Knish: Eastern European Jewish Baked Potato Pastry

Knish from Eastern European Jewish cooking: golden baked potato pastries on a plate with sour cream and dill
Prep
45 min
Cook
55 min
Total
1 hr 40 min
Serves
4 servings (about 12 knishes)
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Eastern European Jewish

How to make knish, the Eastern European Jewish potato pastry, in a home kitchen: its Yiddish name, a thin oil dough, onion-potato filling, shaping, baking at 190°C, storage and reheating, plus fixes for the seams that open.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 8

Boil the potatoes

18 min

Potatoes cut into 3 cm cubes simmering gently in a pot
Cut the potatoes into 3 cm cubes and cook over medium-low heat until tender through. Don't let them fall apart

Peel the potatoes and cut into 1 inch (3 cm) cubes. Put them in a pot with water to just cover and 1/2 tsp salt, over medium heat. When it boils, lower to medium-low, so the surface bubbles quietly, and boil 12–15 minutes. Drain when a skewer slides into the center with no resistance, but the corners still hold their shape.

STEP22 / 8

Cook the onions until sweet

18 min

Finely chopped onions cooking to a pale golden color in a skillet
Make the onions sweet over medium-low heat. Drive off moisture to bring out aroma rather than scorching

Chop the onions into 0.25 inch (5 mm) pieces. Heat 3 tbsp oil in a heavy skillet over medium heat. Add the onions, sprinkle with 1/4 tsp salt, cook 3 minutes over medium heat, then 12–15 minutes over medium-low. Stop when they are pale golden, the edges are translucent and a sweet smell rises. Cooking to dark brown brings bitterness.

STEP33 / 8

Mix the filling

8 min

Filling of mashed potato mixed with cooked onion, black pepper and dill in a bowl
Mix the filling while hot and set the seasoning a little strong. Small lumps can stay

Move the drained potatoes to a bowl while steam still rises. No heat is needed. Coarsely mash with a fork or masher. Add the cooked onions, 1/2 tsp salt, black pepper and dill, and fold from the bottom. It is ready when no liquid pools at the bottom and it holds together moistly, with fork marks showing. Taste it while still warm: it should taste a little strong. Spread on a flat plate and cool about 10 minutes.

STEP44 / 8

Knead the dough and let it rest

15 min, then rest 30 min

Rolling the oil dough into a ball and resting it under a cloth
Rest the dough 30 minutes. Resting keeps it from shrinking back when rolled thin

In a bowl, mix the flour, baking powder and salt. In another bowl, mix the egg, oil, lukewarm water and vinegar, and add to the flour. Stir with chopsticks (or a spoon) until it comes together, turn out onto the counter and knead 5 minutes. When the surface is smooth and the dough springs back slowly when pressed, shape it into a flat disk about 4.5 inches (12 cm) across. Cover with a cloth so it doesn't dry out and rest 30 minutes at room temperature. No heat is used.

STEP55 / 8

Roll thin and set down the filling

12 min

Placing the potato filling in a log along the edge of thinly rolled dough
Roll the dough to about 1.5 mm. Don't push the filling to the very edge; leave room to roll

Preheat the oven to 375°F (190 °C). Lightly flour the counter and divide the dough in 2. Roll one half into a rectangle about 12 inches × 10 inches (30 cm × 25 cm), about 0 inch (1.5 mm) thick. Leave 1 inch (3 cm) clear at the near edge and lay half of the cooled filling in a log about 1.5 inches (4 cm) thick. The filling should not weep moisture, and it should hold its shape on the dough. If the dough shrinks, don't force-stretch it; rest it 2 minutes and then roll.

STEP66 / 8

Roll, cut and close the ends

12 min

Cutting the filled roll into short pieces and shaping round knishes
Pinch the cut ends closed and set seam side down. Slight unevenness settles in the oven

Fold the near edge of dough over the filling and roll once, pushing out air. Keep rolling away from you into a long tube. Press lightly with the back of a knife or a cooking chopstick about every 2 inches (5 cm) to mark 12 equal pieces. Cut them apart, pinch the open top and bottom closed, and press lightly with the seam side down. Patch any tears by pulling the surrounding dough over them.

STEP77 / 8

Brush with egg and prepare to bake

5 min

Brushing egg wash on knishes on a baking sheet and sprinkling a few poppy seeds
Brush the egg wash thin. Pooled egg scorches the bottoms, so brush away the excess

Line a baking sheet with parchment and set the knishes about 1 inch (2 cm) apart. Mix 1 egg with 1 tsp water until no clumps of white show and it is runny, and brush a thin layer over the surface. If using poppy seeds or white sesame, sprinkle a little on now. Keep the wash thin so it doesn't pool at the bottom. No heat is used.

STEP88 / 8

Bake at 375°F (190 °C) and rest

30 min

Baked knishes moved from the baking sheet to a rack, showing their golden surface
Bake at 190 °C for 25–30 minutes. When surface and bottom have a light color, rest on a rack

Bake on the middle rack of the oven preheated to 375°F (190 °C) for 25–30 minutes. They are done when the surface turns from pale gold to brown, the area around the seams is dry, and the bottom has a light brown color when lifted. If the color is pale, move to the upper rack and bake 2–3 minutes more at 375°F (190 °C). Fresh from the oven the inside is very hot, so rest 7 minutes on a rack before serving.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Dough

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
All-purpose flour (soft, low-protein) 9 oz (260 g) Medium-protein flour is fine. Bread flour alone springs back and is hard to roll
Baking powder 1 tsp Lightens the dough slightly. Without it the texture is tighter
Salt 1/2 tsp For the dough
Egg 1 (about 2 oz (55 g)) Goes in the dough. Separate from the one for the wash
Rice bran or canola oil ¼ cup (60 ml) Makes the dough supple. Butter hardens when cold
Lukewarm water ½ cup (90 ml) 35–40 °C. Add a little at a time
Vinegar 1 tsp Makes the dough easier to roll. White wine vinegar works
2 / 3

Potato filling

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Potatoes 1.5 lb (650 g) A floury potato gives a fluffy filling, a waxy one a smoother filling. You can mix them
Onions 2 (about 12.5 oz (360 g)) Finely chopped. Cooked until sweet
Rice bran or canola oil 3 tbsp For the onions. Chicken fat is more traditional, but oil is enough at home
Salt 1 1/4 tsp Potatoes absorb salt, so don't go light
Black pepper 1/2 tsp Coarsely ground is best
Dill 1 tsp 1/2 tsp if dried. Can be omitted, but the aroma gets lighter
3 / 3

Finishing

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Egg 1 Brushed on the surface
Water 1 tsp Mixed into the egg for easier brushing
Poppy seeds or white sesame 2 tsp On top if you like. Optional
Whole-grain mustard 2 tbsp Served at the table
Sour cream 2.75 oz (80 g) Any ordinary sour cream is fine. Yogurt works too
Pickled cucumbers 2.75 oz (80 g) Their acidity cuts the heaviness of the potato
0 / 0

A knish fresh from the oven isn't a showy thing: glossy brown dough wrapped around a plain white filling of potato and onion. Break one in half and the sweet smell of cooked onion rises with the steam, and your kitchen starts to smell like an Eastern European bakery. Knish (קניש) comes from the Ashkenazi Jewish kitchens of Eastern Europe, and today it's best known as a snack from New York's Jewish delis and street carts. The flavor is simple and comforting: well-salted potato, onion cooked until sweet, all in a thin, tender crust.

What knish is and where it comes from

Knish is a pastry of thin dough wrapped around potato, onion, buckwheat kasha, meat or cheese, then baked or fried. Its roots are in the flour-and-dough cooking of Belarus, Ukraine, Poland and Lithuania. It's better understood through the movement of Eastern European Jews and their home cooking than through any single modern border. In North America it took root as a deli snack you hold in one hand.

Potato, onion and thin dough are the thread that links it to Belarusian machanka and Polish pierogi. This version is shaped into rounds, which are easy to make in a home oven.

The essentials of knish

A thinly rolled dough, well-salted potato, onion cooked until sweet, and a snack you can hold in one hand after baking. Roll the dough too thick and it turns heavy, like potato bread. Under-salt the filling and the whole thing tastes blurred.


Ingredients: serves 4, about 12 knishes

Potatoes, onions, flour, eggs, oil, dill, poppy seeds and a rolling pin laid out on a kitchen counter
Shopping for knish is mostly potatoes and onions. Add only the tools and aromatics, and the work steadies

This recipe makes 12 round potato knishes. The dough is made with oil and rolls out thin, and the filling is mostly potato and onion. The dough and filling have no dairy. Serve with sour cream to bring it closer to an Eastern European table.

Allergy and ingredient notes

This recipe uses wheat and egg. If you serve it with sour cream it also contains milk. Use poppy seeds sold for food use, and avoid them if you react to seeds.


Choosing ingredients and tools for knish

Comparing the thin knish dough, the potato filling and the browning in a kitchen
Knish turns out differently depending on dough thickness, moisture in the filling and browning

Ordinary supermarket potatoes, onions, eggs and flour work fine. What matters most is how you treat them: sweeten the onion without scorching it, and salt the potato properly. A mild mash gives you a vague, forgettable knish once it's baked.

Doubt Traditional Easier at home
Fat Chicken fat or butter for aroma Rice bran oil for lightness, and cook the onion longer for sweetness
Shape Wrap into rounds and stand them upright Roll into a log, cut, and pinch the ends
Filling Make potato, onion and pepper bolder Add a little dill so the aroma lasts when it cools
Finish Serve with mustard or sauerkraut Whole-grain mustard, pickles and sour cream as stand-ins
Baking Higher heat to dry the surface Bake at 375°F (190 °C) and move to the upper rack for the last 2 minutes

Dough and potato

Aim for a dough a little thicker than a dumpling wrapper and much thinner than bread dough. Some traditions roll it so thin you can see through it, but at home that tears easily. Start at about 0 inch (1.5 mm), and stop where you can still faintly make out the shape of the potato once it's wrapped.

Mash the potatoes while they're hot. If they cool first, lumps remain and their corners tear the dough as you roll. Make them as smooth as potato cream, though, and the plain, rustic character of knish disappears. A few small bits left in is just right.

Rolling pin, skillet and dill

A rolling pin is what makes thin, even dough possible. If you go on to make more Eastern European dough dishes, it earns its keep quickly with placinta and burek.

For the onion, use a heavy skillet. In a thin pan one spot browns while the rest stays raw, and a heavy pan gives the even heat you need to cook onion until sweet, never scorched. It's also handy for re-crisping leftover knish the next day.

Dill is optional, but if potato and onion alone feel heavy in your household, a little green aroma makes it easier to keep eating. Leftover dill can go into the egg-and-butter side for karjalanpiirakka or an Eastern-European-style cucumber salad.


Method: roll thin and seal the potato inside

The order of steps matters for knish. While the dough rests, make the potato and onion, and wrap only after the filling has cooled a little. Hot filling softens the dough and makes the seams open.


Common knish problems and fixes

Most failures fall into a few groups: the dough tears, the seam opens, the flavor is dull, or the color stays pale.

What happened Cause Fix
Dough tears Not rested enough, filling hot, big potato lumps Rest the dough 30 minutes, cool the filling, mash large potato pieces
Seam opens Overfilled, too much flour at the edge Brush off edge flour, use a little less filling and pinch
Flavor is weak Not enough salt in the potato Taste while warm and salt until it seems a little strong
Pale surface Egg wash too thin, oven too cool Brush on a thin egg wash again and bake 2–3 more minutes at 375°F (190 °C)
Only the bottom scorches Thin baking sheet, egg pooled at the bottom Stack two sheets and brush away pooled egg

Serving and storing knish

Baked knishes served with sour cream, whole-grain mustard, pickles and dill
Knish is a staple you can hold in your hand. A sour side cuts the heaviness of the potato

At the table

Knish is good straight from the oven. Small dishes of whole-grain mustard, pickles, sauerkraut and sour cream cut the heaviness of the potato, and a quick cucumber pickle or vinegared cabbage works just as well.

As a main, serve 2–3 knishes with a soup; a sour borscht or a clear mushroom soup pairs well. If you're curious how other wrapped Eastern European dishes compare, try pierogi, boiled then finished in butter; achma, made of layered thin dough; and burek, which rolls meat in long tubes. It's striking how different the textures are within the same flour-based family.

Serving Pair with Good for
Snack Whole-grain mustard, pickles, tea Fresh from the oven at lunch
Dinner Borscht, mushroom soup, vinegared cabbage A day when potato is the staple
Make-ahead Refrigerated knish, re-crisped in a pan Next-day breakfast or lunch box
Eastern European spread Machanka, pierogi, sauerkraut Several dishes side by side to compare

Storing and reheating

Refrigerated, knish keeps about 3 days. Let them cool, wrap each one in plastic, and put them in a container. To reheat, use a toaster oven at 350°F (180 °C) for 6–8 minutes, or a lightly oiled pan over medium-low heat, 2 minutes per side. The microwave alone leaves the dough limp, so warm it 30 seconds at 600 W, then finish in the toaster oven so it heats through to the center.

To freeze, wrap each knish once it has fully cooled after baking. Thaw in the refrigerator for half a day, then warm in a toaster oven at 350°F (180 °C) for 8–10 minutes. The dough comes out a little drier after freezing, so serve it with mustard or sour cream.

For better next-day knish, re-bake them

Refrigerated knish soak up moisture and soften a little. Dry the surface in a toaster oven or pan, and the flavor comes back in a different way from when they were fresh. Re-baking brings back the sweetness of the potato.


FAQ

Can I just bake it instead of frying?

Yes. Baked knish is easier at home because there's no oil to manage, and the surface turns light while the filling stays moist. Frying makes a different dish, so bake first to learn the right dough thickness.

Can I make it with fillings other than potato?

Yes. There are buckwheat kasha, sautéed cabbage, mushroom, meat and cheese versions, though potato and onion are the easiest to handle at first. With watery fillings like mushrooms or cabbage, always cook off the moisture before wrapping.

Can I use store-bought puff pastry for the dough?

You can, but it becomes a different dish. Puff pastry has layers and a strong butter smell, so the result is closer to a savory pie than a knish. It's a handy shortcut when time is short, but make this oil dough at least once to taste the plain character of the Eastern European Jewish snack.

Can I pack it in a lunch box?

Yes. Let it cool completely, and pack whole-grain mustard or pickles separately instead of sour cream. Potato dishes spoil easily in summer, so use an ice pack and avoid long carrying times.


Knish is a dish that becomes a little too narrow if you attach it to a single country. Season the potato boldly, cook the onion sweet, and seal it all in thin dough. Get that far, and even in a home kitchen you start to see the outline of Eastern European Jewish cooking's "staple you can hold in your hand."

Sources