Otak-Otak: Singapore's Grilled Fish Paste in Banana Leaf

Otak-otak with the banana leaf opened: grilled red fish paste served with white rice, cucumber, lime and sambal on a Singapore table
Prep
35 min
Cook
25 min
Total
1 hr
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Singaporean / Malay

Otak-otak (otah) is white fish, coconut milk and an aromatic paste wrapped in banana leaf, loved in Singapore and Malaysia. Wrapping, cooking time, serving.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Make the aromatic paste coarse

10 min

Making a coarse aromatic paste of red chile, shallots, garlic, galangal and lemongrass in a food processor
Stop the paste while it's still a little rough, and the aroma rises after cooking

No heat is used. Remove about half the seeds from 6 dried red chiles and soften them in hot water for 10 minutes. Finely chop 2.75 oz (80 g) shallots, 3 cloves garlic, 15 g galangal, the tender bases of 2 lemongrass stalks and 4 makrut lime leaves. Put the chiles, aromatics, 1/2 tsp turmeric and 1/2 tsp shrimp paste or miso in the food processor, add 1–2 tbsp of the chile soaking liquid, and run it. Stop at a red paste with small grains still in it, not a full puree.

STEP22 / 6

Mix the fish paste and chill

8 min

Mixing white fish, red aromatic paste, coconut milk and egg in a bowl into a sticky otak-otak mixture
Don't make all the fish smooth; leaving some coarseness gives it texture

No heat is used. Remove the skin and bones from 1.25 lb (600 g) white fish, cut into 1 inches (2 cm) cubes and wipe off the moisture with paper. Chop half the fish coarsely in the food processor and pound the other half with a knife to 0.25–0.375 inch (5–8 mm) pieces. In a bowl, put the fish, aromatic paste, 1 tsp salt, 1 egg, ½ cup (120 ml) coconut milk, 1 tbsp potato starch, 2 tsp fish sauce and 2 tsp sugar, and mix with a wooden spatula for 2 minutes. When the mixture drops slowly from a spoon, rest it in the refrigerator for 10 minutes. If it is too loose, add 1 tsp potato starch.

STEP33 / 6

Soften the banana leaf

6 min

Warming banana leaves in steam and wiping them to make them easier to wrap
Warming banana leaves makes them less likely to crack, and the aroma comes out when you wrap

Get steam going over low heat in a steamer or pot. Wash the thawed banana leaves under running water, wipe off the water with a cloth and cut to 12 inches (30 cm) squares. Shave the thick parts of the veins thin with a knife. Warm each side over the steam for 20–30 seconds, or heat a skillet over low heat to around 250°F (120°C) and press the leaf against it for 15 seconds on each side. It is ready when the leaf bends without cracking and the surface has a sheen. Stop before it scorches and develops holes.

STEP44 / 6

Place on the leaf and wrap into long packets

8 min

Placing the otak-otak mixture in a long shape on a banana leaf, folding it and fastening with toothpicks
Don't wrap otak-otak thick: long and slim lets the heat reach it even in a home skillet

No heat is used. With the glossy side of the leaf up, brush a thin layer of oil in the center. Place about 3.25 oz (90 g) of the mixture on each and spread it into a long shape 7 inches (18 cm) long, 2 inches (5 cm) wide and 1.5–2 cm thick. Fold the left and right sides of the leaf over the mixture, fold the top and bottom, and fasten both ends with toothpicks. Where the leaf has torn, lay a small leaf inside. If it goes over 1 inches (3 cm) thick, the center will be slow to set, so keep it thinner.

STEP55 / 6

Cook the packets in a skillet, leaf and all

12 min

Grilling banana-leaf-wrapped otak-otak in a grill pan with a light scorch on the leaf
The leaf only needs a light scorch; don't grill it black over high heat

Heat a skillet or grill pan over medium heat for 2 minutes. Aim for a surface temperature of 170–180°C. Use no oil, and set the packets seam side down. For the first 3 minutes, cook over medium heat. When the leaf has a light scorch, lower to medium-low. Cook 5–6 minutes per side, turning only once. The packets are done when thin steam comes from the leaf and the mixture feels springy, not mushy, when you press an end. If the leaf starts to smell burnt, lower to low heat, cover and add 2 minutes.

STEP66 / 6

Open one and check that it's cooked through

5 min

Opening the leaf of a cooked otak-otak and checking with a spoon how the center has set
It's done when the center is moist and set with no translucent raw fish

Turn off the heat, take the packets out onto a plate and rest for 3 minutes. Open just one and check that the center is set to a red-orange color with no translucent raw fish remaining. If you have a thermometer, aim for 145°F (63°C) or higher at the center. If the center is loose, close the opened one back up and add 2 minutes on each side over low heat. Serve with warm rice, cucumber, lime and a little sambal.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Fish paste

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
White fish fillets 1.25 lb (600 g) Sea bream, sea bass, cod, swordfish. Remove skin and bones
Salt 1 tsp 1/2 tsp for the fish, 1/2 tsp for final adjusting
Egg 1 Binder. If the egg is small, add 1 tbsp water
Coconut milk ½ cup (120 ml) Shake the can well before using. Stir if separated
Potato starch 1 tbsp Stops it from being loose. Don't add too much
Fish sauce 2 tsp Gives the fish sauce aroma. If you dislike it, use 2 tsp light soy sauce
Sugar 2 tsp Rounds out the heat and the saltiness of the fish
Oil 2 tsp For brushing lightly on the leaves. Rice bran oil or neutral oil
2 / 3

Aromatic paste

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Dried red chiles 6, about 10 g Soak in hot water for 10 minutes. Remove the seeds on days you want less heat
Red chile or fresh chile 1 Color and fresh heat. Optional
Shallots 2.75 oz (80 g) Substitute 2.5 oz (70 g) red onion or onion
Garlic 3 cloves, about 15 g Remove the core if it is strong
Galangal 15 g 10 g ginger also works, but the aroma changes
Lemongrass 2 stalks Only the tender base, thinly sliced. Frozen is fine
Makrut lime leaves 4 Remove the hard central rib and cut into thin strips
Turmeric powder 1/2 tsp Adds color and earthiness
Shrimp paste or miso 1/2 tsp Use miso if there is a shrimp allergy
Chile soaking liquid 1–2 tbsp Add only if the blender won't turn
3 / 3

Wrapping and accompaniments

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Banana leaf 12 inches (30 cm) squares, 8 Thaw and wipe if frozen. Double up if torn
Toothpicks 16 Short pieces of bamboo skewer also work
Warm cooked rice 2 go About 1½ cups (360 ml) uncooked. Jasmine or short-grain both work
Cucumber 1 Cut on the diagonal 0.25 inch (5 mm) thick
Lime 1 Cut into wedges. Lemon also works
Sambal 4 tsp Lets everyone set the heat at the table. The dish works without it
0 / 0

The steam that rises when you open the leaf is nothing like grilled fish or chawanmushi. It smells like a Southeast Asian street stall. In the skillet you first hear moisture steaming inside the wrapper, and a little later the sweet smell of scorching banana leaf. Otak-otak (also written otah) is fish paste mixed with chiles, shallots, galangal, lemongrass, makrut lime leaves and coconut milk, wrapped in banana leaf and grilled. It's eaten across Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia. Expect springy fish, the roundness of coconut milk and the heat of red aromatics, all carrying the green scent of the leaf.

A note on spelling

Otak means "brain" in Malay and Indonesian, a name that comes from the soft look of the fish paste. It is written otak-otak in English-speaking places and sometimes otah in Singapore.


About otak-otak

Otak-otak is grilled, but it doesn't have the texture of grilled fish. The fish is minced, mixed with aromatics and wrapped in a leaf, so the surface never dries out in the heat. The leaf gives off its aroma over the skillet or charcoal, while inside, egg and coconut milk steam and set. The result falls somewhere between fish balls, a terrine and chawanmushi, and it's moist when you cut into it with chopsticks.

In Singapore and on the Malay Peninsula, otah is a stall snack, a side next to plain rice or a topping for noodle dishes. At Singapore stalls it often comes as a small side to laksa or nasi lemak. Several small wraps are grilled at once and sometimes handed over on a paper plate just as they are. It's less a showy main dish than a way to bring the umami of fish and hot aromatics to the table in small amounts. So at home, too, keep the fish thin rather than shaping it into a thick patty like a big hamburger.

The form changes a lot by region. It can be steamed or grilled, made with more egg, or with the fish left coarse. Around Muar in Malaysia, long, red, leaf-wrapped otak-otak is famous, and Peranakan households sometimes combine coconut milk, egg and aromatics to make it smoother. In Indonesia, places such as Palembang and the Riau Islands have their own styles: steamed and then grilled, or a whitish fish paste served with peanut sauce.

Compare it with assam pedas (in Japanese), Singapore's sour-hot stew, to see the difference between fish stewed in tamarind and fish grilled in a leaf.


Ingredients: wipe the fish dry and decide the aromatics first

The ingredients for otak-otak: white fish, coconut milk, egg, red chile, shallots, garlic, galangal, lemongrass, makrut lime leaves and banana leaf laid out in a kitchen
For otak-otak, work goes quickly if you set out the fish, red aromatics, coconut milk and banana leaf separately beforehand

Serves 4, making 8 long packets. With rice, allow 2 per person, or make slightly smaller packets, 10 in all, for a light snack. Prepare eight 12 inches (30 cm) square banana leaves and keep several small leaves aside for patching tears.

Allergies and food safety

This recipe uses fish, egg, fish sauce and a shrimp-based seasoning. If you add shrimp paste, be careful of crustacean allergies. Don't leave the fish paste at room temperature for long before cooking. On warm days, rest the mixture in the refrigerator before wrapping. Cook until the center reaches 145°F (63°C) or higher.


Choosing ingredients for otak-otak

The ingredients that are easy to hesitate over when shopping for otak-otak: coconut milk, galangal, makrut lime leaves, banana leaf, chile condiments and a food processor, laid out in a kitchen
What is worth seeking out at an import grocer or online is not the fish but the ingredients at the core of the aroma

Fish, eggs, cucumber and rice are easy to find at a neighborhood supermarket. The harder items are coconut milk, galangal, makrut lime leaves, banana leaf and the tools for making the aromatic paste. Otak-otak gets much easier once you separate what you can substitute from what you'd like to keep. Hold on to the leaf wrapping, the red aromatics, the coconut milk and careful control of the fish's moisture. The fish itself can suit your fish counter.

Ingredient you're unsure about Closer to the real thing Realistic option Judgment
Fish Mackerel types, Spanish mackerel types, white fish Sea bream, sea bass, cod, swordfish Wipe off moisture and leave some coarseness
Leaf Banana leaf Frozen banana leaf. For practice, parchment paper Use the leaf if you want the aroma
Galangal Fresh or frozen Partly substitute ginger Add a little galangal if you can
Makrut lime leaves Fresh or frozen More lemongrass and a little lime zest Hard to substitute fully
Shrimp paste Belacan, terasi and so on Only 1/2 tsp. Miso if there's an allergy Too much makes it salty
Heat Dried and fresh chiles Use rehydrated dried chiles More aroma than chile powder alone

Fish

Cod gives a soft, light result, but it holds a lot of water. Sprinkle it with salt, leave it for 5 minutes and wipe off the liquid thoroughly so the paste holds together. Swordfish is easy to handle and gives springiness, though low-fat fish can turn a bit firm. Sea bream and sea bass have a refined aroma that goes well with coconut milk.

Breadcrumbs or wheat flour make the mixture easier to handle, but they turn it into ordinary fish patties and lose the tender texture of fish setting inside the leaf. Let egg, the protein in the fish, a little potato starch and coconut milk do the binding, and don't overcook it.

Aromatics and coconut milk

Galangal and makrut lime leaves are what give the dish the aroma of Southeast Asian leaf-wrapped cooking. Galangal has a hard, citrus-like aroma unlike ginger; you can make otak-otak with ginger alone, but even a small amount of galangal makes a difference. Makrut lime leaves, cut into thin strips and mixed into the paste, keep their aroma after grilling, and their green note cuts the fat of the fish when lemongrass alone would make it too round. Onion can stand in for the shallots.

Coconut milk is what connects the hot aromatics and the fish. Milk or fresh cream takes the aroma in another direction. Leftover coconut milk can go into nasi uduk (in Japanese) or soto betawi (in Japanese).

You can make the aromatic paste with a knife, but chopping lemongrass and galangal fine takes time. A small food processor makes it easy to stop at a coarse paste, and any extra can go into ayam betutu or a sambal substitute. Whatever tool you already own is enough.

Banana leaf

If you can't find banana leaf, wrap the packets in parchment paper, then in aluminum foil, and grill. The green aroma of the leaf will be missing, so treat the first time as wrapping practice and look for frozen banana leaf next time to taste the difference. For more dishes that use the leaf as a vessel for aroma, try Venezuela's hallaca (in Japanese) and the Central African Republic's maboke (in Japanese).


Method: wrap in leaf and let the aroma come in from outside

If the fish mixture is too thick, the outside dries before the center sets. Shape it long and slim, 1.5–2 cm thick, and steam-grill it in the leaf. Too high a heat in the skillet scorches only the leaf, and too low makes it watery. Start at medium and lower to medium-low once the leaf has color.

When you want to separate the heat levels

Cutting too much chile from the mixture also thins the aroma. On days when a family splits on heat, use 4 dried chiles in the mixture and add a little sambal substitute at the table, which is easier to adjust.


Otak-otak troubleshooting

Comparing watery, spread-out otak-otak mixture and moist, set otak-otak in a kitchen
Failures with otak-otak tend to come from the fish's moisture, the thickness of the wrap and the strength of the heat
State Cause How to fix it
Watery and runs The fish has too much moisture, too much coconut milk Wipe the fish. Add 1 tsp potato starch and chill for 10 minutes
Crumbly and tough Overcooked, the fish was minced too fine Make it thinner and check from 5 minutes per side. Leave half the fish coarse
Only the leaf scorches black The heat is too strong, the skillet was heated too much Start at medium and lower to medium-low once it has color
Fishy Fish moisture, too little aromatics, undercooked Salt and wipe off the moisture. Add galangal, lemongrass and makrut lime leaves
Leaks from the packet The leaf is stiff or torn, the mixture is loose Warm the leaf to soften it. Double up where it's torn

Wateriness is mostly decided by how you prepare the fish. Thaw frozen fish slowly in the refrigerator, and discard the liquid that collects on the plate as well as the surface moisture. Washing the fish adds water and loosens the paste, so if the smell bothers you, salt it and wipe it dry with paper instead.

Toughness comes from the cooking and from how fine the paste is. If you aim for a smooth fish terrine and run all the fish for a long time, it grills up too uniform and dense. In a home food processor, the safest approach is to pound half the fish coarsely and make the other half into paste.


Serving and storing otak-otak

Grilled otak-otak, white rice, cucumber, lime and sambal laid out on a small table in a Singaporean style
Add rice, cucumber, lime and heat to otak-otak and you can eat the rich fish flavor lightly

White rice is the basic accompaniment, and cucumber and lime lighten the richness of the fish and coconut. For a street-stall plate, put rice, cucumber and something hot together like nasi lemak (in Japanese), or serve it with laksa (in Japanese), the coconut noodle soup. For a lighter table, pair it with Hainanese chicken rice (in Japanese) or roti john (in Japanese).

If you add a soup, choose a light chicken soup or some stir-fried greens. They won't fight the aroma of the otak-otak the way a sour sinigang would.

The leaf smells best on the day you grill it. Let leftovers cool without opening the leaf, put them in an airtight container and finish them within about 2 days in the refrigerator. To reheat, warm the packets in a skillet over low heat for 3 minutes per side. In a microwave, open the leaf, set it on a heatproof plate, cover loosely with plastic wrap and heat at 600 W for 40–50 seconds, though the microwave tends to drive off the aroma.

Grilled packets freeze better than the uncooked mixture, which releases water and loosens when thawed. Cool the grilled packets, wrap them one by one in plastic wrap and keep them in the freezer for about 2 weeks. Thaw in the refrigerator for half a day, then warm slowly in a skillet over low heat.


Frequently asked questions

Q1. Which fish suits it best?

For a first attempt, swordfish, sea bream and sea bass are easy to handle. Cod works too if you salt it and wipe off the moisture first, since it breaks easily. Mackerel has a strong aroma and brings out the local feel, but in a home kitchen the fishy smell can win out; if you use it, choose very fresh fish and make the aromatics a little stronger.

Q2. I don't like coconut milk.

Reduce the amount from ½ cup (120 ml) to ¼ cup (80 ml) and add 2 tbsp water. Leaving it out completely tightens the fish paste and makes the heat feel angular. Milk or fresh cream moves it away from the Southeast Asian aroma, so reducing the amount is the more natural fix.

Q3. Can I cook it in an oven or toaster oven?

Yes. Arrange the packets on a baking sheet and bake in a 400°F (200°C) oven for 12–15 minutes, turning once partway, and confirm 145°F (63°C) or higher at the center. In a toaster oven the heat is close and the leaf scorches easily, so cover lightly with aluminum foil at first and remove it for only the last 2 minutes.

Q4. Can I make a non-spicy version for kids?

You can, but with zero chile the aroma weakens too. Use 2 dried chiles with the seeds removed, and put the sambal on a separate plate for the adults. A little more makrut lime leaf, lemongrass and lime keeps it from tasting vague.


Sources and references