Pav Bhaji: Mumbai Street-Style Mashed Vegetable Curry with Buttered Buns

Mumbai street-style pav bhaji: mashed vegetable curry topped with butter, served with onion, lemon, and toasted pav
Prep
20 min
Cook
45 min
Total
1 hr 5 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Indian

A home recipe for Mumbai street pav bhaji: parboiling the vegetables, reducing the tomatoes, mashing to keep some texture, toasting the pav, substituting spices, and storage, with a heat level that keeps the butter from getting heavy.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Parboil the vegetables

15 min

Parboiling potato, cauliflower, carrot, and green peas at a gentle simmer in a pot
Do not break everything down from the start; cook the potato and carrot first, then add the cauliflower and peas

Peel the potatoes and cut into 1 inch (2 cm) cubes, cut the cauliflower into small florets, and cut the carrot into 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) cubes. In a pot, put 3 cups (700 ml) of water, 1/2 tsp of salt, the potato, and the carrot, bring to a boil over medium heat, then simmer at medium-low for 8 minutes. Add the cauliflower and green peas and keep the heat at a gentle 90–95°C simmer for 5 more minutes. Turn off the heat when a bamboo skewer slides easily into the potato and the cauliflower dents slightly when pressed. Reserve about ½ cup (150 ml) of the cooking liquid.

STEP22 / 7

Fry the onion and aromatics

7 min

Frying butter, cumin seeds, onion, ginger, and garlic in a frying pan
Pop the cumin in butter and oil, and fry the onion until lightly colored

Put 1 tbsp of oil and 1 oz (30 g) of butter in a deep frying pan and warm over medium heat. When the butter's foam turns fine, add the cumin seeds and let them pop for about 30 seconds. Add the onion and fry over medium heat for 5 to 6 minutes, and when the edges are light golden, add the ginger, garlic, and green chili. Aromatics turn bitter if they scorch, so move on before the bottom of the pan browns too much.

STEP33 / 7

Reduce the tomatoes and bell pepper

10 min

Reducing tomatoes and bell pepper in a frying pan to make the red masala
Cook off the liquid from the tomatoes before combining with the vegetables, and the flavor will not be diluted on the pav

Chop the tomatoes into 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) pieces and the bell peppers into 0.25 inch (7 mm) pieces, add them, and raise the heat to a strong medium. A lot of liquid comes out at first, but stir with a wooden spoon and reduce for 8 to 10 minutes. The guide is that a little red oil separates at the bottom of the pan, the whole has a plump thickness, and the trace pressed by the spoon holds for an instant. If it is about to scorch, drop to medium-low, and if a raw tomato sourness remains, do not hurry; add 1 to 2 more minutes.

STEP44 / 7

Combine the spices and parboiled vegetables

6 min

Combining parboiled vegetables and spices with the reduced tomato masala
Let the powdered spices blend on low heat, add the parboiled vegetables, then return to medium

Lower to low heat, add the coriander powder, turmeric, Kashmiri chili, garam masala, and 1 tsp of salt, and stir for 30 seconds. If the powdered spices threaten to scorch, add just 2 tbsp of the reserved cooking liquid. Add the parboiled vegetables, return to medium heat, and mix everything. Move on when the whole pan is bubbling, the corners of the potato have broken down a little, the red masala coats evenly with no floury look, and the vegetables hold loosely together.

STEP55 / 7

Mash coarsely in the pan

7 min

Coarsely mashing pav bhaji vegetables with a potato masher in a frying pan
Do not smooth pav bhaji with a blender; keep some texture with a masher for the right feel on the bread

Keep the heat at medium and press the vegetables with a potato masher. Do not make a full paste; aim to leave small pieces of potato and cauliflower for about 30%. If it lacks liquid and the masher feels heavy, add 3.5 tbsp (50 ml) of the cooking liquid at a time. Keep the heat where large bubbles blurp up from the bottom of the pan, and the flavor comes together as you mash.

STEP66 / 7

Thicken and decide the acidity

10 min

Thickly reduced pav bhaji with the trace of a wooden spoon remaining
For the final thickness, the spoon's trace should stay briefly and the bhaji should not slide off the bread

Lower to medium-low, add about ½ cup (150 ml) of water or cooking liquid, and simmer 8 to 10 minutes. When the line drawn with a wooden spoon across the bottom of the pan stays for about 2 seconds and the bhaji does not run off when scooped with bread, add the amchur. If you have no amchur, add 1 tbsp of lemon juice after turning off the heat. Adjust the salt, and at the end melt in 10 g of butter.

STEP77 / 7

Toast the bread in butter

6 min

Toasting small rolls in butter on a flat griddle until the cut faces are golden
Toast the pav in butter just before eating. A golden cut face keeps it from falling apart when wiping up the bhaji

Cut the pav or sandwich rolls in half horizontally. Warm a frying pan or griddle over medium heat and melt 20 g of butter. When the butter foams and smells toasty, lay the rolls cut side down. Over medium heat, 1 to 2 minutes per side: take them out when the cut face is golden, the butter has soaked in, and the surface is slightly crisp. The guide is that the cut side does not go limp when you pick it up. It scorches easily, so drop to medium-low from the second batch.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

For parboiling the vegetables

Ingredient Amount Substitutes and notes
Potatoes 3 medium, about 15 oz (420 g) A floury potato mashes more easily than a waxy one
Cauliflower 1/3 head, about 8 oz (220 g) If frozen, use it still frozen
Carrot 1, about 5.5 oz (150 g) Brings sweetness. If you leave it out, add a little more potato
Green peas 3.5 oz (100 g) Frozen is fine. Edamame changes the aroma, so use a small amount
Water 3 cups (700 ml) Enough to come about 70% of the way up the vegetables
Salt 1/2 tsp For seasoning
2 / 3

For the masala

Ingredient Amount Substitutes and notes
Onion 1 medium, about 7 oz (200 g) Finely chopped
Tomatoes 3 medium, about 15 oz (420 g) If you have no ripe ones, 9 oz (250 g) of canned diced tomatoes
Green bell pepper 2 Plays the role of capsicum in India. The green aroma matters
Ginger 15 g Grated or minced
Garlic 2 cloves Grated or minced
Green chili 1 Leave out if you do not like heat
Butter 1 oz (30 g) Another 20 g is used for the finish
Neutral oil 1 tbsp Butter alone scorches easily
Cumin seeds 1 tsp Whole if possible. If you have only powder, 1/2 tsp
Coriander powder 2 tsp The base that keeps it from tasting like plain curry powder
Turmeric 1/2 tsp Color and earthy aroma
Kashmiri chili powder 1 tsp With ordinary chili powder, start at 1/4 tsp
Garam masala 1 tsp You can add a little more at the end
Amchur (dried mango powder) 1/2 tsp If you have none, 1 tbsp of lemon juice after turning off the heat
Salt 1 tsp Adjust at the end
Water ½–1 cup (150–250 ml) Adjust to how far you reduce it
3 / 3

For just before eating

Ingredient Amount Substitutes and notes
Pav or small dinner rolls 8 Unsweet dinner rolls, round buns, or low-milk rolls
Butter 20 g For toasting the bread
Red onion 1/2 If it is a regular onion, soak it in water for 5 minutes
Lemon 1 Cut into wedges
Cilantro 1/2 bunch A little sliced scallion if you dislike it
Extra butter 10 g, to taste A small piece on top of the plate
0 / 0

Late at night, onions and tomatoes sizzle in the pot until the bottom turns a little red. In go the boiled potato, cauliflower, carrot, and green peas, and you press them roughly with a masher until they melt into a thick mash rather than a tidy curry. Then small buns go into butter in a separate pan, and that smell is pav bhaji. It's a signature street food of Mumbai, in Maharashtra in western India: a tangy, spiced vegetable mash you scoop up with buttered, toasted bread, good as a snack or as a whole meal.


Pav bhaji in Mumbai

Pav is a small white bread roll, and bhaji means a vegetable dish or vegetable curry. The dish began in Mumbai. English-language accounts say it spread among textile mill workers as something easy to eat in a short lunch break. Today it's served everywhere from street stalls to canteens to restaurants, and the sight of vegetables mashed on a big iron griddle, red masala spread out, and pav toasting alongside is one of the emblems of Mumbai street food.

Potato, cauliflower, carrot, green peas, bell pepper, tomato, onion, spices, and bread laid out on a kitchen counter as pav bhaji ingredients
Pav bhaji can use leftover vegetables, but potato, tomato, bell pepper, and the bread form the backbone of the flavor

Pav bhaji has two faces: it uses up leftover vegetables, and it's also a rich street-food feast. The vegetables are flexible (potato, cauliflower, carrot, peas, cabbage, eggplant), but once tomato, bell pepper, butter, lemon, onion, cilantro, and toasted bread come together, it becomes pav bhaji.

What sets it apart is texture and balance. The vegetables fuse in the pot, yet a few pieces of potato and cauliflower survive; the tomato's acidity is reduced down; and the butter and lemon added just before eating give it definition. In a dish like aloo gobi the vegetables stay intact, while here mashing is the main act of cooking.

About the spelling

In English you will see "pav bhaji" and "pao bhaji," and in Hindi and Marathi it is written पाव भाजी.

From the street griddle to a home kitchen

What to look at Mumbai street character Where to land in a home kitchen
Vegetables Mashed hard on an iron griddle Parboil in a pot, mash coarsely in a pan
Bread Small pav toasted in butter An unsweet dinner roll or small sandwich bun
Spices Pav bhaji masala is often used Build it from cumin, coriander, garam masala, and chili
Acidity Lemon, amchur, tomato Lemon is enough for a first batch. Amchur is handy for making ahead
Finish Onion, cilantro, lemon, butter Serve the onion on the side. Add aroma just before eating

Ingredients (serves 4): think of the vegetables, the masala, and the finish separately

This makes a main for four. It is not a side dish but a plate eaten with toasted bread. The heat is kept mild, so you can add green chili or chili powder at the table.

Allergies and dietary restrictions

The bread contains wheat and the butter contains milk. If you avoid dairy you can cook with vegetable oil, though the aroma will be a little lighter than pav bhaji. If you avoid wheat, serving it with toasted rice-flour bread or steamed potatoes makes it easier to eat.


Choosing ingredients and substitutes for pav bhaji

Cumin, coriander, amchur, a masher, a flat griddle, bread, and lemon laid out on a kitchen counter as a shopping photo
More than the vegetables, pav bhaji turns on whole cumin, the sour note, the tool for mashing, and the size of the surface for toasting the bread

Store-bought pav bhaji masala is quicker, but a first batch comes out well with spices you probably already have. If you're setting priorities, look for whole cumin, amchur for acidity, a masher, and a flat griddle. Bread, onion, potato, and tomato are easy to find anywhere.

Cumin seeds give you the street aroma the moment they pop in butter and oil. Powder alone works, but a bag of whole seeds also serves for dal tadka and aloo gobi. Amchur is dried mango powder; lemon can stand in, but amchur adds acidity to the reduced bhaji without adding liquid, which helps when you make it ahead. It also goes into the filling of chana masala and samosas.

The tools matter more than you might think. A blender purees everything into something closer to vegetable soup, while a masher leaves small pieces of potato and cauliflower that sit better on the bread. A flat griddle toasts all the pav at once; a frying pan works, but with a crowd at the table the bhaji cools while you wait on the bread.

Authentic ingredient Substitute What to preserve
Pav Unsweet dinner roll, small sandwich bun A soft bread whose surface cracks lightly when toasted
Pav bhaji masala Cumin, coriander, garam masala, chili, amchur Do not rely on curry powder alone. Add acidity at the end
Amchur Lemon juice, lime juice Without acidity the sweetness of the vegetables feels heavy
Large tava, iron griddle Frying pan, hot plate Toast the bread hot and serve right away
Plenty of butter Less butter plus oil Keeping a bit of milky aroma makes it more like pav bhaji

Sweet pastry rolls are the one substitute to avoid, since their sweetness pushes forward against the acidity and spice. If that's all you have, toast the cut sides well and serve extra lemon and onion to restore the balance.

Curry powder is the other trap. Made with curry powder alone, the dish drifts toward a Japanese home-style potato curry. Keep at least two of these three (cumin seeds, the green aroma of bell pepper, and the final acidity), and the outline of pav bhaji holds. And even with real pav bhaji masala, untoasted bread takes the fun out of it.



Common pav bhaji problems and fixes

A comparison photo of a watery bhaji and a thick bhaji that does not collapse on bread
If pav bhaji is watery, the bread loses. Reduce it until the spoon's trace stays
Problem Cause Fix
Watery Vegetables were added before reducing the tomatoes Simmer uncovered over medium-low for 5 to 8 more minutes
Tastes like curry powder Not enough cumin and acidity Add a little cumin powder and lemon at the end
Vegetable pieces are hard Underparboiled Add 3.5 tbsp (50 ml) of water, cover, and steam-simmer on low for 5 minutes
The bread goes soggy The bhaji is thin, or the cut face was not toasted Reduce the bhaji and toast the cut faces firmly
Greasy Too much butter at the start Keep it moderate while cooking and add a little on the plate

Leftover liquid is the most common problem. Pav bhaji is meant to be scooped with bread, so check the bottom of the pot at the end: draw a line with a wooden spoon, and if liquid fills it right back, keep going. It's ready when the line holds briefly and the surface closes slowly.

The order of cooking prevents most of this. Rather than breaking every vegetable down in a pressure cooker, parboil the potato and firm vegetables, make the onion-and-tomato masala separately, and reduce the tomatoes before the vegetables go back in. Thin tomato makes everything watery and the flavor blurs on the bread; get that order right and a home skillet comes close to the richness of the street.


Serving and storing pav bhaji

A family-style spread of a pot of pav bhaji, toasted bread, onion, cilantro, and lemon on the table
Bring the pot of pav bhaji to the table, and combine onion, lemon, cilantro, and toasted bread yourself for fun

Plate the bhaji with chopped onion, cilantro, and lemon beside it, and top it with a small piece of butter if you like, wiping up the melting part with bread. Keeping the onion out of the pot preserves its aroma and crunch. Break the bread by hand, scoop, and squeeze over a little lemon; it simply tastes more like itself eaten this way than with a spoon.

At Mumbai stalls the bhaji is reheated on the griddle while the pav toasts beside it. At home, keep the bhaji hot in the pot and toast only the bread just before eating. For a full meal, a refreshing raita or a cucumber-and-onion salad makes it easier going, and samosa suits a day when you want something fried, though this one plate is already enough for dinner.

The bhaji keeps 2 days in the refrigerator and 2 weeks in the freezer. Store the bread separately and untoasted, and prepare the onion, lemon, and cilantro separately too. To reheat refrigerated bhaji, warm it in a pot with 2 to 3 tbsp of water over low heat for 5 to 7 minutes, or microwave at 600 W for 2 minutes, stir, then 1 more minute. Frozen bhaji is less likely to turn grainy if thawed in the refrigerator for half a day before heating in a pot over low heat. A little lemon at the end brings back the brightness of a fresh batch.

Next-day leftovers make a good filling for grilled cheese toast. Still, the best bite is the classic one: toasted pav with butter, onion, and lemon all together.


Frequently asked questions

Is pav bhaji masala required?

No. Cumin, coriander, garam masala, chili, and amchur or lemon do the job. If you use a store-bought blend, check the label, since some contain salt; reduce the salt in the recipe a little.

Which vegetables can I include?

Keep potato, tomato, and bell pepper as the backbone. Cauliflower, carrot, green peas, cabbage, and eggplant can be swapped. Watery zucchini or mushrooms tend to thin it out, so use only a small amount and reduce it at the end.

Can I make it with sandwich bread?

Yes, though sandwich bread has a large surface and tends to collapse under the bhaji. Cut thick slices into small pieces and toast the cut faces firmly in butter. A small unsweet roll still comes closer to the real thing.

Can I make a mild version for children?

Yes. Leave out the green chili and replace the Kashmiri chili with paprika powder; adults can add chili, green chili, and lemon on their plates. Even with the heat gone, keep the cumin and the reduced tomato.

Can I reduce the butter?

Yes. Cut the 1 oz (30 g) of butter in the cooking to 15 g and add 1 tbsp more vegetable oil. Keep at least a little butter for toasting the bread, because that's where much of the aroma comes from. If you switch to oil entirely, add more lemon and onion at the end to make up for it.

What goes well with other Indian dishes?

To lighten it, raita; to add beans, dal tadka; to add a vegetable dish, aloo gobi. Since pav bhaji already comes with bread, skip the rice or naan.


Sources consulted

  • Wikipedia, "Pav bhaji": confirmation of its origin in Mumbai, the makeup of the dish, and its main variations.
  • The Guardian, "Meera Sodha's recipe for pav bhaji": confirmation of the home version using leftover vegetables, bread toasted in butter, and eating with lemon and onion.
  • Bon Appetit, "Pav Bhaji With So Much Butter": confirmation of the street-food background and the image of mashing vegetables and toasting bread on a griddle.