Sop Saudara: Makassar Beef Soup with Rice Vermicelli and Perkedel

South Sulawesi sop saudara served with beef, rice vermicelli, perkedel, fried shallots and sambal
Prep
35 min
Cook
1 hr 45 min
Total
2 hr 20 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Indonesian

Sop saudara is a beef soup born in Pangkep, South Sulawesi. Covers the local way of layering rice vermicelli, perkedel, fried shallots and sambal, a version made with beef shank that skips the offal, aroma substitutes, the heat control that goes wrong most easily, storage, and which ingredients are worth buying and which to skip, for a home kitchen.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Make the aromatic paste

10 min

Coarsely crushing the aromatic paste for sop saudara in a mortar
Make a coarse paste of onion, galangal, coriander and cumin to lay the aromatic foundation of the beef soup

Make a coarse paste of the red onion, garlic, ginger, galangal, candlenuts, coriander, cumin, nutmeg, white pepper and 3 tbsp water in a mortar or food processor. It is done when the large pieces of onion are gone, the cumin is lightly broken and it holds together like damp sand. Stopping while a little grain remains, rather than making it fully liquid, makes it easier to cook off the moisture in the next step. Slicing frozen galangal half-thawed keeps the blade from slipping.

STEP22 / 6

Simmer the beef quietly

70 min

Simmering beef soup with lemongrass and makrut lime leaves over low heat
Simmering the beef quietly over low heat keeps the meat from toughening and the soup from clouding

Cut the beef into 1 inch (3 cm) cubes and put it in a pot with 2 quarts (1.8 L) water, 1 tsp salt, lemongrass, makrut lime leaves, bay leaf and cinnamon. Warm over medium heat for about 12 minutes until just short of boiling, skim the foam that rises and drop to low heat. Simmer for 70 minutes with the surface trembling slightly, and check that a skewer goes into the center without resistance. If it is still tough, add ¾ cup (200 ml) water and extend by 15 minutes at a time. A hard boil tightens the meat and clouds the soup.

STEP33 / 6

Shallow-fry the perkedel

18 min

Shallow-frying potato perkedel to serve with sop saudara
Make only the surface of the perkedel toasty in oil at about 170°C so it holds in the soup

Cut 12.5 oz (350 g) potatoes into 1 inch (2 cm) cubes, spread them in a heatproof dish, sprinkle with 2 tbsp water and microwave at 600 W for 7 minutes. Mash while hot and mix in 1 egg, 20 g scallion, 1 tbsp fried shallots and 1/4 tsp salt. When it holds together and doesn't crumble when pressed by hand, shape 8 balls 1.5 inches (4 cm) in diameter. Put in oil 0.5 inches (1 cm) deep, heat to 350°F (170°C) and pan-fry for 2 minutes, then turn and fry 2 minutes more. Take them out when the surface is a pale golden and they spring back a little when touched.

STEP44 / 6

Fry the aromatic paste and return it to the soup

12 min

Returning the fried aromatic paste to the beef soup to finish
Frying the paste until oil seeps out before returning it to the soup leaves less raw taste

Put 2 tbsp oil in a skillet and fry the aromatic paste over medium-low heat for 8 minutes. When the moisture has cooked off, the paste feels heavy on the spatula and oil seeps out at the edge. Once the raw smell of onion and garlic is gone, you have a smooth, heavy paste. Add 2 ladlefuls of soup from the beef pot and scrape the bottom of the pan, then return the fried paste to the pot. Simmer 4 minutes over low heat and check that the soup changes from brown to a slightly deeper color. Don't mix in any burnt black bits.

STEP55 / 6

Prepare the rice vermicelli and rice

12 min

Preparing rice vermicelli, lontong-style rice, boiled eggs and lime for sop saudara
The vermicelli and rice are combined in the bowl, so drain them first without simmering them in the pot

Soak 3.5 oz (100 g) rice vermicelli in water at about 176°F (80°C) for 4 to 5 minutes, following the package, and drain in a sieve. Drain it when there is no core if pinched with your fingers and it bends without breaking. For lontong-style, cut the chilled rice into 1 inch (2.5 cm) cubes; if serving separately, portion 5.5 oz (150 g) per person. Halve the boiled eggs, cut the lime into wedges and chop the scallion and celery leaves fine. The trick is not to simmer the vermicelli in the pot.

STEP66 / 6

Assemble the bowls and pour in hot soup

5 min

Pouring sop saudara soup into a bowl with rice vermicelli and lontong-style rice
Combine rice vermicelli, rice, beef and perkedel in the bowl and pour hot soup over to finish

Rewarm the soup over medium heat for 3 minutes, and when the sides of the pot simmer, drop to low heat. Adjust with 1/4 tsp salt and 1/2 tsp raw cane sugar so that it is slightly strong, to eat with rice. Put the vermicelli, beef, perkedel and boiled egg in a bowl and pour in about 1¼ cups (300 ml) of hot soup. If putting rice in the bowl, add about 2.75 oz (80 g) here; if serving separately, set it beside. Top with 1 tbsp fried shallots, scallion and celery leaves and serve with lime and sambal. Rather than dissolving all the sambal at the start, add 1/2 tsp at a time after the first bite to keep the aroma of the beef broth.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Beef soup

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Beef shank or chuck, in a piece 1.5 lb (650 g) Beef cut for stew also works. Cut into 1 inch (3 cm) cubes
Water 2 quarts (1.8 L) About 1.25 quarts (1.2 L) should remain after simmering
Salt 1 1/2 tsp For seasoning the meat and the soup. Adjust at the end
Raw cane sugar 1 tsp Not to sweeten, but to round the edge of the saltiness
Neutral oil 2 tbsp For frying the aromatic paste
Lemongrass 2 stalks Bruise the bottom 4 inches (10 cm). 2 tsp if dried
Makrut lime leaves 4 Frozen is fine. If unavailable, 1 thin strip of lime zest
Bay leaf 1 A stand-in for daun salam. Slightly lighter aroma
Cinnamon stick 1/2 Too much and the sweet scent wins
2 / 3

Aromatic paste

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Red onion or onion 5 oz (140 g) A stand-in for local shallots
Garlic 5 cloves About 25 g
Ginger 20 g Sliced thin
Galangal 20 g If unavailable, add 10 g more ginger. The aroma changes
Candlenuts 3 Substitute 25 g cashews
Ground coriander 1 tbsp The foundation of the beef broth. Don't skip
Cumin seeds 1 tsp 3/4 tsp if ground
Nutmeg 1/4 tsp Too much and the sweet scent wins
White pepper 1/2 tsp Use less if black pepper
Water 3 tbsp To help blend the paste
3 / 3

Toppings for the bowl and finishing

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Dried rice vermicelli 3.5 oz (100 g) Retains more rice aroma than glass noodles
Cooked rice 1.25 lb (600 g) Serve separately as the base. Can be made lontong-style and put in the bowl
Potatoes 12.5 oz (350 g) For the perkedel
Egg 1 Binds the perkedel
Scallions 1.5 oz (40 g) Half for the perkedel, half to finish
Celery leaves or mitsuba 15 g For aroma at the end. If unavailable, use more scallion
Boiled eggs 2 Halved
Fried shallots 5 tbsp A stand-in for bawang goreng
Sambal oelek 4 tsp 1 tsp per person in a separate dish
Lime 1 1/2 if using lemon
Frying oil ¾ cup (200 ml) For shallow-frying the perkedel
0 / 0

Lift the lid on the pot at the end of the day and the smell of beef shank rises with lemongrass and makrut lime leaves, while thin white rice vermicelli shows through the steam. Into the bowl go perkedel, a boiled egg and fried shallots. The heat gets settled at the table, not in the pot: everyone stirs in sambal a little at a time, and that's the fun of making it at home. Sop saudara is a beef soup from Pangkep and Makassar in South Sulawesi. It's a clear, aromatic broth made filling with noodles, potato and egg.

Sop saudara on a table with sambal, lime and fried shallots
Sop saudara is eaten with rice vermicelli, perkedel, fried shallots and lime layered over a beef soup

Sop saudara in South Sulawesi

How sop saudara is eaten

A bowl of sop saudara layers rice vermicelli, potato perkedel, egg and fried shallots over beef broth, and in Makassar it is also eaten with warm rice or grilled milkfish. Eateries often add offal. At Warung Pangkep in Makassar, you can choose beef liver, tripe, fried lung or kikil, the gelatinous cut of beef foot.

It stands apart from other Indonesian soups: soto ayam has chicken in a yellow broth, rawon uses black nuts, and Coto Makassar has a rich, nutty flavor. What sets sop saudara apart from Coto Makassar is the rice vermicelli and perkedel. They stretch a meat soup into something halfway between a staple and a side dish.

A note on spelling

Indonesian uses both spellings, Sop Saudara and Sop Sodara. "Saudara" means brother or relative, but there are several explanations for where the name came from.

Where the name comes from

The history of sop saudara has more than one version. H Abdullah, from Pangkep, has told how he worked in the 1950s at Sop Sentral in Makassar before starting his own shop at Pasar Senggol. He explains the name as "Saya Orang Pangkep, Saudara," meaning "I am a person from Pangkep, brother," and says he added intestine, lung, heart and so on to the beef. Another report names the founder as Haji Dollahi, so the years and names vary. The accounts agree on one thing: people from Pangkep built up the meat-soup business in Makassar.

A third story, recorded in a collection of traditional Indonesian food and drink, says Sop Pangkep came from a shop run by two brothers, and customers started calling it "sop sodara." Whichever version you follow, the name links a person from Pangkep, a shop in Makassar and a friendly relationship with customers.

A bowl for celebrations

Sop saudara wasn't always an everyday restaurant dish. It was served at circumcisions, weddings, birth celebrations, Eid al-Fitr and Eid al-Adha, house moves and thanksgiving gatherings, and Makassar families still make it for celebrations and guests. Noodles, potato and egg turn a single pot of beef soup into a full meal. Piling on the extras is a way of telling a guest, "have this too."

At home, make beef shank the star and prepare the noodles, perkedel, fried shallots, lime and sambal separately. You can skip the offal and still enjoy putting your own bowl together.

Element of the table Meaning locally How to make it at home
Beef or water buffalo, offal Broth and the fun of choosing toppings Use beef shank as the base; offal is optional
Rice vermicelli A thin staple to take up the meat broth Rehydrate dried vermicelli in a separate pot
Perkedel Sweetness of potato and fried toastiness Mash potatoes and make 8
Rice or ketupat A staple to take the soup Serve rice separately, or put a little in the bowl
Lime and sambal Sourness and heat adjusted at the table Serve at the end, apart from the pot

Ingredients (serves 4)

Beef, rice vermicelli, rice, potatoes, aromatics and spices laid out as the ingredients for sop saudara
Prepare the beef, rice vermicelli, potatoes, aromatics and spices separately

This makes four large bowls. If you serve rice separately, as at local eateries, allow about 5.5 oz (150 g) of cooked rice per person. For lontong-style rice in the bowl, press 1 lb (500 g) of cooked rice to a thickness of 1 inch (2 cm), chill it and cut it into 1 inch (2.5 cm) cubes.

Allergies and labeling

This dish uses beef, egg, and candlenuts or the cashews that substitute for them. Store-bought sambal, fried shallots, rice vermicelli and spices can contain wheat, soy, shrimp and so on. If you have a food allergy, check the ingredient label before buying. If you add offal and are unsure about freshness or preparation, don't force it; make it with beef shank alone.

Telling the aromatic ingredients apart

Galangal looks like ginger, but using ginger alone rounds off the outline of the aroma. Its local name is lengkuas, makrut lime leaves are daun jeruk and fried shallots are bawang goreng. When searching at import shops or online, use both the English and local names. If you can't find galangal, increase the ginger by 10 g and grate a little lime zest at the end. The aroma changes, but it disperses the heaviness of the beef.

Choosing ingredients for sop saudara

Galangal, makrut lime leaves, sambal, fried shallots and spices that are easy to hesitate over when shopping for sop saudara
When shopping at import shops or online, what gives the dish its outline is not the beef but galangal, sambal, fried shallots and spices

You can find beef, potatoes, eggs and rice vermicelli at any nearby supermarket. If you want offal, lung or liver can go in, but beef shank is plenty the first time. Two things matter more than the meat: galangal, the heart of the aroma, and frying the aromatic paste in oil before it goes back into the broth.

Galangal

Galangal is worth seeking out. Adding more ginger just makes the soup taste more of ginger, and you lose galangal's slightly hard, woody aroma. Only 20 g goes into the paste, so frozen galangal is the practical buy: look for a pack of about 7 oz (200 g) you can cut from, rather than chilled or powdered, and divide the rest into portions. It earns its place if you also cook soto ayam or rawon. If you'll make this only once, use 10 g more ginger plus a little lime zest. The aroma won't be the same, but it lifts the heaviness of the beef.

Sambal and cumin

Sambal oelek is there so each person can add heat to their own bowl, not to turn the soup red. It's worth buying if your family members differ in how hot they like things. If you rarely eat spicy food, the red pepper flakes you already have, plus lime, will do. Check the ingredient label when you buy.

Cumin is only 1 tsp, but it gives the aromatic paste its shape. Ground cumin that has been open a long time loses its aroma, and then even good galangal won't bring out the depth of the beef. If you cook other Indonesian dishes or curries, pick a reliable brand and stick with it. If the cumin in your cupboard still smells good, or you keep whole cumin on hand, use what you have.

Method: simmer, fry, assemble in the bowl

Fry the aromatic paste in a separate pot and simmer the beef quietly. Don't simmer the rice vermicelli, perkedel, rice and egg in the soup for long. Layering them in order in the bowl lets you keep both the clarity of the broth and the texture of the fried elements.

Don't simmer the perkedel in the soup

If you put perkedel in the pot and simmer it a long time, the potato falls apart and the soup gets heavy. Putting it in the bowl and pouring hot soup over is enough. The toasty surface remains and it soaks up a little soup as you eat. If you are short on time you can use baked potatoes instead of frying, but the aroma of the fried surface weakens.

Fixing cloudy, tough or bland sop saudara

A cloudy beef soup compared with a clear finished sop saudara, showing the causes of failure
Comparing the cloudiness of the soup, the toughness of the meat and the aroma at the end shows how heat and handling of the paste matter

Cloudy soup means the beef boiled too hard. Instead of bringing it to a boil fast over medium heat, take about 12 minutes to warm it, and drop to low heat when the foam gathers. If it has already gone cloudy, turn off the heat, leave it for 10 minutes, skim the foam and excess fat from the surface, then rewarm it over low heat. It won't turn clear again, but it will taste lighter.

Tough beef needs more simmering. Add ¾ cup (200 ml) water and keep going 15 minutes at a time over low heat, with only small bubbles at the edge. Larger pieces take longer, so keep going past 70 minutes if you need to. The beef is done when a skewer slides into the center and the fibers loosen when you press the meat.

A weak aroma means the aromatic paste wasn't fried long enough. Paste that goes straight into the soup keeps the raw taste of onion and garlic and buries the galangal and cumin. Fry it in a skillet over medium-low heat until oil seeps out at the edge. If it smells burnt, loosen the bottom with 2 tbsp water and leave the blackened bits behind.

Too much sambal? Watering it down alone won't fix it. Rehydrate 20 g more vermicelli and add 1.75 oz (50 g) of rice, and squeeze in a little lime to soften the heat. If you add water to the whole pot, do it last so the beef broth keeps its richness.

Serving and storing sop saudara

At the table

Sop saudara on a table with sambal, lime, fried shallots, rice and perkedel
Sambal, lime and fried shallots in separate dishes let each person adjust heat and aroma

Sop saudara is a full meal on its own. For a menu that recalls the Pangkep table, grill a little salted mackerel or white fish under the broiler to serve alongside. On days you don't want fish, warm vegetables like gado-gado are enough.

The sweet peanut sauce of sate ayam can clash with the soup's flavors. If you want another rich beef dish, try rendang. To compare clear soups, move on to soto ayam, which shows off the regional differences in Indonesian cooking.

Put the sambal, lime and fried shallots in separate small dishes. That way only the people who want heat get it, and anyone can add sourness to their own bowl. You don't have to copy the local bowl exactly; let each person finish the flavor.

Storage and reheating

Sop saudara soup, rice vermicelli, rice, perkedel and garnishes stored separately in containers
Storing the soup separately from the vermicelli, rice, perkedel and garnishes keeps the textures the next day

Don't leave the soup sitting in the pot at room temperature. Divide it into shallow containers, cool it as quickly as possible, then refrigerate or freeze. Stews need this care because of Clostridium perfringens (in Japanese). Eat refrigerated soup within about 2 days, counting from the next day. Store the vermicelli, rice, perkedel, garnishes and sambal separately; noodles left in the soup absorb the liquid and make the next day's bowl heavy.

To reheat, warm only the soup in a pot over medium-low heat for about 8 minutes, stirring from the bottom, until it is hot all the way through, at least 167°F (75°C). Pour boiling water over refrigerated vermicelli for 10 seconds to loosen it, and warm the rice in a microwave. Three minutes in a toaster oven brings back the perkedel's crisp surface.

Freeze only the soup and beef. Thaw them in the refrigerator over half a day, then warm over low heat; high heat tightens the meat and separates the fat. If anything seems off in smell or appearance, throw it out rather than tasting it to check.

Frequently asked questions

Do I put the rice in the bowl or serve it separately?

Either works. Serve rice or ketupat alongside, or put about 2.75 oz (80 g) in the bowl. Serving it separately keeps the soup from getting diluted, while rice in the bowl makes it easier to eat as one dish. This recipe serves it separately.

Can I substitute glass noodles for the rice vermicelli?

Yes, though you lose some of the rice aroma and texture. Use 2.75 oz (80 g), soak them a little less than the package says, and drain. Glass noodles feel light in the soup, so keep the perkedel and fried shallots to make the bowl more satisfying.

Sources