Bulalo: Filipino Beef Shank and Bone Marrow Soup

Filipino bulalo: beef shank, marrow, corn and greens simmered in a clear broth
Prep
25 min
Cook
2 hr 50 min
Total
3 hr 15 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Filipino

Bulalo is a clear Filipino beef shank and bone marrow soup from Tagaytay and Batangas. Learn clear broth, corn and greens timing, a pressure-cooker shortcut.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Wash the beef bones and parboil

10 min

Parboiling bone-in beef shank in a pot with gray foam and scum floating on the water
Boil briefly and hard for the parboil, push the gray foam and scum out, then go to the main simmer

Rinse 2 lb (900 g) bone-in beef shank and 10.5 oz (300 g) tendon or shank block under running water to remove bone dust and blood. Put 2 quarts (1.8 L) of water for parboiling in a pot over high heat and add the meat once it boils. When it comes to a hard boil again, reduce to medium heat and cook for 5 minutes. When the water is gray and cloudy and foam and scum float on the surface, turn off the heat. Discard the water, wash the meat in lukewarm water and wash the pot once as well.

STEP22 / 6

Simmer the aromatics and beef over low heat

2 hr 20 min

Simmering bone-in beef shank with onion, garlic and peppercorns in a clear broth over low heat
Keep the main simmer at a gentle bubble over low heat, skimming only the scum and leaving a little fat

Return the meat to the washed pot with 2.25 quarts (2.2 L) of water for the main simmer, the onion, garlic, whole black pepper and 1 tsp salt. Bring to a boil over high heat and skim off any fine scum that appears. After it boils, lower the heat and simmer with the lid slightly ajar for 2 hours to 2 hours 20 minutes. The heat should be low enough that small bubbles rise quietly from the bottom of the pot. Move on when a skewer slides into the meat without resistance and the tendons around the bone look shrunken. In a pressure cooker, cook at high pressure for 35 minutes and check the same cues after natural release.

STEP33 / 6

Cut the vegetables large

10 min

Cutting corn, cabbage, bok choy, potatoes and green beans large for bulalo
Cut the vegetables large so they keep their shape to the end

Cut the corn into 1.5 inches (4 cm) rounds, the potatoes into 1 inches (3 cm) chunks, the cabbage into wedges with a little core left, the bok choy lengthwise into quarters and the green beans into 2 inches (5 cm) lengths. This step is knife work only. If the vegetables are cut too small, they fall apart in later steps and cloud the soup. Leaving a bit of the corn cob, the cabbage core and the bok choy stems makes serving easier at the table.

STEP44 / 6

Simmer the corn and potatoes

15 min

Simmering corn and potatoes in the beef bone soup over medium-low heat
Add the root vegetables and corn before the greens, and cook over medium-low heat so they keep their shape

Add the corn and potatoes to the pot once the beef is tender. Bring to a simmer over medium heat, then drop right away to medium-low and cook for 15 minutes. The heat should be low enough that small bubbles rise from the cut ends of the corn. It is enough when a skewer slides easily into the potato and the yellow of the corn deepens. A hard boil crumbles the marrow and turns the broth milky, so do not shake the pot too much.

STEP55 / 6

Season with patis and add the greens

5 min

Adding greens and cabbage to the bulalo pot and spooning in patis
Add the patis a little at a time at the end, and finish the greens in a short time that keeps their color

Add 1 tbsp patis down the side of the pot and warm over low heat for 1 minute. Taste, and add up to 1/2 tsp salt. Add the cabbage, bok choy and green beans and simmer without the lid for 4 minutes. Keep the heat low to medium-low, just enough to make the surface of the leaves sway. Stop when the bok choy stems turn slightly translucent and the leaves are a deep green and wilted. Cooking long after adding the greens gives the soup a heavy, green smell.

STEP66 / 6

Serve without breaking the marrow

3 min

Serving beef shank with its marrow in a bowl, with corn and cabbage alongside, as the final bulalo step
Put the meat on last so the marrow stays intact, and add patis and sourness at the table

Turn off the heat and lift the bone-in meat gently with tongs. The marrow slips out easily, so put the corn and cabbage in the bottom of the bowl and set the meat on top. Pour in the soup and add calamansi or sudachi as you like. At the table, put out patis, red chili and rice separately so everyone can adjust saltiness and sourness. It is ready to eat when the meat has come off the bone and the marrow gives way softly when pressed with a spoon.

0 / 0

On the day you make bulalo, don't hurry the pot. The seasoning is plain: onion, garlic, whole peppercorns and patis, then corn, cabbage and greens at the end. Even so, the steam rising off it carries the round aroma of beef bones. This Filipino soup of beef shank and marrow, also called beef shank soup or beef marrow stew in English, is a specialty of southern Luzon, especially around Batangas, Cavite and Tagaytay. It sounds like food for a cold place, and in a cool, high town like Tagaytay, a hot bowl suits it perfectly.

Bulalo in Batangas and Tagaytay

A pot of bulalo being served at the table with rice, patis and calamansi, a Filipino meal
Bulalo comes to the table in the pot; everyone adjusts it with rice, patis, calamansi and chili

In the Philippines, bulalo usually arrives in a large pot or deep bowl, with cross-cut bone-in shank sitting in the soup. You crumble the marrow from the center bit by bit with a spoon and move back and forth between soup and rice. Think of it as bones, broth, corn and greens eaten together, and the cooking decisions get easier.

Bulalo is a well-known local dish in Tagaytay, where a hot beef bone soup in the cool highlands is part of many visitors' memories. It also connects to Batangas's beef culture.

Among Filipino dishes, bulalo takes a different path from sinigang, which is defined by sourness; kare-kare, eaten with peanut and fermented shrimp paste; and arroz caldo, the morning rice porridge. Monggo, the everyday mung bean dish, is a close neighbor, but bulalo is plainer still: at its center is simply the beef bone broth.

What matters locally Why keep it at home A realistic home approach
Bone-in beef shank Marrow and gelatin give the soup body Look for it at a butcher, frozen-meat shop or online
Clear broth The right amount of fat and scum makes it easy to drink Discard the parboiling water and simmer gently
Corn Adds sweetness and makes the meal satisfying Cut fresh or frozen corn on the cob into thick rounds
Greens and cabbage Lighten the heavy beef bone soup Use bok choy, komatsuna, napa cabbage or cabbage
Patis Adds a lingering note salt alone lacks Add a little at the end and serve more at the table

Ingredients: building the broth from beef shank and corn

The ingredients for bulalo: bone-in beef shank, corn, cabbage, greens, peppercorns and patis
Bulalo makes a clear beef bone soup from bone-in shank, corn, greens, peppercorns and patis

This makes a big pot for 4. Ideally, use 2.75 lb (1.2 kg) bone-in beef shank alone. If that is hard to find, combine 1.5 lb (700 g) bone-in shank with 10.5 oz (300 g) shank block and 7 oz (200 g) beef tendon. This balances the amount of meat and the richness of the broth.

:::ingredients

Meat and broth

Ingredient Amount Role
Bone-in beef shank 2 lb (900 g) Serves as both marrow and meat. Thaw frozen shank before using
Beef tendon or beef shank block 10.5 oz (300 g) A supplement when there is little bone-in meat
Water, for parboiling 2 quarts (1.8 L) Discard the first water
Water, for the main simmer 2.25 quarts (2.2 L) Top up as needed, up to 1¼ cups (300 ml), during cooking
Onion 1, 7 oz (200 g) Cut into 4 wedges
Garlic 6 cloves, 1 oz (30 g) Crushed
Black pepper, whole 2 tsp, about 5 g For simmering. Separate from the ground pepper for finishing
Salt 1 1/2 tsp Adjust at the end together with the patis
Patis 2 tbsp Filipino fish sauce. 1 tbsp in the pot, the rest at the table

Vegetables and finishing

Ingredient Amount Role
Corn 2 ears, 1 lb (500 g) trimmed weight Cut into 1.5 inches (4 cm) rounds
Potato 2, 10.5 oz (300 g) 1 inches (3 cm) chunks. Too many cloud the broth, so keep it modest
Cabbage 1/4 head, 10.5 oz (300 g) Large wedges with a little core left
Bok choy 2 heads, 8.5 oz (240 g) Quartered lengthwise. If using komatsuna, 7 oz (200 g)
Green beans 3.5 oz (100 g) Cut into 2 inches (5 cm) lengths
Calamansi or sudachi juice of 4 Squeeze at the table
Hot rice 4 servings Firm rice suits it, to take on the soup
Red chili 1, 10 g Thinly sliced. Only for those who want heat

This dish uses beef and fish sauce. If you skip fish sauce, use 1 tbsp light soy sauce and 1/3 tsp salt instead. The aroma changes, so this is a home substitute, not a local-style flavor. Cook the beef thoroughly to the center, with no red left around the bone.

Choosing ingredients and substitutes for bulalo

Patis, peppercorns, a pressure cooker, beef shank and corn laid out in a kitchen
When shopping for bulalo, what takes thought is less the meat itself than patis, peppercorns and a pot that can simmer long

Meat and vegetables

The meat decides the bowl. Thinly sliced supermarket beef won't give you bulalo's marrow richness, so buy the meat, corn, cabbage and greens at a nearby grocery or butcher where you can ask about freshness. Bulalo is often shortened to "beef bone soup" in Japanese, but at home the real key is how well you protect the marrow. On days you can get bone-in shank, make it the star.

Patis and peppercorns

Patis, strongly scented whole peppercorns and a good pot may take a little more hunting. Patis adds a lingering note you can't get from salt, but bulalo doesn't lean on sourness or heat, so go easy. Put just 1 tbsp in the pot and let everyone add the rest at the table, and the soup stays light.

Whole peppercorns release their aroma slowly through the simmer. Ground pepper alone sinks its heat to the bottom of the soup and blurs the clean beef flavor. If you'll make bulalo more than once, a bag of whole black pepper is worth having.

Pot or pressure cooker

Bone-in meat takes time to turn tender. A heavy pot is enough for a slow weekend simmer, but for weekday cooking, a pressure cooker of 4.25 quarts (4 L) or more is the realistic choice.

Substitutes

With so few ingredients, every substitute shows in the taste. Keep four things in mind: marrow, clear soup, fish sauce and the size of the vegetables.

What you are deciding If using as is If substituting Notes on substituting
Bone-in beef shank The most bulalo-like Oxtail combined with shank Less marrow. Make up the gelatin with tendon
Patis Aroma leans Filipino A little Thai fish sauce The aroma leans Thai, so go easy
Calamansi Light sourness Sudachi, kabosu Lemon is strongly scented, so use a little
Greens Close to pechay Bok choy, komatsuna, napa cabbage Add leafy greens at the end and cook briefly
Corn The pillar of sweetness and looks Frozen corn on the cob Kernel corn alone is not substantial enough
Pressure cooker Easy to shorten the time Heavy pot on low heat Takes longer but makes a clearer soup

Local ingredients are fine. Careful parboiling, whole peppercorns and fish sauce saved for the end will bring your pot close to the real thing.

Method: don't rush a clear beef broth

Divide bulalo into stages rather than trying to shorten the simmer. Parboiling pushes out the cloudiness, the main simmer stays on low heat, and the vegetables go in last. If potatoes and greens go in from the start, the broth clouds and the leaves sink and turn heavy.

Common bulalo problems and fixes

A cloudy, greasy beef bone soup compared with a clear bulalo broth, showing how to fix problems
In bulalo, the parboil, low heat and how you skim fat greatly change the clarity of the soup

The usual trouble with bulalo is a heavy broth, not weak flavor. Strip out all the fat and the soup feels thin; ignore the surface and the mouthfeel turns dull. Vegetables, too, only suffer from long cooking.

Problem Cause Fix
Soup is cloudy gray Not enough parboiling, kept at a hard boil Discard the parboiling water and keep the main simmer low
Greasy Too much fat left from tendon and marrow After simmering, ladle 3 to 5 tbsp of fat off the surface
Meat is tough Not simmered long enough, or heat too low Extend by 30 minutes over low heat and judge by how a skewer goes in
Vegetables sink Greens added too early, cut too small Add greens for the last 4 minutes and cut large
Strong fish-sauce smell Too much patis from the start 1 tbsp in the pot, add the rest at the table
Potatoes cloud the broth Broke down, released starch Cut into 1 inches (3 cm) chunks or larger and stop at 15 minutes

If it tastes bland, resist salting the whole pot. A few drops of patis in each bowl lift the aroma and satisfy more, while a saltier pot will taste sharp when you reheat it the next day.

Serving and storing bulalo

Leftover bulalo divided into soup and solids in storage containers, with chilled fat removed
Refrigerate bulalo with the soup and solids separate, and warm it the next day after removing the set fat

Plain white rice, a quick vinegar pickle of tomato and onion, grilled eggplant or a fragrant dish like chicken inasal keeps the meal from getting heavy. On days you want sourness, squeeze sudachi in place of calamansi and add just a little red chili.

If you make it ahead, store the soup and solids separately. Hot soup stays hot too long in a deep container, so let it cool for about 30 minutes, then move it to a shallow one. Refrigerate for 2 days. The soup alone freezes for 3 weeks; potatoes and greens lose their texture in the freezer, so freeze only the meat and soup.

By the next day, white fat will have set on the surface. Leave about 1 tbsp of it, since it brings the aroma back when you reheat. Warm it on the stove over low heat for 8 minutes, or in a microwave for 3 minutes at 600 W, stirring once partway. For fresh greens, add 2.75 oz (80 g) of komatsuna at the end of reheating and cook for just 1 minute.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make it without bone-in beef shank?

You can, but you lose the pleasure of the marrow, so the dish feels weaker. Combining 1 lb (500 g) oxtail, 1 lb (500 g) shank block and 7 oz (200 g) beef tendon makes up for the broth and gelatin. With only thin beef slices, it's really a beef and vegetable soup rather than bulalo.

How much can a pressure cooker shorten it?

Parboil the same way, then do the main simmer at high pressure for 35 minutes with natural release. Check the meat afterward, and if it's tough, pressure cook for another 10 minutes. Add the vegetables at the end over ordinary heat, since pressure cooking dulls the color and aroma of the greens.

Is the marrow okay to eat?

If the bone-in meat has been cooked thoroughly to the center and handled cleanly, the marrow is one of the pleasures of bulalo. Scoop it out a little at a time and eat it with the soup and rice. It's rich in fat, so if it isn't for you, melting a little into the soup is enough.

Can I replace patis with Thai fish sauce?

Yes. Start with 2 tsp in the pot, then add more at the table if needed. Soy sauce alone gives saltiness but not the lingering fish-sauce note.

Can I change the vegetables?

Yes. Cabbage, bok choy, komatsuna, napa cabbage and green beans all work well. Some households add daikon or carrot, but they sweeten the soup, so keep the amount modest. Turn off the heat while the greens are still bright.

Sources and references