Canh Chua Cá: Sweet-and-Sour Fish Soup from the Mekong Delta

Reddish canh chua cá with tomato, pineapple, okra, bean sprouts and white fish, topped with herbs
Prep
15 min
Cook
20 min
Total
35 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Vietnamese

A recipe for canh chua cá, the home-style soup of Vietnam's southern Mekong Delta, made with tamarind, pineapple, tomato, okra and white fish. Covers what the name means, the delta ingredients that go in, making the tamarind liquid, keeping the fish from breaking up and herb substitutes for a home kitchen.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Make the tamarind liquid

5 min

Working a block of tamarind loose in warm water and straining it through a sieve
Dissolve the pulp in warm water and strain to remove the seeds and fibers

Put 2 oz (60 g) of tamarind block in a bowl and pour in 1 cup (240 ml) warm water. Leave it for about 5 minutes, working the pulp loose with your fingers, until the pulp dissolves into the water and the whole thing is a thick brown liquid, then strain through a fine sieve. Press the pulp left in the sieve firmly with the back of a spoon and discard the seeds and fibers. Pressing out the pulp well here gives a solid sourness.

STEP22 / 6

Cut the fish and vegetables

3 min

Fish cut 1.3 cm thick, tomato wedges and diagonally sliced okra
Cut the fish 1.3 cm thick, the tomatoes into wedges and the okra 1 cm wide

Cut the white fish fillets 0.5 inches (1.3 cm) thick. Cut the tomatoes into 8 wedges, trim the stems from the okra and slice it on the diagonal 0.5 inches (1 cm) wide, and cut the pineapple into thin bite-size slices. Roughly chop the herbs and slice the red chile into thin rings. Everything takes about 3 minutes to cut, and having it all ready before the fish goes in prevents overcooking.

STEP33 / 6

Bring the soup to a boil

8–10 min

A pot of soup with tamarind liquid and pineapple coming to a boil over high heat
When it boils, taste it and check the balance of sweet and sour

Put the tamarind liquid, 1.5 quarts (1.4 L) water, 2 tbsp fish sauce, 3.5 oz (100 g) pineapple and 4 tbsp sugar in a pot over high heat. When it comes to a boil after about 8–10 minutes, taste it once. If sour, sweet and salty seem about equal, it is just right. You are ready when a sweet pineapple aroma rises and the soup is a faint amber.

STEP44 / 6

Add the fish and skim

5 min

Adding white fish to the soup and skimming off the scum that rises with a ladle
Once the fish is in, don't stir; just skim off the scum that rises

Gently lower the fish into the boiling soup and wait for it to come back to a boil. When white scum rises to the surface, skim it off with a ladle. Reduce to medium heat and cook for about 5 minutes, until the flesh is white and opaque to the center. Don't stir once the fish is in: stirring breaks up the flesh and clouds the soup. It is a success if the fillets hold their shape without breaking up.

STEP55 / 6

Add the vegetables and bring back to a boil

2 min

Soup brought back to a boil after adding tomatoes, okra and bean sprouts
Turn off the heat when the tomato skins curl and the okra turns bright green

Add the tomatoes, okra and bean sprouts (and bạc hà if you have it) and simmer over medium heat for about 2 minutes until it comes back to a boil. Turn off the heat when the tomato skins have curled a little and the okra is a bright green. The vegetables should keep a crisp texture, so don't overcook them. Taste once more and adjust the sweet-and-sour balance with sugar or fish sauce.

STEP66 / 6

Top with herbs to finish

Topping a bowl of soup with herbs, fried shallots and red chile
Add the herbs after the heat is off and let the residual heat wilt them

After turning off the heat, ladle into bowls so each gets 1–2 pieces of fish and an even share of vegetables, mound the chopped herbs in the center of the soup, and scatter the fried shallots, fried garlic and chile rings over the top. The herbs are best when they just wilt in the residual heat of the hot soup, which is when their aroma is strongest. You can also bring the pot to the table and let everyone add herbs as they eat.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Soup

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Tamarind (pulp block) 2 oz (60 g) Use it with the seeds and fibers and strain the liquid
Warm water (for the tamarind) 1 cup (240 ml) Around 104°F (40°C)
Water 1.5 quarts (1.4 L) —
Fish sauce (nước mắm) 2 tbsp Brands differ in saltiness, so adjust at the end
Sugar 4 tbsp Adjust according to the sourness
Pineapple 3.5 oz (100 g) Thin bite-size slices. If canned, drain the syrup
2 / 3

Fish and vegetables

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
White fish fillets 400–500 g Sea bream, sea bass, cod and so on. Cut 0.5 inches (1.3 cm) thick
Tomatoes 2 Cut into wedges
Okra 2 oz (60 g) Sliced on the diagonal, 0.5 inches (1 cm) wide
Bean sprouts 2 oz (60 g) Removing the root tails gives a cleaner result
Bạc hà (thick taro-relative stems) 2 oz (60 g) If you can get it, peel and slice on the diagonal. Leave it out otherwise
3 / 3

Finishing

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Ngò om (rice paddy herb) 1 bunch If unavailable, leave it out and add a little Thai basil
Sawtooth coriander 1 bunch Cilantro can substitute
Fried shallots 1/2 tsp Store-bought fried onions also work
Fried garlic 1/2 tsp —
Red chile (fresh) 1 Sliced into rings. Leave out if you don't like heat
Jasmine rice 4 servings Cook and serve alongside. Rice noodles also work
0 / 0

Rivers the color of tea run like a net between rice paddies and orchards, and small boats carry fish, pineapples and heaps of herbs. In Vietnam's southern Mekong Delta, that bounty of river and field goes straight into the family pot. Canh chua cá is one of the results: a soup packed with fish and vegetables that brings together the sourness of tamarind, the sweetness of pineapple and the saltiness of fish sauce (nước mắm).

Canh chua cá, the Mekong Delta's sour fish soup

A small boat on a Mekong Delta waterway loaded with fish, pineapples and herbs

"Canh" means soup, "chua" means sour, and "cá" means fish, so the name tells you what to expect: a fish soup with sourness in the lead. The sourness comes from tamarind, and sugar, pineapple and nước mắm (Vietnamese fish sauce) are layered on top. You taste sour, sweet and salty all at once, and that's the charm of it.

The Mekong Delta is blessed with river fish, seafood, vegetables and fruit, and many of its dishes make use of that richness. Canh chua is most often made with a kind of catfish, though snakehead, tilapia, eel or shrimp also go in. Alongside the fish come pineapple, tomato, okra and bean sprouts, plus the thick stems of a taro relative that Vietnamese call bạc hà, all everyday ingredients from the delta's fields and waterways.

Good to know

Among "sour soups," the Philippines' sinigang puts the sourness further forward. Canh chua balances sourness and sweetness with sugar and pineapple, so the first sip tastes gentle.

A Vietnamese family meal sets out rice, side dishes and soup together, and canh chua is a standard soup alongside freshly cooked jasmine rice. Some households make it with chicken or shrimp instead of fish.


Ingredients (serves 4)

The ingredients for canh chua cá: white fish, tamarind, pineapple, tomatoes, okra, bean sprouts and herbs

Tip

Tamarind sourness differs a lot between brands. Make the soup first with the amounts in the table, then adjust the sweet-and-sour balance at the end with sugar and fish sauce, and you won't go wrong. If it's too sour, add sugar 1 tsp at a time; if it's lacking, add fish sauce 1 tsp at a time.

Caution

This dish contains fish and fish sauce. People with a fish allergy should avoid it. Some fried shallots and fried onions are made with wheat flour, so anyone with a wheat allergy should check the ingredient label.

Choosing fish, tamarind and herbs for canh chua cá

White fish fillets, tomatoes, okra, pineapple and tamarind from an ordinary supermarket

White fish fillets from an ordinary supermarket work well, especially firm-fleshed fish such as sea bream, sea bass or cod. The catfish used in Vietnam are hard to find elsewhere, but pangasius (basa), sometimes sold frozen, is a catfish relative from the Mekong. Bone-in fillets give a better broth; just watch for bones when you eat.

Tamarind is the key to the sourness. Indian and Asian grocers and online shops sell it as pressed pulp blocks or paste. Lemon or lime will stand in, but they can't match tamarind's fruity sourness, so try to get tamarind if you can. If you use a block, knead it in warm water and use the strained liquid.

Tip

A block of tamarind keeps for a long time in the refrigerator. Cut off only what you need with a knife, wrap the rest in plastic wrap and keep it in a storage bag, and you can use it in pad thai from Thailand or sambar from India as well.

In Vietnam the soup is finished with a generous handful of ngò om, a lemon-scented herb from the rice paddies, and ngò gai, or sawtooth coriander. Neither is easy to find elsewhere. Ngò om has no true stand-in, but you can leave it out and scatter a little Thai basil; for sawtooth coriander, cilantro comes closest in aroma. Bạc hà is also rare outside Vietnam. Its main job is to soak up the soup, so leaving it out doesn't change the flavor much.


How to make canh chua cá

Plan on about 15 minutes of prep, about 20 minutes of cooking, and about 35 minutes in total. Once the fish goes in, it comes together quickly, so cut the vegetables and herbs first.

Caution

Watch for fish bones. If you use bone-in fillets, remove the large bones when plating, and take particular care when small children or older people will eat it.

Tip

Bean sprouts and okra continue to cook in the residual heat. If there will be a gap before serving, add the vegetables just before eating to keep them crisp.

Serving canh chua cá and ways to vary it

A canh chua cá meal set out with jasmine rice
Set the soup on the table with freshly cooked jasmine rice

Canh chua cá comes to the table with jasmine rice, and you sip the soup between bites. A little soup spooned over the rice in your bowl is good too. Or boil rice noodles, put them in a bowl and pour the soup over, and you have a noodle dish that is complete in one bowl.

To round out a Vietnamese meal, pair it with bánh xèo (in Japanese), a savory pancake that wraps fillings in a thin crepe of rice-flour batter. Together they give you a clear picture of the herb-heavy table of southern Vietnam.

Canh chua made with shrimp and with chicken side by side

Made with shell-on shrimp instead of fish, the soup becomes canh chua tôm. Shrimp cook quickly, so add the vegetables as soon as they turn red and curl up. Some households use thinly sliced chicken breast; cook it until it is white through to the center and no clear juices run out.

The vegetables can change with the season. In summer, use more okra and tomato; in winter, thin slices of celery or Chinese cabbage stems add a crisp texture that suits the soup well. If you like heat, steep chopped red chile in fish sauce and set it on the table so everyone can add as much as they want.

Frequently asked questions

What if I don't have tamarind?

Use lemon or lime juice. Bring the soup to a boil first, then start with 2 tbsp of lemon juice and taste. The flavor will be cleaner and less fruity than with tamarind.

Can I use canned pineapple?

Yes. Drain the syrup well and cut back a little on the sugar. Fresh pineapple gives a stronger sourness and aroma.

Leftover canh chua being moved to a storage container

Can I make it ahead?

The fish and vegetables break down and lose texture as they sit, so finish the soup the day you make it. Cool leftovers slightly and refrigerate them right away, and when reheating, bring the whole pot to a full boil.

What if I don't like herbs?

Leave them out. Sliced scallions scattered on top add color and aroma instead.

Sources