Asam Pedas: Singapore and Malay Sour-Spicy Fish Stew

Asam pedas: fish, okra, tomato and eggplant in a red tamarind broth served with rice
Prep
30 min
Cook
35 min
Total
1 hr 5 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Singaporean and Malay

Asam pedas is a sour, spicy Malay-style fish stew also eaten in Singapore. The recipe covers tamarind, lemongrass, aromatic paste, substitutes and storage.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Prepare the fish and aromatics

12 min

Turning dried chiles, onion, lemongrass and turmeric into a red aromatic paste in a food processor
The aromatic paste need not be a completely smooth purée; a little graininess is fine

No heat. Cut 1.25 lb (600 g) white fish into easy-to-eat pieces 4 to 5 cm square, sprinkle with 1/2 tsp salt and leave 10 minutes. Wipe off the water that comes out with paper. Remove about half the seeds from 8 dried red chiles and soak them in ¾ cup (200 ml) boiling water for 10 minutes. Cut the onion into 1 inches (2 cm) squares, the ginger into thin slices, the eggplant into 1 inches (3 cm) chunks, the okra with stems trimmed in half on the diagonal and the tomatoes into 8 wedges. Put the chiles, onion, garlic, ginger, turmeric, shrimp paste or miso and 2 tbsp of the chile soaking liquid in a food processor and make a red paste that keeps some graininess.

STEP22 / 6

Fry the aromatic paste

8 min

Frying the red aromatic paste in a pot until red oil seeps along the wall
Frying the aromatic paste until the oil seeps out keeps a raw onion smell from lingering in the soup

Put 3 tbsp oil in a heavy pot and warm over medium-low heat for 1 minute. Add the aromatic paste and 2 stalks of lemongrass, bruised and cut into 2 inches (5 cm) pieces, and fry for 6 to 7 minutes, scraping the bottom of the pot with a wooden spoon. The temperature guide is 160 °C to 350°F (170 °C), with fine bubbles continuing rather than the sound of hard scorching. Move on when the raw smell of onion is gone, red oil seeps along the wall of the pot and the paste has turned a slightly deeper reddish brown.

STEP33 / 6

Make the sour tamarind stock

8 min

Pouring tamarind water over the fried aromatic paste to make a red sour stock
After adding the tamarind water, don't keep it at a hard boil; let the sourness settle over low heat

Dissolve 1 oz (30 g) tamarind paste in ½ cup (120 ml) lukewarm water and add it to the pot. Also add 2¾ cups (650 ml) water, 2 tsp sugar, 1 tsp salt and 1 tsp fish sauce, and warm over medium heat for about 4 minutes. When small bubbles appear, lower to low heat and simmer 3 minutes to let the sourness settle. Taste the soup here: if the sourness is too sharp, add 1/2 tsp sugar and 2 tbsp water. If the flavor is weak, add salt 1/4 tsp at a time.

STEP44 / 6

Simmer the fish gently

7 min

Gently simmering white fish in red tamarind soup over low heat
After the fish goes in, simmering quietly over low heat keeps the flesh from falling apart

With the soup barely bubbling, add the fish without overlapping. The heat stays low. Swirl the pot to move the soup and don't press the fish with a wooden spoon. After 5 minutes, turn just one large piece and check that the center is whitish and opaque and the flesh flakes lightly with chopsticks. If you have a thermometer, 145°F (63 °C) or above at the center is the guide. If it still looks translucent, add 1 to 2 minutes over low heat.

STEP55 / 6

Add the vegetables and simmer briefly

6 min

Adding okra, tomato and eggplant to the red fish soup and simmering over medium-low heat
Simmering the vegetables briefly at the end leaves texture within the sourness

Add the eggplant in 1 inches (3 cm) chunks, the okra halves and the tomato wedges and raise to medium-low heat. Keep small bubbles rising continuously on the surface of the soup and simmer 5 to 6 minutes. Turn off the heat when the okra has gone from bright green to a calmer color, the cut surface of the eggplant is soft and the corners of the tomato begin to break down. A hard boil breaks the fish, so even when sinking the vegetables, only swirl the pot lightly.

STEP66 / 6

Adjust the seasoning and serve with rice

5 min

Ladling asam pedas from the pot with the heat off and checking the red oil and how the fish is cooked
Resting with the heat off lets the sourness and salt settle and makes it easier to pair with rice

Rest 3 minutes with the heat off. Residual heat seasons the fish, and the red oil settles on the surface. Take out the lemongrass so it is easy to eat, and check sourness, saltiness and sweetness. If the sourness is lacking, add 2 tsp tamarind water; if saltiness is lacking, 1/4 tsp salt; if the heat is too strong, 1/2 tsp sugar. Serve in bowls, scatter 10 g cilantro or shiso and add hot rice.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Main ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
White fish fillets 600 g Spanish mackerel, swordfish, sea bass, sea bream, thick-cut cod
Salt for seasoning the fish 1/2 tsp Leave 10 minutes and wipe off the moisture
Okra 10 Trim the stem ends and cut in half on the diagonal
Eggplant 2 small, about 180 g Cut into 3 cm chunks. 1 if using a globe eggplant
Tomatoes 2, about 300 g Cut into 8 wedges
Lemongrass 2 stalks Bruise the base and cut into 5 cm pieces. Frozen also works
Water 650 ml Even richer if you use fish-bone stock
Oil 3 tbsp Rice bran oil or vegetable oil
Sugar 2 tsp Rounds out the sourness. Brown sugar also works
Salt 1 tsp Adjust finally by 1/4 tsp at a time
Fish sauce 1 tsp A supplement when not using shrimp paste
Cilantro or shiso 10 g For finishing. Omit if you dislike it
Hot cooked rice from 2 rice-cooker cups Eaten with the soup spooned over
2 / 3

Aromatic paste

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Dried red chiles 8, about 14 g Removing half the seeds makes it milder
Boiling water ¾ cup (200 ml) Soak the chiles for 10 minutes
Onion 4 oz (120 g) Red onion or shallot also work
Garlic 3 cloves Remove the germ if it is strong
Ginger 20 g Replace 10 g with galangal if you have it
Ground turmeric 1 tsp 10 g if using fresh turmeric
Shrimp paste or miso 1/2 tsp Use miso if there is a shrimp allergy
Chile soaking liquid 2 tbsp Add only if the blender won't turn
3 / 3

Tamarind water

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Tamarind paste 1 oz (30 g) 20 g to start for strongly concentrated products
Lukewarm water ½ cup (120 ml) Dissolve well and strain if there are seeds or fibers
0 / 0

In the kitchen, dried chiles soak in hot water, onion and lemongrass wait on the board, and tamarind is being loosened in a bowl of water. Already the air smells nothing like an ordinary simmered fish: instead of sweet-salty soy sauce, there's red oil, a citrus-like sourness and the stock coming off the fish. Once small bubbles start forming at the edge of the pot, you'll find your hand moving a little faster as it spoons out the white rice.

Asam pedas means "sour, spicy" in Malay, and the name tells you exactly what you get: fish simmered with the sourness of tamarind and the heat of chile. It's eaten across the Malay Peninsula, Sumatra and Borneo, and at the Malay and Peranakan tables of Singapore. Think of it as a sour-spicy fish stew that grew up between port towns and straits. Get three things right and you can come close to the original at home: the sourness, a red aromatic paste, and cooking that keeps the fish whole.

About the spelling

The common Malay spelling is asam pedas. In English it is also written assam pedas.


Asam pedas in Singapore and the Malay world

The heart of asam pedas is the balance between sour and hot. Unlike a curry rounded with coconut milk, it starts with a red aromatic paste fried until a thin film of oil floats on top, then loosened with tamarind liquid, and the fish is simmered only briefly. The soup stays light. Over rice, the sourness keeps each mouthful fresh, while the fat of the fish and the aroma of chile linger.

Names and aromatics shift from region to region, so you'll also meet versions called asam padeh and gerang asam. In Singapore, chile pastes such as sambal and lempah run through Malay, Peranakan and Eurasian cooking, and asam pedas grows out of that tradition. Fish, vegetables and souring agents change from shop to shop and household to household. Minangkabau-style eateries in Singapore have even added sweetness to suit local tastes.

Locally, the sourness comes from tamarind, asam keping or lime, and the heat from dried chiles, fresh chiles or sambal. The fish might be stingray, mackerel types, sea bream, river fish or fish heads, and the pot is scented with lemongrass, turmeric, ginger and fermented shrimp seasoning. Okra, eggplant, tomato and laksa leaf are common additions, and in Peranakan recipes laksa leaf and torch ginger can carry the whole aroma.

If you like eating fish with aromatics, otak-otak, wrapped in leaves and grilled, makes a good next read. Set asam pedas beside the Philippines' sinigang and Thailand's tom yum goong and you'll see how differently each one uses tamarind and sourness. For more casual Singaporean food, there's roti john, and for the aroma of chicken stock and rice, Hainanese chicken rice.


Ingredients — decide the fish, tamarind and aromatic paste first

A kitchen with white fish, tamarind, dried chiles, lemongrass, okra, tomato and eggplant laid out for asam pedas
For asam pedas, gathering the fish, tamarind, dried chiles and lemongrass first settles the flavor

Serves 4. Use thick fillets of fish. A fish that breaks easily like cod also works, but the first time, ones whose flesh doesn't flake easily when heated, such as Spanish mackerel, swordfish, sea bass or sea bream, are easier to handle. If using frozen fish, thaw it in the refrigerator, wipe the surface dry and then salt it.

Allergy information

This uses fish, shrimp-derived seasoning and fish sauce. If adding shrimp paste, be careful about shellfish allergy. At a table with people who dislike heat, reduce the dried chiles to 6 and remove more of the seeds.


Ingredients that cause hesitation when shopping — fix the sourness and aroma

You don't need to order the fish or okra online. Focus on sourness, aromatics and color, which can be hard to find at a nearby supermarket. If these are vague, the dish turns into just a red fish soup, so settle them first when you shop.

Tamarind is the star of this dish. Lemon or vinegar also bring sourness, but it is different from the round fruity sourness of tamarind. The first time, using paste saves the work of loosening seeds and straining, and makes sourness easier to adjust.

Shrimp paste is an ingredient that adds fermented umami to the red soup in small amounts. You can make it without, but to move toward a Malay-style sour-spicy fish stew, mixing 1/2 tsp into the aromatic paste gives more outline than miso alone. At a table with a shellfish allergy, don't force it; make up for it lightly with miso and fish sauce.

Turmeric is not only for color but the aromatic base that rounds out the smell of fish. If you can't get fresh turmeric, a small amount of powder is enough. Too much turns powdery and bitter, so 1 tsp is the upper limit.


Choosing fish, tamarind and herbs for asam pedas

Every swap pushes the flavor in a new direction, so choose carefully. The first time, hold on to the tamarind, lemongrass and turmeric, and let the fish and herbs lean toward whatever you can buy easily.

Ingredient in question Closer to the original A practical answer at home Judgment
Fish Stingray, red fish, fish heads Spanish mackerel, swordfish, sea bass, sea bream Choose thick cuts that hold together
Sourness Tamarind pulp, asam keping Tamarind paste Lemon juice alone won't do
Herbs Laksa leaf, torch ginger Shiso, cilantro, a little mint Add lightly at the finish
Fermented umami Belacan, shrimp paste 1/2 tsp shrimp paste, or miso and fish sauce Leave it out if there's an allergy
Heat Dried and fresh chiles Rehydrated dried chiles, adjusted by number Chile powder alone flattens the aroma

The fish is the biggest question. Stingray gives you the local feel, but it's hard to find reliably. Spanish mackerel balances fat and soft flesh well and suits a sour soup, while swordfish holds its shape and has little fishy smell, which makes it a good first choice. Cod is easy to get but fragile, so pick thick fillets, keep the cooking short and leave it alone in the pot. Salmon works too, though its strong fat and aroma take it away from the taste of a local white fish.

Stick with tamarind for the sourness. Vinegar is sharp and pulls the fish's aroma somewhere else entirely. Laksa leaf and torch ginger are hard to gather outside the region, so this recipe builds its aroma on lemongrass, ginger and turmeric, with a little shiso or cilantro added at the end.


Method — fry the paste and cook the fish briefly

What goes wrong in this dish is underfrying the aromatic paste and overcooking the fish. Fry the paste without scorching until the oil seeps out, and add the fish last, cooking it quietly over low heat. Stir around after the fish goes in and the flesh breaks up and the soup clouds.

If you divide the heat within the family

Reduce the dried chiles to 6 and remove nearly all the seeds. For adults, add a sambal substitute at the table 1 tsp at a time, which lets you adjust without making the whole pot too hot.


Common asam pedas failures and fixes

A kitchen comparing a red soup too sour with broken fish and asam pedas where the fish kept its shape
Asam pedas failures tend to come from too much sourness, hard boiling and underfried aromatic paste
State Cause How to fix
Too sour The tamarind paste is strongly concentrated Round it with 2 tbsp water, 1/2 tsp sugar and a little salt
The fish falls apart Boiled hard, or stirred too much with a wooden spoon Low heat once the fish is in. Swirl the pot to move the soup
The aroma is weak The aromatic paste was underfried Fry 6 to 7 minutes over medium-low heat until the oil seeps out
Powdery Too much turmeric Up to 1 tsp. If lacking, make up with aromatics, not color
Fishy The fish moisture wasn't wiped, or it wasn't cooked enough Salt and leave 10 minutes, wipe the moisture and simmer until the center is white

Add the tamarind gradually. With a strongly concentrated product, putting it all in at the start makes the soup too sharp, so begin with 20 g and add more after tasting in step 3. Sourness mellows a little as it simmers, and if it tastes just slightly strong, it will be right with rice.

You'll see the fish breaking down before you taste it. When the edges of the flesh begin to split and the soup clouds with fine flakes, the heat is too high. Turn it down to low, and slide the vegetables into an open spot in the pot instead of dropping them on the fish.

A weak aroma has to be fixed while frying the paste; chile powder added afterward won't give depth. Cook off the moisture from the onion and let the color of the chile and turmeric move into the oil. This is the step not to rush.


Serving and storing asam pedas

How to serve it

Asam pedas served on a large platter at a home table with rice, cucumber and herbs
Asam pedas is eaten by spooning the sour soup over rice, returning the mouth with herbs and cucumber

Serving is simple: spoon rice into a deep bowl and pour the fish and red soup over it. Between the stickiness of okra, the softness of eggplant and the sourness of tomato, the pot already has plenty going on, so a light side is enough. Skip heavy fried food and go for sliced cucumber, boiled egg, greens stir-fried with garlic and unsweetened tea.

To build a wider Southeast Asian table, compare it with the sambal of Malaysia's nasi lemak, the sourness of Indonesia's arsik and the herbal quality of Thailand's tom yum goong. Each one makes the character of asam pedas a little clearer.

Storing and reheating

A kitchen preparing to store leftover asam pedas in glass containers, kept apart from the rice
To store, move the fish with its soup into a container without breaking it, and keep it separate from the rice

Move leftovers into a wide container so the fish doesn't break. Let it cool slightly, refrigerate it and eat it by the next day at the latest; tamarind or not, this is still a fish dish. Store the fish and rice separately, too, because rice soaks up the sour soup and turns heavy overnight.

To reheat, warm it in a pot over low heat for 5 to 6 minutes until the soup bubbles. In a microwave, give it 1 minute 30 seconds at 600 W, adding 30 seconds at a time if the center of the fish is still cold.

Leftover soup over noodles

Leftover soup makes a good lunch the next day over somen or rice noodles. Take out the fish, bring just the soup to a light boil and pour it over the noodles. A little cilantro, shiso and cucumber keeps the sourness from taking over.


FAQ

Can I make it without tamarind?

You can, but the dish changes a good deal. In a pinch, mix 2 tsp pickled plum (ume) paste, 2 tsp lemon juice and 3 tbsp water for the sourness, though you'll lose the round fruitiness of tamarind. If you want it to taste like asam pedas, use tamarind paste.

Will the taste be weak without shrimp paste?

It will be a little lighter, but it still works. If you have a shrimp allergy, leave it out and use 1/2 tsp miso and 1 tsp fish sauce instead. To avoid fish sauce as well, add another 1/4 tsp salt and fry the aromatic paste thoroughly to bring out depth.

How do I make it less hot?

Cut the dried chiles down to 6, remove more of the seeds and leave out the fresh chiles. Anyone who likes more heat can add sambal or chile flakes at the table. Making the whole pot hot and then diluting it tends to throw off the balance of sourness and salt.

May I add coconut milk?

Adding it turns the dish into a different kind of fish curry, since asam pedas is defined by sourness and heat without coconut. To soften the heat, add a little sugar instead, and let rice and cucumber cool the palate.

What goes with it to make a complete table?

Rice, cucumber and stir-fried greens are all you need. For a Southeast Asian menu, try it alongside the ginger sauce of Hainanese chicken rice, the rich soup of laksa and the sourness of sinigang.


Sources