Esh: Chadian Sorghum-Millet Dough with Okra-Peanut Sauce

Chadian esh: a plate of sorghum and millet dough served with okra-peanut sauce
Prep
20 min
Cook
45 min
Total
1 hr 5 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Chadian

Chad's esh, a stiff dough of sorghum and millet flour served with okra-peanut sauce. How to cook the flour, build the sauce, how it is eaten in Chad, substitutions and storage, laid out so you never lose your place in the kitchen.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Mix the flour into water

10 min

Mixing sorghum and millet flour with water to make a slurry
Don't put the flour directly in the pot; dissolve it in water first to get rid of big lumps

No heat is used. In a bowl, put 4 oz (120 g) white sorghum flour, 2 oz (60 g) millet flour and 1 cup (250 ml) water, and mix from the bottom with a whisk. It is heavy at first, but after about 2 minutes the large flour lumps disappear. Set the other 4 oz (120 g) of white sorghum flour aside in a separate dish for stirring in later. The slurry is right when it falls in a thick line as you lift the whisk, the surface is smooth, and no mounds of flour remain.

STEP22 / 6

Fry the base of the sauce

12 min

Frying onion, garlic and tomato in a pot to make the base of the okra sauce
Cook off the water of the tomatoes over medium heat to make a red base that holds okra and peanuts

Warm a heavy frying pan or small pot over medium heat and add 2 tbsp rice bran oil. Add the beef and sear for 2 minutes; when the surface is no longer red, add the onion. Keeping the heat at medium, fry for 5 minutes until the onion is translucent, then add garlic, tomatoes, chile and black pepper. Fry another 5 minutes until the corners of the tomatoes collapse and a thin red paste remains on the bottom of the pot. Cooking off the water here keeps the sauce from turning watery later.

STEP33 / 6

Simmer the okra and peanuts

18 min

Loosening unsweetened peanut butter with hot cooking liquid and adding it to the okra sauce
Loosening the peanuts with hot liquid instead of adding them straight in helps prevent scorching and lumps

Add the okra, dried small fish, bouillon cube and 1 cup (250 ml) water; when it boils, lower to medium-low. Simmer for 8 minutes, with the edges of the pot just bubbling. In a separate small bowl, put 2.5 oz (70 g) unsweetened peanut butter, add ¾ cup (200 ml) hot cooking liquid or hot water in 3 portions, and loosen it smooth with a wooden spoon. Return the loosened peanut to the pot and simmer on low for another 8 minutes. When the sauce falls from the spoon in a thick line and the okra holds everything together without stringing too much, season with 2 g salt.

STEP44 / 6

Pour the slurry into hot water

8 min

Pouring the flour slurry into boiling water and stirring with a wooden spoon
Add the slurry in a thin stream. Keep the spoon moving along the bottom to prevent only the base from setting

Put 2½ cups (600 ml) water and 3 g salt in the heavy pot and bring to a boil over high heat. When large bubbles rise, lower to medium and pour in the slurry from step 1 in a thin stream. Pour slowly, and move the wooden spoon as if scraping the bottom of the pot. After about 3 minutes it becomes a white porridge, and after about 5 minutes the bubbles on the surface get small. If the heat is too high only the bottom sets, so when the porridge starts to spit, lower to medium-low at once.

STEP55 / 6

Work in the remaining flour

12 min

Working the remaining flour into sorghum porridge in a heavy pot until it pulls away from the sides
Turn it over from the bottom of the pot on low heat. It shapes easily once it pulls away from the sides as one mass

Lower to low heat and add the 4 oz (120 g) white sorghum flour you set aside in 4 portions. Each time you add flour, fold it from front to back with the wooden spoon and work it by pressing against the side of the pot. After 4 minutes it suddenly gets heavy, and by about 8 minutes it begins to pull away from the sides of the pot. Keep the heat low before any scorched smell appears, and stir until the dough follows the spoon as one heavy mass when lifted. The guide is a smooth surface, a round mass about 4.5 inches (12 cm) across on the bottom of the pot, and a spoon mark that stays for 3 seconds. If it runs like water, add 2 minutes over low heat; if it crumbles, add 2 tbsp hot water and stir again for 1 minute.

STEP66 / 6

Shape and serve with the sauce

5 min

Shaping esh in a small bowl and pouring okra-peanut sauce around it
Wetting the bowl with water lets the esh come out easily and gives a smooth surface

Reheat the sauce on low until it bubbles gently. Turn off the heat under the esh and press it into a small bowl wetted inside with water. Aim for a hemisphere about 3 inches (8 cm) across per portion, smoothing the surface with a wetted wooden spoon. Turn it out onto a plate and ladle the okra-peanut sauce around it. It is soft while hot and firms as it cools, so bring it to the table as soon as it is plated. If eating by hand, let it cool a little, take a bite-sized piece and make a hollow with your thumb to hold the sauce.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

The esh

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
White sorghum flour 8.5 oz (240 g) The star. Any other sorghum flour also works, but the aroma changes slightly
Millet flour 2 oz (60 g) If hard to find, add the same amount of sorghum flour
Water 3½ cups (850 ml) Split 1 cup (250 ml) for the slurry and 2½ cups (600 ml) for the pot
Salt 3 g A little under 1/2 tsp. 2 g on days when the sauce is salty
2 / 2

Okra-peanut sauce

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Okra 9 oz (250 g) Frozen okra is fine. The finer you chop, the more it thickens
Tomatoes 2, about 9 oz (260 g) 7 oz (200 g) of canned diced tomatoes also works
Onion 1, about 6.5 oz (180 g) Finely chopped
Garlic 2 cloves, about 10 g Finely chopped
Beef stew meat 5.5 oz (150 g) If omitted, increase the dried small fish by 10 g
Dried small fish (niboshi-style anchovies) 20 g Remove heads and guts and break roughly. Substitutes for dried fish
Unsweetened peanut butter 2.5 oz (70 g) Do not use sweetened
Rice bran oil 2 tbsp, about 24 g Peanut oil is closer if you have it
Water or chicken stock 2 cups (450 ml) Split 1 cup (250 ml) for simmering and ¾ cup (200 ml) for loosening the peanuts
Bouillon cube 1, about 5 g Adds Maggi-style saltiness. Adjust to the salt level
Chile 1 Remove the seeds for milder heat
Black pepper 1 g About 1/3 tsp
Salt 2 g Taste at the end and add
0 / 0

When the flour-and-water slurry first goes into the pot, it's thin and milky. A few minutes later the wooden spoon suddenly turns heavy, and the scraping sound at the bottom of the pot drops lower. That's the moment esh gets interesting. Worked over low heat and pushed against the side of the pot, the porridge pulls into a single soft mass, ready to take sauce. This stiff staple of sorghum and millet comes from Chad, and here it's paired with a sticky sauce of okra, tomato and peanuts.

Stirring esh in a heavy pot and checking the thickness at which it pulls away from the sides
How easy esh is to eat depends on its thickness when stirred. Watch the weight of the spoon and how it pulls away from the pot

Esh, a grain staple of Chad and the Sahel

Esh goes by several names. The Arab population in the north calls it "boiled millet flour," and in French-speaking Chad the same grain ball is boule de mil, or simply boule. Whatever you call it, it is always eaten with sauce. People tear off a piece by hand and use it to scoop up the sauce, so the dough has to be firm enough to hold together.

Esh has close cousins across Africa. Tanzanian ugali is built on the white elasticity of cornmeal, and Burkina Faso's tô pairs the aroma of sorghum with okra sauce. Esh sits near both, but at the Chadian table the dumpling is first of all a vessel for sauce. The sauce here follows the okra, tomato and peanut combination often seen in Chad.

Planning your esh day

Make the sauce first. Once you start stirring a grain dumpling you can't walk away from it, and if you stir flour while okra sauce simmers beside it, one of the two will burn. Simmer the okra and tomato, build body with the peanuts, and keep the sauce warm over low heat before you turn to the esh.

Stage Kitchen guide Key to avoiding failure
Mix flour into water 10 minutes, no heat Get rid of the big lumps here
Simmer the sauce 30 minutes, medium to low heat Chop the okra first and loosen the peanuts separately
Stir the esh 20 minutes over low heat Don't add the remaining flour all at once
Serve 5 minutes, while warm Wet the bowl with water to shape it

Ingredients

Sorghum flour, millet flour, okra, tomato, onion and unsweetened peanut butter laid out as esh ingredients
Preparing sorghum and millet flour, okra, tomato, onion and unsweetened peanuts separately keeps the work steady

This recipe uses peanuts and fish. If you have an allergy, don't make it as written. Replace the peanuts with white sesame paste and the dried fish with kombu stock to make a different dish. The esh itself contains no wheat, but some flours may be contaminated with wheat on the production line, so check the label if you must avoid gluten strictly.

Choosing ingredients for esh

Flour for esh, unsweetened peanuts and a heavy pot, laid out to help decide what to buy
Worth seeking out online are the sorghum flour that sets the grain aroma, unsweetened peanuts, and a heavy pot that resists scorching

Okra, tomatoes, onion, garlic, meat and dried fish all come from an ordinary supermarket. Three things are worth seeking out: sorghum flour, unsweetened peanut butter and a heavy pot.

Sorghum flour gives esh its grain character. Use all cornmeal and you drift toward ugali or polenta. Wheat flour, potato starch or rice flour on their own change both the stickiness and the aroma, so outside Chad, keep at least the sorghum flour.

Peanuts bring aroma and body at once. Choose an unsweetened type, not the sweet spread made for bread, which makes the sauce too sweet to rescue.

The pot matters because esh tends to stick to the bottom while you stir. A thin saucepan sets the dough only at the base, so pick one with a thick bottom that stays put when you lean on the wooden spoon.

Frozen okra works fine, but it releases water. Spread it on a colander and brush off the surface frost before it goes into the pot.

When you substitute, hold on to three things: the aroma of the sorghum and millet widely used in the Sahel, a firmness you can tear by hand, and a sticky sauce to eat it with.

Element Local thinking Where to land at home
Grain Millet or sorghum stirred into a staple Center on white sorghum flour with a little millet flour
Sauce Boule or esh is always eaten with sauce Build stickiness and richness with okra, tomato and peanuts
Fish umami A little dried fish or meat umami goes in Use dried small fish; halve it if too strong
How to eat Tear by hand and scoop up sauce A spoon is fine, but aim for hand-tearing firmness

Method

You use two pots: a small pot or frying pan for the sauce and a heavy pot for the esh. Once you start stirring the esh, there is no time to touch your phone. Light the heat only after you have water, flour, a wooden spoon and a wet small bowl all within reach.

Common esh problems and fixes

A comparison of loose esh and esh of the right stiffness that holds a hemisphere
Spread out like the left means too much water; holding a hemisphere like the right catches the sauce well

Heat and water are the tricky parts. Sorghum flour lacks the elasticity of wheat, so with too little water the dough crumbles, and with too much it spreads across the plate.

The most common mistake is adding all the remaining flour at once after you start stirring. It floats on the surface and lumps, and the inside stays raw. Add it in 4 portions, stirring until each one completely disappears.

If the bottom scorches, don't scrape it up and mix it in, or the burnt smell will run through everything. Move only the clean upper part to another pot, add 2 tbsp hot water and bring it back over low heat.

Serving and storing esh

Tearing off esh and eating it with okra-peanut sauce
Esh is taken a little at a time by hand or spoon and coated in the sticky sauce

Set the esh in the center of the plate and pour the sauce in from the side. Mixing everything from the start loses the texture of the dumpling. If you're eating by hand, press a hollow with your thumb and scoop up the sauce; at the table, cutting bite-sized pieces with a spoon and coating them works just as well.

A sour tomato salad on the side keeps the meal from feeling heavy, and for greens, a sauté like Kenya's sukuma wiki is a good match. Curious about other stirred staples? Try Botswana's bogobe jwa lerotse or Ghana's banku, and the differences in flour, fermentation and sauce come into focus.

Storage

Esh and okra sauce in separate storage containers with water for reheating beside them
Store esh and sauce separately. To reheat, add a little water and warm over low heat

Store the esh and sauce separately. Cool the esh in a shallow container, press plastic wrap against the surface and refrigerate for up to 2 days; the sauce also keeps up to 2 days in the refrigerator. To reheat, sprinkle 2 tbsp of water over one serving of esh, microwave at 600 W for 1 minute 30 seconds and stir, adding 30 seconds at a time if it's still hard. On the stove, use low heat and stir in hot water 1 tbsp at a time.

Esh can be frozen, though it tends to turn grainy after thawing, and finished hemispheres crack on the surface. Freeze it in bite-sized pieces instead and drop them into soup or leftover okra sauce.

Frequently asked questions

Are esh, tô and ugali the same dish?

They're close, but not the same. All are stirred grain-flour staples: ugali is made from cornmeal, tô is a West African staple of sorghum or millet eaten with sauce, and esh is Chad's stirred ball of millet or sorghum. At home, the difference comes down to the flour and the sauce you pair it with.

Can I make it without millet flour?

Yes. Use 10.5 oz (300 g) white sorghum flour and 3½ cups (850 ml) water. The aroma becomes a little more one-note, but it stays close to esh. Flours absorb water differently, so adjust at the end with 2 tbsp of hot water at a time.

I don't like the sliminess of okra

Slice the okra into 0.25 inch (5 mm) rounds and simmer uncovered to keep the sliminess modest; coarse chopping and a lid increase it. Since esh is meant to take sauce, leave some stickiness, so the sauce falls slowly from the wooden spoon.

Can I use sweetened peanut butter?

Better not to. Sweetened peanut cream makes the tomato and okra sauce sweet, and salt or chile can hardly bring it back. With no unsweetened type on hand, coarsely crush 2.75 oz (80 g) of unsalted roasted peanuts in a mortar or food processor and loosen them with hot cooking liquid.

Can I make it without meat?

Yes. Leave out the beef and increase the dried small fish to 1 oz (30 g) to keep the umami. To avoid fish as well, rehydrate 8 g of dried shiitake and use the soaking liquid as part of the water. Without fish, it becomes a vegetarian grain dumpling with okra-peanut sauce rather than the exact Chadian taste.

Sources