Irish Soda Bread: Brown Soda Bread with Wholemeal Flour and Buttermilk

A brown wholemeal soda bread with one slice cut from the loaf
Cuisine
Irish

How to make Irish brown soda bread from equal parts wholemeal and plain white flour, salt, bicarbonate of soda and buttermilk, following the National Dairy Council Ireland recipe. Covers adding buttermilk only until the dough comes together, why the dough is not kneaded, cutting the cross without separating the loaf, judging the bake by colour and a hollow sound, and how soda bread is eaten at Irish tables.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Preheat the oven and prepare the tray

STEP 1

Preheat the oven to 400°F (200°C). Line a flat baking tray with baking paper. Home ovens can run hotter or cooler than their dial, so check the colour and sound in step 6 as well as the time.

STEP22 / 7

Mix the dry ingredients evenly

Mixing white flour, wholemeal flour, bicarbonate of soda and salt in a bowl
Mix the two flours, salt and soda evenly before any liquid goes in

Put the plain white flour, wholemeal flour, salt and bicarbonate of soda into a large bowl and mix them well. Aim for the soda to be spread evenly through the flour. Pockets of unmixed soda can lead to bitter spots or an uneven rise, so don't leave streaks.

STEP33 / 7

Add the buttermilk a little at a time

Pouring buttermilk little by little into the centre of the flour and mixing
Add the buttermilk gradually and stop once the dough comes together

Make a well in the centre of the flour. Pour in about half of the buttermilk first. With your fingers or a round-bladed knife, draw the flour from the sides into the liquid. Then add the remaining buttermilk a little at a time. Stop when no dry flour is left and the mixture has become a soft, sticky dough. Depending on your flour, you may not use all 1¾ cups (400 ml).

STEP44 / 7

Shape quickly, without kneading

Gathering the dough into a round on a floured surface and flattening it slightly
Shape the dough into a round and flatten it a little, with minimal handling

Turn the dough out onto a lightly floured surface. Bring it together into a round ball and flatten it slightly with your palm. Do not knead it. The reaction between the buttermilk and the soda is already under way, so keep handling brief. You are not aiming for the springy, stretchy feel of a yeasted dough.

STEP55 / 7

Cut a deep cross

Cutting a cross into the top of the round dough without separating it at the base
Cut deeply, but keep the four quarters joined at the bottom

Move the round onto the lined tray. With a large sharp knife, cut a deep cross into the top, marking the loaf into quarters. Do not cut all the way through the base. The four sections should stay joined as a single loaf.

STEP66 / 7

Bake and check the base

Lightly tapping the base of the baked loaf to listen for a hollow sound
A browned crust and a hollow sound from the base are the signs of doneness

Bake at 400°F (200°C) for about 30 minutes. The loaf is done when it has browned and sounds hollow when you tap the base lightly. Lift it carefully with a cloth, because it will be very hot. Use the colour and the hollow sound to decide, not the time alone.

STEP77 / 7

Cool on a wire rack

Freshly baked soda bread cooling on a wire rack
Cool the whole loaf on a rack

Place the loaf on a wire rack to cool. Eat it on the day it is baked, or toast it the next day.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Plain white flour 9 oz (250g) Lightens the loaf alongside the wholemeal flour
Plain wholemeal flour 9 oz (250g) The nutty flavour and coarse crumb of brown soda bread
Salt 1 tsp Seasoning
Bicarbonate of soda (bread soda) 1 tsp The raising agent, reacting with the buttermilk's acid. Not the same as baking powder
Buttermilk Up to 1¾ cups (400 ml) Acid and moisture. Add only until a sticky dough forms; some may be left over
Flour for dusting A little For the work surface
0 / 0

Irish households once handed soda bread recipes down within the family, and the bicarbonate of soda and buttermilk were often measured by hand and by eye rather than on scales. This loaf still asks for a little of that judgement. You pour in the buttermilk a bit at a time and stop when the flour has come together, instead of tipping in the whole jug. Made with equal weights of plain white flour and plain wholemeal flour, it is a brown soda bread from four dry ingredients and buttermilk, quick to mix and straight into the oven.

Irish Soda Bread and How It Is Eaten

Irish soda bread is a bread leavened with bicarbonate of soda and buttermilk instead of yeast. Acid in the buttermilk reacts with the soda, so there is no waiting for the dough to prove. That reaction starts the moment the two meet, which is why the work moves fast once the liquid goes in: mix, shape, cut a cross and bake.

"Soda bread" covers a lot of ground. There are brown or wheaten loaves built around wholemeal flour, loaves made mostly with white flour, and countless household mixes. Another traditional brown soda bread adds an egg and honey and is baked in a loaf tin. The traditional style uses four ingredients, while an American version adds eggs, butter, sugar and dried fruit, and newer twists bring in seeds, or stout and treacle. Each has its own balance of flour, liquid and baking time, so the plain version here is a good place to learn the skill those family bakers relied on: reading the dough as you add the liquid.

Buttered soda bread with smoked salmon on a separate plate
Butter and smoked salmon are an optional way to serve the bread, not part of the dough

In Ireland, soda bread is part of an Ulster Fry, and brown bread comes alongside seafood chowder. In Dublin, brown soda bread is served with egg dishes and smoked salmon. For more dishes from the same country, see Ireland.

Ingredients for One Round Loaf

White flour, wholemeal flour, bicarbonate of soda, salt and buttermilk laid out as ingredients
Only five measured ingredients go into the dough

This recipe makes one round loaf. Have all the buttermilk ready, but you may not need all of it.

Equipment

  • Large mixing bowl
  • Measuring spoons
  • Measuring jug for the buttermilk
  • Round-bladed knife (or your fingers) for mixing
  • Flat baking tray
  • Baking paper
  • Large sharp knife for cutting the cross
  • Wire rack for cooling

Choosing Flour, Buttermilk and Soda for Soda Bread

Wholemeal flour is the heart of the flavour, and it also changes how much liquid the dough needs. Coarse and fine grinds absorb buttermilk differently, and buttermilk thickness varies from product to product. Treat 1¾ cups (400 ml) as the most you should have ready, not an amount to pour in automatically, and check the label of your wholemeal flour as you go.

For the white flour, use plain (all-purpose) flour rather than cake flour (hakurikiko). Buttermilk supplies both the acid for the rise and much of the moisture, so use real buttermilk; milk soured with lemon is not a stand-in. The same goes for the leavening: the recipe is written for bicarbonate of soda, which is a different product from baking powder.

Method: Mix, Shape and Bake Without Delay

Have everything ready first

Once the buttermilk meets the soda, the reaction has begun. Preheat the oven and line the tray before you start mixing, so the dough can go straight from bowl to oven.

Common Soda Bread Problems and Fixes

Problem Likely cause What to do
Dough feels stiff with dry patches Not enough buttermilk for your flour Add more of the measured buttermilk a little at a time until it becomes a sticky dough
Dough is very wet All the buttermilk went in at once Next time, start with about half and add the rest gradually, stopping as soon as the dough comes together
Loaf is dense or tough Dough was kneaded or handled for too long Shape it quickly into a round and get it into the oven; don't knead
Loaf splits into four pieces The cross was cut through the base Cut deeply but keep the quarters joined at the bottom
Base doesn't sound hollow after about 30 minutes Oven or flour differs from what the recipe assumes Keep baking until it browns and the base sounds hollow when tapped, rather than trusting the time alone

Most of these come back to one habit: watch the dough, not the measuring jug.

Serving and Varying Soda Bread

Spread slices with salted butter at the table; the butter isn't mixed into the dough. Smoked salmon and a bowl of chowder are both natural partners, as they are in Ireland.

Once you know the plain loaf, try changing the ratio of white to wholemeal flour. The dough will take up liquid differently, so judge the buttermilk by feel all over again.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to add all 1¾ cups (400 ml) of buttermilk?

No. Add it gradually and stop when the flour has become a sticky dough. Depending on your flour, some buttermilk may be left over.

Should I knead the dough?

No. Bring it together quickly into a round and flatten it slightly. The reaction starts as soon as the buttermilk goes in, so long handling works against the rise.

Does the cross go all the way through?

Cut it deeply, but not through the base. The loaf should stay in one piece, marked into quarters on top.

How many people does one loaf serve?

The recipe makes one round loaf, and how many it serves depends on how you eat it.

Can I eat it the next day?

Eat it on the day it is baked, or toast it the next day.

Sources