away from your eyes and mucous membranes.


Choosing Pelau Ingredients and Substitutes

A kitchen with coconut milk, beans, thyme, sugar and chiles, the things that cause hesitation when shopping for pelau
What's worth seeking out for pelau is not rice or chicken, but beans, coconut and Caribbean aromatics

Any supermarket will have the chicken, rice, onion, carrots and pumpkin. The harder items are pigeon peas, coconut milk, thyme, Scotch bonnet and chadon beni. Look for pigeon peas at a Caribbean or import grocery, but don't wear yourself out hunting for them. Beans are easy to substitute, so get the coconut milk and thyme first.

For the closest aroma, choose unsweetened canned coconut milk made for cooking. Coconut drinks in cartons vary in sweetness and water content. Thyme changes the aroma of the whole pot even in small amounts, and dried thyme from a small supermarket jar will do.

The aromatic heat of Scotch bonnet is harder to replace. If you can't get it fresh, keep the pot mild and add a little hot sauce at the table. All-purpose seasoning is optional and handy when you want salt, garlic, pepper and cumin in one step. If you use it, reduce the salt as the ingredient table shows so the saltiness doesn't double up.

Comparing substitutes: pigeon peas and pumpkin against black-eyed peas and ordinary pumpkin
Even on days without pigeon peas, keeping the skeleton of beans and coconut makes it work as a home version of pelau
Ingredient in doubt Closer to local A realistic solution elsewhere Verdict
Rice Parboiled rice, long-grain rice Jasmine rice, short-grain rice Reduce the water by about 2.5 tbsp (40 ml) for short-grain rice
Beans Pigeon peas Black-eyed peas, cooked soybeans, chickpeas The aroma changes but the texture comes through
Pumpkin Sweet calabaza-type pumpkin Ordinary pumpkin It breaks down easily, so cut it into 1 inch (2 cm) cubes and leave it alone until the end
Chadon beni Culantro, bandhania Cilantro stems, scallions, thyme The direction of the aroma differs, but a green outline comes through
Scotch bonnet Add whole Habanero, a hot hot sauce Add it whole the first time and remove it without breaking it
Burnt sugar Brown sugar Raw cane sugar, light brown sugar White sugar colors quickly and scorches easily

The type of rice alone makes a big difference. Long-grain rice separates easily and suits pelau. Short-grain rice holds together sweetly, which is delicious but a step away from the local lightness. On days you use it, drain the washed rice in a sieve for just 10 minutes, reduce the water, and stir as little as possible after resting. Those three steps keep the stickiness down.


Method: Don't Fear the Burnt Sugar, and Don't Fuss with the Rice

Pelau is a one-pot dish, but it isn't just a matter of putting everything in and cooking. The order matters: marinade, burnt sugar, coating the rice in oil, low-heat cooking and resting decide the result. Stir too much and the rice breaks; stir too little and only the bottom scorches. Keep your touch light, and run a wooden spoon along the bottom of the pot just once.

If you use a rice cooker

Do the burnt sugar and the searing of the chicken in a pot, then transfer to the rice cooker together with the rice, beans, vegetables and liquid. With short-grain rice, start the liquid at ¾ cup (200 ml) coconut milk and 1¼ cups (280 ml) water. After the normal cooking cycle, rest for 10 minutes and check that the chicken is cooked. Burning the sugar in the rice cooker alone risks scorching and damage to the appliance, so avoid it.


Common Pelau Problems and Fixes

Comparing a watery pelau with a pot scorched too far, as failure examples
Pelau failures concentrate on the color of the burnt sugar, the amount of liquid and too little resting

The most common mistake is being afraid of the sugar and adding the chicken while the color is still pale. The result is dull, like a mixed rice dish made without soy sauce. The next most common is too much coconut milk and water, which pushes the rice toward porridge. Pelau can be moist, but once the grains are completely crushed it turns heavy.

Failure Cause How to recover
Bitter The sugar turned black and smoked Discard that sugar, wash the pot and start over
Pale color The sugar wasn't burnt enough Compensate with 1 tsp ketchup and 1/2 tsp soy sauce. Next time, burn the sugar darker
Sticky rice Too much liquid, too much stirring Remove the lid and cook over low heat for 3 minutes to drive off moisture, then rest 10 minutes
Rice with a hard core The heat was too low or the water too little Add 3 tbsp boiling water and cook 5 more minutes over low heat
Chicken still red Bone-in pieces too large Take out only the chicken, cover, and cook 5–8 more minutes over low heat
Scorched bottom The heat was too high or the pot too thin Move only the top and don't stir in the scorched bottom

A light brown crust is part of the pleasure of pelau, but a black, bitter layer can't be undone once it's mixed through. If the bottom smells doubtful, leave the wooden spoon out of it and lift only the rice on top onto another plate. Sacrificing the black layer in the pot saves the rest of the dish.


Serving, Variations and Storing Pelau

Serving

Pelau plated with coleslaw, cucumber, lime and hot sauce
Pelau is a rich one-pot rice, so a tart side dish beside it makes it easier to keep eating

Pelau is a meal on its own, but something tart beside it makes it much easier to eat. A simple chow of thinly sliced cucumber dressed with lime, salt and chile works well, and so do cabbage coleslaw or an avocado and tomato salad. For anyone who likes heat, put a few drops of Scotch bonnet hot sauce on the edge of the plate.

To build out a Caribbean table, start with doubles, then try Jamaican jerk chicken or Haitian griot to see how the same chile and thyme get used in different ways. Puerto Rico's pernil and mofongo are good next dishes for the Caribbean pairing of rice, beans and meat.

Variations

Chicken is the easiest version, but there are also versions with pork, beef or salted meat, as well as vegetarian ones. For a vegetarian pelau, replace the chicken with more firm fried tofu and pumpkin, and build the color by cooking onion in the burnt sugar. You lose the chicken's umami, so use vegetable bouillon and a little soaking liquid from dried shiitake instead of chicken stock to give the rice more depth.

Storage

Pelau divided into storage containers, shaped into shallow forms that refrigerate easily
Dividing pelau into shallow containers and cooling it quickly makes it safer to eat the next day

Chicken and rice are stored together here, so cool pelau quickly. Within 2 hours of cooking, move it to shallow containers, and refrigerate once the steam has gone. It keeps 2 days refrigerated or 2 weeks frozen. To reheat, microwave each serving at 600 W for 2 to 2 minutes 30 seconds. If it looks dry, sprinkle on 2 tsp water and cover loosely with plastic wrap. Bone-in meat heats slowly, so keep going until steam rises from the center.


Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make it without pigeon peas?

Yes. Black-eyed peas are the closest match. Cooked soybeans taste slightly Japanese, but they hold their texture well. Chickpeas have a strong aroma, close to the channa in doubles. Whichever you use, rinse canned beans once and adjust the salt at the end.

Is Scotch bonnet essential?

No. It adds aroma and heat, but it isn't one of the core three. If your family dislikes spice, leave it out and add a little hot sauce at the table. Even a whole pepper can suddenly make the pot much hotter if it breaks, so remove it when the rice is done.

How do I change the liquid when using short-grain rice?

For 2 rice cups of long-grain rice, use 200 ml coconut milk and 360 ml water. For short-grain rice, start with 320 ml water and avoid stirring while it cooks, or the rice turns sticky and the pumpkin breaks down. If it still comes out too soft, cut another 2 tbsp of water next time.

Can I use boneless chicken?

Yes. With boneless thighs, 1.5 lb (650 g) is enough. Cut them into 3–4 cm cubes and shorten the searing to about 6 minutes in total. The broth is weaker than with bone-in chicken, so replace half the water with chicken stock to keep the rice from tasting thin. Breast meat dries out easily, so stick with thighs the first time.

Is it good made the day before?

Yes, and the flavors meld overnight. Because it's rice, keep it out of room temperature and refrigerate it as described above. When reheating, add a little water and heat until the rice plumps up again. For a lunch box, reheat it thoroughly in the morning, then let it cool.

Sources