Machher Jhol: Bengali Fish Simmered in Tomato and Spices

Finished machher jhol, plated for six servings
Serves
6 servings
Cuisine
Bengali

How to make machher jhol, a Bengali fish curry, with thick skinless white fish, a reduced tomato and spice sauce, and a short covered finish. This version serves 6 with 12 pieces of fish and includes every step, how to check that the fish is cooked, how it compares with other versions, and its place at the Bangladeshi and Bengali table.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 12

Cut and season the fish

Rubbing the salt and turmeric mixture over all sides of the raw fish
Coat every side of each piece

Cut 3.25 lb (1.5 kg) of skinless, boneless white fish into 12 equal pieces. In a small dish, mix 1 tsp salt and 1 tsp turmeric. Rub the mixture over all sides of the raw fish, and do not taste the raw fish to check the seasoning. Cover the fish and rest it in the refrigerator for 30 minutes, until every piece is evenly coated in yellow.

STEP22 / 12

Prepare the onion, garlic and ginger

Finely grating a white onion
Grate the onion finely

Using a clean board and tools, finely grate the large white onion. Crush the 4 garlic cloves. Peel the 1 inch (2.5 cm) piece of ginger and crush it to a paste. The onion should be finely grated, and the garlic and ginger should be soft and paste-like.

STEP33 / 12

Dice the tomatoes

Cutting tomatoes into 2.5 cm dice
Cut the tomatoes into 2.5 cm dice

Cut 7 oz (200 g) of tomatoes into 1 inch (2.5 cm) dice. Set them aside with the onion, garlic and ginger until the spices go in. The pieces should be even in size.

STEP44 / 12

Sear the fish

Turning the fish to sear its surface
This step only sears the surface

Heat 5 tbsp of the vegetable oil in a wide, shallow pan over medium-high heat. Place the seasoned fish into the hot oil and sear the first side. Turn the fish and sear the remaining surfaces, but do not cook it through at this stage. The surface should be lightly seared, with the centre still raw.

STEP55 / 12

Set the fish aside

Moving the seared fish to a plate
The fish finishes cooking later in the sauce

Lift the seared fish onto a clean plate and leave the oil in the pan. The fish is not fully cooked yet, and it finishes cooking later in the sauce. The plate should hold all the seared pieces, with the oil still in the pan.

STEP66 / 12

Fry the aromatics

Stir-frying the aromatics over medium-high heat for 2 minutes
Keep the aromatics moving for 2 minutes

Add the remaining 1 tbsp of oil to the same pan, then add the grated onion, crushed garlic and ginger paste. Stir over medium-high heat for 2 minutes, keeping the aromatics moving. If they begin to burn or stick, add a splash of water; skip this if they do not. This is separate from the 2½ cups (600 ml) of warm water added later. The aromatics should smell fragrant and look softened, without any burnt edges.

STEP77 / 12

Add the salt and ground spices

Adding 1 teaspoon of chilli powder
Chilli powder is the last ground spice

Add the remaining 2 tsp salt and the remaining 1/2 tsp turmeric to the aromatics. Then add 1 tbsp ground coriander, 1 tsp ground cumin (not whole seeds) and 1 tsp chilli powder. Stir until the spices are mixed through and the paste turns a deep, even colour.

STEP88 / 12

Add the tomatoes and water

Pouring warm water into the pan of ground spices and tomatoes
The fish stays on its plate for now

Add 3 tbsp tomato purée, then the 7 oz (200 g) of diced tomatoes. Pour in 2½ cups (600 ml) warm water, keeping the fish on its plate for now. Cook the sauce for 5 minutes, until it is bubbling and the tomatoes have started to soften.

STEP99 / 12

Reduce the sauce

Oil risen to the surface of the sauce and seeping to the sides of the pan
Look for oil on the surface and at the edges

Reduce the sauce over medium-high heat for 15 minutes, until it thickens. Look for oil on the surface of the sauce and at the sides of the pan. The sauce is ready when oil rises to the surface and seeps to the sides of the pan.

STEP1010 / 12

Return the fish to the sauce

Spooning sauce over all sides of the fish
Coat every side with sauce

Gently place the seared fish back into the reduced sauce, arranging it in a single layer if possible. Spoon the sauce over all sides of the fish. Every piece should be coated with sauce.

STEP1111 / 12

Simmer the fish until cooked through

Cooking the fish in a covered pan over low heat
The closed lid cannot show doneness, so check the fish itself

Lower the heat and add 1/2 tsp sugar. Put the lid on the pan and cook the fish, covered, until it is fully cooked. Expect this to take up to 5 minutes, but do not rely on the clock alone. The fish is done when the center reaches 63°C (145°F), or the flesh is opaque and flakes easily with a fork. If it is not there yet, cover it and keep cooking, then check again.

STEP1212 / 12

Finish with chillies and coriander

The finished fish curry for six servings at the table, with optional white rice served separately
Rice is an optional side

Wash the whole green chillies and the coriander sprigs well under running water. Add the chillies whole to the fully cooked fish, then add the coriander as well. Bring the 6 servings of fish to the table, and serve plain rice on the side if you like.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Thick skinless, boneless white fish, such as cod or halibut 3.25 lb (1.5 kg) The main ingredient, cut into 12 equal pieces
Salt 3 tsp 1 tsp for the fish, 2 tsp for the sauce
Ground turmeric 1 1/2 tsp 1 tsp for the fish, 1/2 tsp for the sauce
Vegetable oil 6 tbsp 5 tbsp to sear the fish, 1 tbsp added before the aromatics
White onion, finely grated 1 large Aromatic base of the sauce
Garlic, crushed 4 cloves Aromatic base of the sauce
Ginger, peeled and crushed to a paste 1 inch (2.5 cm) piece Aromatic base of the sauce
Ground coriander 1 tbsp Ground spice for the sauce
Ground cumin 1 tsp Ground spice for the sauce
Chilli powder 1 tsp Ground spice for the sauce
Tomato purée 3 tbsp Added to the sauce before the diced tomatoes
Tomatoes, cut into 1 inch (2.5 cm) dice 7 oz (200 g) Added to the sauce after the purée
Warm water 2½ cups (600 ml) The liquid for the sauce
Water for the aromatics a little Only if the aromatics burn or stick
Sugar 1/2 tsp Added after the heat is lowered, before the lid goes on
Whole green chillies to taste Garnish
Fresh coriander (cilantro) sprigs to taste Garnish
0 / 0

"Machey bhatey Bangali," goes the saying about the cuisine of Bangladesh, and it places rice and fish at the base of the table. Machher jhol is one of the clearest expressions of that pairing: fish in a light, spiced stew. In this version, thick pieces of white fish are rubbed with salt and turmeric and seared. They are set aside while grated onion, garlic, ginger, ground spices, tomato and warm water cook down in the same pan. Then the fish goes back in to finish in the sauce.

About Machher Jhol

Jhol is a light stew, and fish, vegetables, chicken or meat can all go into it. Machher jhol is the fish version, and it takes many forms. The Bengali table isn't confined to one recipe or one country's borders, and the name also turns up in fish stews in Odia, Maithili and Bhojpuri.

Fish and rice are only part of the picture. Leafy vegetables, lentils and gourds get equal attention, and every region has its own habits. Among the fish dishes of Sylhet is pabda jhol, which makes a good comparison with the pabda family recipe described further down. You can find more dishes from Bangladesh on Sekai Gohan.

The order that matters

Sear the fish without cooking it through. Reduce the sauce on its own until oil rises to the surface and seeps to the sides. Only then, put the fish back in to finish cooking under a lid.

Ingredients: 6 Servings, 12 Pieces of Fish

The ingredients for machher jhol set out separately, including 1.5 kg of skinless, boneless white fish
Everything rests separately before cooking begins

Wash the green chillies and coriander sprigs well under running water before using them.

Equipment

  • Wide, shallow pan with a lid
  • Cutting board and knife
  • Separate clean board and tools for vegetables and garnish
  • Small dish for mixing the salt and turmeric
  • Bowl or dish with a cover for resting the fish
  • Grater
  • Mortar and pestle or another tool for crushing the garlic and ginger
  • Clean plate for the seared fish
  • Spatula and spoon
  • Fork or food thermometer for checking the fish
  • Serving dish

Choosing the Fish and Oil for Machher Jhol

Choose thick, skinless, boneless white fish such as cod or halibut. The recipe makes 6 servings from 12 equal pieces, so cut them evenly and they'll cook at the same pace.

The steps use neutral vegetable oil. Of the 6 tbsp, 5 tbsp go into searing. The last tablespoon goes into the pan after the fish comes out, just before the aromatics, as in other Bengali fish curries. Mustard oil is handled differently, as explained under other versions.

Method: Sear, Build the Sauce, Then Finish the Fish

Reading the steps

Each step is one action, so the list is long. The fish is cooked through only near the end, under the lid.

Fixing Common Machher Jhol Problems

The seasoned fish rests, covered, in the refrigerator, not on the counter. After that, most trouble comes from the sauce. It needs real time to reduce, and it's worth watching the pan rather than the clock.

What you see What to do
The aromatics begin to burn or stick Add a splash of water, then carry on. Don't use the 600 ml of warm water for this
The seared fish is still raw in the center That's expected at this stage. It finishes cooking in the sauce
No oil has appeared after 15 minutes of reducing Keep reducing over medium-high heat until oil rises to the surface and seeps to the sides of the pan
The fish won't fit in one layer Keep the pieces as close to one layer as you can, and spoon sauce over all sides of every piece
The fish isn't opaque after 5 minutes under the lid Keep cooking, covered, and check again until it reaches 63°C (145°F) or is opaque and flakes easily with a fork

Other Versions of Machher Jhol

Plain rice, served separately, is the natural partner. Beyond this recipe, machher jhol changes from kitchen to kitchen. The versions below use different ingredients and methods, so their amounts don't transfer to the recipe above.

Version What makes it different
Mustard oil option Heat the 5 tbsp until smoking hot to remove its bitter pungency, then lower the heat to medium-high before adding the fish
Pabda family recipe Handed down from a father, it uses pabda or catfish, mustard oil and hot water. The fish is seasoned and fried, then joined with a separate paste-based gravy
Rui machher jhol Uses rohu with potatoes and gourds, and mustard oil. Tempering and vegetables follow the second addition of oil
Cod and cauliflower version Uses cod and cauliflower, with mustard oil
Divided mustard oil version Divides mustard oil between the sauce and the fish, and sears the fish in a separate pan
Potato and ghee version Uses potatoes and ghee. The ghee is added to the oil left after frying, before the onion goes in

Frequently Asked Questions

Does this recipe serve 6 or 12?

It makes 6 servings. The 12 refers to the pieces of fish.

Can I use rohu or bone-in fish?

Rohu is the fish used in Bengal, and thick white fish such as cod or halibut stands in for it here. These steps are written for skinless, boneless pieces, so for rohu, a recipe written for it is a better starting point than adapting this one.

Can the fish rest on the counter?

No. Rest the fish, covered, in the refrigerator for 30 minutes.

Is it safe to use the green chillies and coriander uncooked?

They go on as a garnish after the fish is fully cooked. Wash them well under running water, and keep them away from boards, plates and tools used for raw fish.

Sources